Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The day-to-day running of Emergency Medicine Australasia (EMA) has been transformed by adopting the web-based peer review and online manuscript submission process Manuscript Central. This system by ScholarOne (Charlottesville, VA, USA) is now available in version 4.0 which has been upgraded to include Manuscript Central Optima, an integration with Thomson Scientific's Web of Science and EndNote, as well as eForms and eCommerce to create an easier and more streamlined process. The Thomson Corporation acquired ScholarOne in August 2006 through Thomson Scientific, and a ‘European User Conference’ in November 2006, and a ‘USA User Conference’ in January 2007 paved the way for the final genesis of version 4.0 of Manuscript Central. Manuscript Central v4.0 enables users to submit, review, annotate and format technical manuscripts online in innovative ways, giving authors and publishers alike access to additional expertise in information and tools that span the entire research process. At the click of a button as the Editor-in-Chief (EIC), it was possible recently to rapidly check the total number of manuscripts submitted to EMA in the last year. The result yielded 154 papers, of which 51 have been rejected, 43 accepted and 60 are still ‘in progress’. The breakdown of the types of paper submitted revealed 82 original research papers, 16 review papers, 36 case reports, 9 Editorials, 8 Letters to the Editor and 3 Perspectives. Forty-eight papers were submitted from outside of Australasia (31%), and of those accepted for publication, their countries of origin included the UK, the USA, Switzerland, Hong Kong, India, Japan, United Arab Emirates, Pakistan and Nigeria among others. These statistics tell nothing of the publication process itself, but again it was easy to discover further core data through the EIC Centre. Papers submitted to EMA have somewhat disappointingly been taking an average time of 38 days (around 6–7 weeks) from first submission to reaching a first decision (to reject outright, or to proceed to minor revision or to a major revision). This key performance indicator clearly leaves room for improvement, with the aim now being to reduce this to closer to 20 days or 4 weeks maximum for this critical initial decision time. Once the EMA editorial process including peer review fully engages into action, the average number of days from submission of a revision to final decision is then 130 days. Much of this time is out of our hands, as it in part depends on the time the authors take to respond, and how many revisions are needed. After a paper is finally accepted by EMA, the average number of days to then be published in print is 139. Much more important though, is that for original research and review papers, it is now only 30 working days to the release of a citable electronic publication on OnlineEarly, each with a unique Medline searchable .doi number. This electronic version involves the paper being formatted into journal style, proof read by the author, permissions sought and the paper being signed off prior to release online. These latter publication times are well within similar biomedical journals' benchmarks, and are a credit to everyone involved. Aspiring authors who are wondering just who reads the contents of EMA should know that currently, there are some 2802 print copies of the journal published that go to all members of the Australasian College for Emergency Medicine and the Australasian Society for Emergency Medicine, to some private subscriptions and to libraries in Australasia, Europe and the USA. Even more impressive are the figures for journal usage in the last year on the Web through Blackwell Synergy, the online journal service from Blackwell Publishing (now part of Wiley). Over two and a half thousand Table of Contents for EMA are accessed on Blackwell Synergy each month, with between 7000 and 23 000 abstracts downloaded each month, and between 3000 and 8000 full text papers (either hypertext markup language [HTML] enabled, or as .pdf files) downloaded every month. The download trend has increased steadily throughout the last year, with a total now of 109 671 full text papers downloaded since January 2006. This is an exhilarating and challenging time for the readers and editors alike of EMA. Exhilarating because the international reach of EMA is undeniable; challenging because the journal must strive to improve and maintain excellence in the quality, relevance and readability of the papers it publishes. More challenging still is to look to the future as readers become increasingly familiar with what is on offer on Web 2.0. The concept of Web 2.0 was articulated in 2004, and within a year and a half, Google had no less than 9 500 000 citations to this new platform.1 Seven core principles or core competencies for Web 2.0 were espoused by one pioneer Tim O'Reilly. These included services, not-packaged software, with cost-effective scalability; control over unique, hard-to-recreate data sources that get richer as more people use them; trusting users as codevelopers; harnessing collective intelligence; leveraging the long tail through customer self-service; software above the level of a single device and finally lightweight user interfaces, development models and business models.1 These concepts of open, online social networking on Web 2.0 are embodied in the rapid rise of phenomena such as blogs, wikis, podcasts and vodcasts utilizing Really Simple Syndication feeds, easily accessed by website tagging and organizing tools, with authors bypassing the need to use the more complex Web 1.0 HTML.2 Medical educators and clinicians alike will undoubtedly be drawn to this new collaborative interactive medium where clinical thoughts, images and videos can be shared real-time.3 Will EMA still be with us? Absolutely, just as the popularity of small or large printed medical textbooks alike has been untouched by the appearance of online or CD-ROM productions. However, Web 2.0 will behove all of us at EMA to maintain the best quality possible by excellent peer review, timely paper turnaround and publication times, and most importantly, relevant content that our readers want. What is lost in interactivity will be compensated for by the avoidance of an initial flood of unreviewed, unexpurgated, largely unreferenced and potentially uncontrollable medical content online, as Web 2.0 explodes on the scene. A similar danger to the printed word journal was successfully brought under control in the best biomedical journals by a vigorous editing process, competitive referencing system, and by the readers' understanding of the fundamental importance of the evidence-base of the data cited on the scientific rigour of the conclusions drawn.4 Clearly the journal process at EMA does not happen by itself, with many individuals working on the journal of their own free will, in their own ‘spare’ time. This includes the Editorial Executive, the respective Section Editors and the many peer reviewers, to whom I owe a debt of gratitude and admiration for their dedication, enthusiasm and energy shown, in spite of the avalanche of commitments at work, as well as at home. Finally, Alison Hughes, the Editorial Assistant at Blackwell Publishing, has been outstanding, offering the highest levels of professional assistance, reliability and focus any Editor-in-Chief could hope for, ably assisted by Blackwell Publishing Production Editor Charlotte Bolcskey and overseen by our invariably supportive Journal Publishing Manager Alma Ross. Thank you to you all for your expertise and encouragement as the journal moves forwards in a positive fashion. Ultimately, EMA is about what you, the readers, make of it; what you enjoy, how you contribute, what you cite, and above all, what you learn that changes your clinical practice, or at least regularly makes you question your knowledge base and challenge your established care processes. That will be our success. Web 2.0 or no Web 2.0, we will be there. Associate Professor Anthony FT Brown is the Editor-in-Chief of Emergency Medicine Australasia.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Anthony Brown (2007) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: