Key result
Synthetic scaffolds for tissue engineered heart valves resulted in a higher transvalvular pressure gradient compared to natural scaffolds.
Why the study?
Numerous tissue engineered heart valve strategies have been studied in large animal models over the last 25 years, prompting a systematic evaluation and summary of all available publications.
Do synthetic scaffolds compared to natural scaffolds improve hemodynamics and mortality in large animal models of pulmonary valve tissue engineering?
Meta-Analysis (n=693)
Do synthetic scaffolds compared to natural scaffolds improve hemodynamics and mortality in large animal models of pulmonary valve tissue engineering?
In large animal models of pulmonary valve tissue engineering, synthetic scaffolds are associated with higher transvalvular pressure gradients compared to natural scaffolds, though poor study reporting and heterogeneity limit definitive conclusions.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Poor reporting and heterogeneity in TEHV animal studies caution against clinical translation; leaves open the need for standardized preclinical protocols.
In the last 25 years, numerous tissue engineered heart valve (TEHV) strategies have been studied in large animal models. To evaluate, qualify and summarize all available publications, we conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis. We identified 80 reports that studied TEHVs of synthetic or natural scaffolds in pulmonary position (n = 693 animals). We identified substantial heterogeneity in study designs, methods and outcomes. Most importantly, the quality assessment showed poor reporting in randomization and blinding strategies. Meta-analysis showed no differences in mortality and rate of valve regurgitation between different scaffolds or strategies. However, it revealed a higher transvalvular pressure gradient in synthetic scaffolds (11.6 mmHg; 95% CI, [7.31-15.89]) compared to natural scaffolds (4,67 mmHg; 95% CI, [3,94-5.39]; p = 0.003). These results should be interpreted with caution due to lack of a standardized control group, substantial study heterogeneity, and relatively low number of comparable studies in subgroup analyses. Based on this review, the most adequate scaffold model is still undefined. This review endorses that, to move the TEHV field forward and enable reliable comparisons, it is essential to define standardized methods and ways of reporting. This would greatly enhance the value of individual large animal studies.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Uiterwijk et al. (2021) conducted a meta-analysis in Pulmonary valve replacement (n=693). Synthetic scaffolds vs. Natural scaffolds was evaluated on Transvalvular pressure gradient (p=0.003). Synthetic scaffolds for tissue engineered heart valves resulted in a higher transvalvular pressure gradient compared to natural scaffolds.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: