Key result
The publication of the Difficult Airway Society guidelines highlights the need for better national data on airway complications to benchmark changes in training and clinical practice.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The editorial discusses the complexities and medico-legal implications of publishing clinical guidelines, specifically focusing on the Difficult Airway Society guidelines.
A colleague who is a member of the National Panel of Specialists (the Scottish equivalent of the College Assessors on Advisory Appointment Committees) recently commented how often a seemingly simple task turned out to be very different. Examining the qualifications, training record and experience of an individual and then considering whether or not he or she is appropriately trained for a consultant post appears at first sight to be a fairly straightforward task. In practice it is sometimes far from that. The same caveat applies when considering articles submitted for publication in journals such as Anaesthesia. The ‘normal’ process seems simple enough; we obtain expert reviewers' opinions and either accept, reject or discuss with the authors what changes the editors would require before acceptance. However, as the recent editorial by Yentis [1] noted, issues sometimes arise which require compromise rather than the rigid application of predetermined rules. The submission for consideration of publication of the guidelines produced by the Difficult Airway Society (DAS) in this month's issue gave rise to considerable discussion. Unlike the majority of manuscripts submitted, these guidelines were something that had already been finalised and therefore could not really be amended in light of editorial policy or reviewers' opinions. To do so would mean they no longer carried the approval of the DAS. The editors were therefore faced with deciding either to accept without amendment or to reject. Publication of such guidelines may be seen as an endorsement of the views of a group of enthusiasts and concern was expressed that it might lead to the establishment of a medico-legal standard. Would failure to follow these guidelines constitute negligent practice if the patient came to harm? What should clinicians make of the decision to publish and what should they do about these guidelines? Perhaps the legal position is the easiest to deal with. Although publication in a learned journal clearly adds credence to these recommendations it does not, itself, set them as a legal standard upon which a court would solely rely. The original test of the appropriateness of a medical practice goes back to the Hunter v Hanley judgement in Scotland which was followed by the Bolam case in England [2,3] and essentially stated that, as long as the practice followed was recognised as reasonable by a significant body of medical opinion, then failure to follow another recognised practice would not of itself constitute negligence. However the more recent Bolitho case [4] has led to the situation where merely following an accepted practice is not sufficient to avoid a charge of negligence – the practice followed must also be capable of logical justification to a court. If a charge of negligence is made, what will matter is whether the conduct and practice of the anaesthetist is reasonable and justifiable in the context of contemporary medical practice. The publication of guidelines and recommendations is but one factor in the assessment of the value of evidence. So how should these guidelines be regarded? It is clear that they represent the views of a group of enthusiasts who have individually and collectively done much to improve airway management. Airway training seminars and workshops continue to be very well supported – a testament to the excellent preparation and teaching of the organisers and the relevance that clinicians feel this has to their practice. However, many may wish to question some of these recommendations before deciding which, if any, aspects of their practice to modify. The first consideration is the extent of the problem. How many patients are harmed nowadays because of airway problems and what mechanisms are involved? Although problems with tracheal intubation may well be the leading cause of anaesthetic mortality, the references quoted in support of that statement are dated. The medical defence societies now only deal with negligence cases in the private sector although they do deal with complaints about clinical performance and may represent doctors at coroner's courts, fatal accident inquiries or the General Medical Council. Their data are therefore almost certainly not representative of contemporary anaesthetic practice. The Australian Incident Monitoring Study [5] provides a more broadly based assessment and the practice of anaesthesia may be reasonably similar to that pertaining in the UK although these data are now also over 10 years old. A proper examination of the situation would be expensive in respect of time and money and may not be a practical proposition. Consideration of the Confidential Enquiry into Maternal Deaths or NCEPOD gives an impression of the workload which would be involved. Retrospective examination of cases may provide useful information but is unlikely to be complete. Hand-written anaesthetic records are not as accurate as computer generated records but the latter are not universally (or even widely) available. This is potentially a vital factor given the time scale of events in the situation of airway problems. Debriefing of all those involved in a critical airway incident shortly after the event might be ideal and may well happen on occasion in individual departments but is unlikely to be suitable for national co-ordination. The new National Patient Safety Agency is tasked with forming a national database of critical incidents and may be a useful resource for correlating these data, but is still in its infancy. However, without such an investigation and knowledge of all the factors involved in particular cases, there is little way of knowing whether the introduction of these guidelines will help or even if some of them could produce other problems. Anaesthetic machines around the country now have a number of ‘guidelines’ in laminated sheets attached to them. That may be very useful for very rare complications such as malignant hyperthermia or anaphylactoid reactions, where it may be important to ensure that an exact protocol has been followed or that a particular treatment has not been omitted in error. Airway management is not just an important part of anaesthetic practice – it is an integral part of the everyday work of every anaesthetist. Management of airway problems should be almost second nature and reference to a flow chart while a patient is desaturating does not seem to be a sensible option. Every anaesthetist should have a clear airway management plan in mind for each and every patient – not just a primary plan but also what will be attempted if events do not turn out as expected. Flow charts may be appropriate for teaching therefore, but not for the anaesthetic room. What of the individual recommendations? Problems resulting from attempted tracheal intubation may ensue not just from lack of success but from failure to recognise lack of success or failure to desist from further attempts. The routine use of end-tidal carbon dioxide monitoring should virtually eliminate the situation of unrecognised oesophageal intubation – a situation which has played a major part in morbidity and mortality in the past. The strong advice not to make repeated attempts at intubation is very sensible and the place that repeated trauma to the upper airway may play in worsening the situation needs to be widely recognised. Perhaps the recommendation which will arouse most comment and debate is the suggestion that in the ‘Can’t Intubate, Can't Ventilate' (CICV) situation immediate recourse should be made to cricothyrotomy and that this should be recognised as a ‘core skill’ for all anaesthetists. At what level of desaturation should recourse be made to surgical access to the airway? Recent correspondence in this journal suggests that an exact saturation figure will be questioned [6–8] and values from 80% down to 50% have been suggested. Rigorously applied, particularly with the higher of these suggested levels, I suspect that this recommendation would lead to a very significant increase in the number of attempts at surgical access to the airway. Very significant because attempting surgical access will prevent other attempts to oxygenate with a face mask and because the technique is not without hazard. The presence of this recommendation in ATLS and some military protocols is not really a strong argument in favour given the different situation. Presumably there is the same lack of evidence base. There can be little argument that, if ventilation is truly impossible and the oxygen saturation dropping, then percutaneous or surgical access to the trachea will be the only way of keeping the patient alive. I doubt that I am alone in never having encountered the CICV situation in over 25 years of anaesthetic practice but I have certainly encountered cases where ventilation was very difficult. Would I have resorted to surgical access as an inexperienced trainee if these guidelines had been in place then and how much damage might I have inflicted? How good are junior trainees at assessing the difference between ventilation which is very difficult and only just sufficient and that which is truly impossible (at least in their own hands)? Will patients be better served if trainees feel ‘encouraged’ to proceed to cricothyrotomy if ventilation is very difficult? Retrospective review of individual cases is unlikely to be helpful unless there is some method of assessing just how difficult it was to ventilate the patient – another almost impossible request. How much time and training would be necessary to ensure trainees were even reasonably competent on a continuing basis at cricothyrotomy? Would the time and effort be better employed in ensuring that trainees are (even) better at pre-operative assessment of airway difficulty; in persuading trainees to use face masks more and laryngeal masks less; in improving the knowledge and abilities of those assisting the anaesthetist; or in teaching the inexperienced to use succinylcholine more often for intubation? Again, without accurate data it is impossible to state whether the more widespread use of succinylcholine would lead to a decrease in problems with intubation resulting from better relaxation in the first place and rapid recovery if intubation is not possible, or whether this would be outweighed by an increase in the incidence of anaphylactoid reactions. It is perhaps too easy to respond that all measures which might improve patient safety should be adopted. Given the constraints on the service and the very complex interactions between these various human and technical factors, care needs to be taken to ensure that the time and effort implementing one part of these recommendations does not either fail to make any impact on the problem, distract from other potentially more helpful changes or even introduce other problems. If cricothyrotomy is a ‘core skill’ which all anaesthetists must possess, how much additional time will this require before trainees can undertake cases without direct supervision? How much time will be required to maintain a skill which will be used rarely or not at all? And if this recommendation is followed how will we know whether the change has been for the better or not? These are not easy questions to answer but are highly relevant in the present situation of a continuing reduction in trainees' clinical experience with reduced working hours. So should Anaesthesia have published these guidelines? The decision of the editorial team was clearly in favour. What should individuals do? Read and evaluate them carefully, consider changes in personal and departmental practice and if appropriate make comment. There is much of value in the guidelines – not just the flow charts themselves but also the descriptive text which accompanies them. The authors are to be congratulated on producing so many well thought out and reasoned comments about the technique of intubation and the many technical devices which are now available. These guidelines will find a valuable place in training scenarios and simulators but probably not as an aide memoire in clinical practice. What should we do as a specialty? Urgently consider how to gather better information on the extent and nature of the problem and how to benchmark changes in training and practice rather than having to base recommendations on clinical opinion, however, expert and consensus-based that might be.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
W. A. Chambers (2004) conducted an editorial in Difficult airway management. Difficult Airway Society (DAS) guidelines was evaluated. The publication of the Difficult Airway Society guidelines highlights the need for better national data on airway complications to benchmark changes in training and clinical practice.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: