Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
HISTORY AND PHYSICAL EXAMINATION An asymptomatic 14-year-old girl presented for the evaluation of scoliosis. There was no family history of a spinal deformity. On physical examination, she had right thoracic curvature with a mild trunk shift to the right. She was noticeably lordotic in the thoracic region. Her neurologic examination was normal, including the presence of symmetric abdominal reflexes. Based on an atypical curve (Fig 1), magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was ordered (Figs 2-4). Laboratory studies all were normal, including a complete blood count with a manual differential, an erythrocyte sedimentation rate, serum electrolytes, a uri- nary homovanillic acid, and a urinary vanillylmandelic acid.Fig 1: The posteroanterior radiograph shows a mediastinal shadow adjacent to the convexity of a right thoracic curvature.Fig 2: This coronal T1-weighted image shows that the posterior mediastinal mass is isointense to skeletal muscle.Fig 3: A heterogeneous, diffusely enhancing mass is seen after gadolinium and fat suppression.Fig 4: This T2-weighted sequence with gadolinium and fat suppression shows extension of the mass into the right T6 foramen.Based on the history, physical findings, laboratory tests, and imaging studies, what is the differential diagnosis? IMAGING INTERPRETATION A standing posteroanterior radiograph of the spine (Fig 1) shows a right-sided mediastinal mass that is elongated and smoothly contoured, overlying the apex of a right thoracic scoliosis. No calcification is seen in the mass. No bony erosion or destruction is present, though there is some splaying of the posterior sixth and seventh ribs on the right. The curve is fairly sharp, and the apex is higher than that typically seen for right thoracic curvatures.37 Wedging of the apical vertebral bodies is evident, with an increased vertebral height on the convexity. A coronal T1 sequence (Fig 2) shows a posterior mediastinal mass that is isointense to skeletal muscle. No vertebral invasion is seen. A coronal sequence with gadolinium and fat suppression (Fig 3) shows a somewhat heterogeneous, diffusely enhancing mass. There is evidence of foraminal extension on the right side (T5 through T7), with minimal enhancing tissue laterally in the right side of the spinal canal. An axial T1 sequence with gadolinium and fat suppression (Fig 4) again shows the paraspinous mass with enhancing tissue extending into the right T6 neural foramen. DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS Ganglioneuroblastoma Primary sarcoma (Ewing's, Peripheral primitive neuroectodermal tumor) Ganglioneuroma Paraspinal inflammatory mass Lymphoma Schwannoma Neurofibroma An excisional biopsy was done to determine the diagnosis. Based on the history, physical findings, laboratory tests, radiographic studies, and histologic picture, what is the diagnosis and how should this lesion be treated? HISTOLOGY INTERPRETATION At low magnification (Fig 5), the field is dominated by Schwannian stroma (predominant cell type is the Schwann cell) with scattered individual ganglion cells, sometimes displaying a tendency to cluster. At higher power (Fig 6), the ganglion cells all appear mature with surrounding satellite cells. No neuroblastic nests (clusters of neuroblastic cells) are identified, and neuropil is absent. Neuropil represents a fine pattern of cellular (neuritic) processes that extend from neuroblasts. Neuropil appears to be within the extracellular space.Fig 5: At low power, a Schwannian stroma with occasional ganglion cells is seen (Stain, hematoxylin and eosin; original magnification, x40).Fig 6: At high power there are mature ganglion cells without any neuroblastic nests (Stain, hematoxylin and eosin; original magnification, x400).DIAGNOSIS Ganglioneuroma (Schwannian stroma dominant), mature DISCUSSION The diagnosis of a mature ganglioneuroma was established by excisional biopsy performed in conjunction with an anterior spinal fusion at the apex of the scoliosis. The lesion extended into the T5 foramen, which precluded a complete excision through the anterior approach. The mass was 8 × 4.2 × 2.1 cm, and had a yellow, glistening, homogenous surface without evidence of hemorrhage or necrosis. One week later, the patient had a posterior procedure for removal of residual tumor and spinal stabilization. After a hemilaminectomy and facetectomy at T5, exploration of the intervertebral foramen showed that the T5 root was dilated at the level of the midforamen. The root was resected proximally, and the foramen then was cleared of any remaining soft tissue. An instrumented posterior spinal fusion was done from T4 to T11 (Fig 7). The patient is currently asymptomatic without signs of recurrence at more than 2 years after surgery.Fig 7: A standing posteroanterior radiograph after tumor resection and instrumentation is shown.This case shows a posterior mediastinal mass associated with a secondary scoliosis in an adolescent. Anatomic structures that most commonly give rise to a posterior mediastinal mass include the vertebral body, the disc, the nerve root, and the sympathetic chain. The majority of posterior mediastinal masses in children and adolescents will be neurogenic in origin, most commonly involving the sympathetic chain (ganglioneuroma, ganglioneuroblastoma, or neuroblastoma). Saenz et al reviewed 63 children with solid posterior mediastinal tumors and found that 89% were neurogenic (most commonly neuroblastoma). Other diagnoses included primitive neuroectodermal tumor and non-Hodgkin's lymphoma,31 which (along with neuroblastoma) are often referred to as small, blue, round cell tumors. The lesions found in ganglioneuroblastoma are more intermediately differentiated than seen here. Primitive neuroectodermal tumors are poorly differentiated, arise in the bone and soft tissues outside the central and sympathetic nervous system, and are seen most commonly during the second decade of life.8 Both Ewing's sarcoma and primitive neuroectodermal tumor have a strong histogenetic relationship, and some feel that these differ only in the degree of differentiation. A primary sarcoma is unlikely based on the lack of symptoms, the absence of destructive changes on imaging, and their rarity. Intraspinal lesions are extremely rare and bony destruction is common. The few reported cases have all presented with neurologic symptoms. Lymphomas represent malignant tumors originating in lymph nodes or lymphoid tissue. A non-Hodgkin's lymphoma is unlikely based upon the patient's age and the fact that these lesions are rarely seen in the posterior mediastinum.39 In comparing the features of benign neurogenic tumors on plain radiographs, ganglioneuromas tend to be flat and elongated, while schwannomas and neurofibromas tend to be oval.15 In the present case, a benign neurogenic tumor was most likely based upon the patient's age, the absence of symptoms, the normal laboratory profile, and the absence of destructive changes on imaging. Neuroblastoma was unlikely (and not placed in the differential) because of the patient's age, the normal urinary homovanillic and vanillylmandelic acid, and the findings on MRI including the presence of well-defined borders and the absence of rib spreading and/or bony erosions.4 Where neuroblastoma is seen most often in children younger than 2 years, ganglioneuroma is typically diagnosed in older children and adolescents.22 Infection was also unlikely given the patient was asymptomatic and had normal laboratory studies. While clinical features and imaging studies may assist in organizing a differential diagnosis, a biopsy is always required to establish the diagnosis. Several options for biopsy may be considered, including a CT-guided needle biopsy, a thoracoscopic biopsy, or an open biopsy. In the present case, the presurgical evaluation suggested the presence of a benign lesion, and the decision was made to treat the secondary scoliosis at the same time. As such, we elected to perform an open biopsy (excisional) as the first stage. In cases in which the clinical and/or radiologic features are suggestive of a malignant lesion such as a sarcoma, it may be preferable to proceed with a CT-guided needle biopsy before definitive management like a course of preoperative adjuvant chemotherapy would be recommended before surgical resection. Ganglioneuroma represents one type of peripheral nerve sheath tumor (originating in peripheral nerves, in sympathetic or parasympathetic ganglia, or in embryonic remnants of the neural tube), and typically arises in the sympathetic chain, most commonly in the posterior mediastinum, the retroperitoneum, the adrenal gland, or the sacrum or pelvis.21,23,30 Rarely, ganglioneuroma may be found in other locations, such as the maxilla, kidney, spinal cord, heart, intestinal tract, spermatic cord, and tongue.26,38 These lesions grow slowly, and most are diagnosed incidentally. Infrequently, gait disturbance and radicular pain may be observed.33 The tumor has been reported in association with neurofibromatosis,10,40 and has presented as idiopathic scoliosis in an asymptomatic adolescent.2,7,32 Ganglioneuroma represents the benign end of a spectrum of neuroblastic tumors including ganglioneuroblastoma (intermediate differentiation) and neuroblastoma (malignant, least differentiated form) (Table 1). The diagnosis is determined histologically. The ratio of occurrence of neuroblastoma to ganglioneuroma is approximately six to one.22 The spectrum of pathologic findings in neuroblastic tumors relates to variations in the degree of maturation of the cellular elements (neuroblasts, ganglion cells) and the extracellular elements or stroma (Schwann cells, fibrovascular septae, or both).21 The International Neuroblastoma Pathology Committee published guidelines for classification of neuroblastic tumors based on the original work of Shimada et al.34-36 The final histologic prognostic assignment (favorable or unfavorable) is based on tumor type, subtype, patient age, and mitosis/karyorrhexis index (number of cells per 5000 that are undergoing mitosis or karyorrhexis, < 200 represents a favorable prognosis). In considering the cellular elements, a mature ganglioneuroma is comprised of ganglion cells. There are no neuroblastic rests, and neuropil is absent. Some differentiating neuroblasts may be identified in a ganglioneuroma, which redefines the lesion as maturing rather than mature. In contrast, a ganglioneuroblastoma has neuroblastic rests, while neuroblastoma represents the least differentiated form, being comprised predominantly of neuroblasts. In considering the extracellular matrix, ganglioneuromas have a predominantly Schwannian stroma (comprised of Schwann cells), in contrast to neuroblastomas, in which the matrix is predominantly composed of thin, fibrovascular septae (less than 50% Schwannian stroma). Ganglioneuroblastomas are intermediate, having more than 50% Schwannian stroma.TABLE 1: Neuroblastic TumorsGanglioneuromas may occur de novo, or may represent the regression of one or more foci of neuroblastoma (spontaneously or after treatment). Multiple lesions have been reported in bone and soft tissue, which likely represent “spontaneous maturation of metastases from neuroblastoma.”25 Though rare, a small number of case reports have documented malignant transformation, usually to a high- grade neurogenic tumor.3,5,10,12,17,29 Transformation to a mesenchymal tumor (rhabdomyosarcoma) or a malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumor has also been reported.9,18 The primary lesion may contain a higher-grade component, which mandates a thorough histologic evaluation of the entire specimen.9,14,38 In such cases, there is transformation of the spindle cell component rather than the ganglion cell component. In the case report by Kulkarni et al,20 spinal neuroblastoma was identified 11 years after resection of a spinal ganglioneuroma, suggesting that the ganglion cell component may rarely go through malignant transformation. They questioned whether this represented a dedifferentiation of the ganglioneuroma versus a quiescent form of neuroblastoma. Ricci et al also reported transformation of the ganglion cell component in several patients who previously had been treated with radiation therapy.29 In comparing the findings on plain radiographs in neuroblastoma, ganglioneuroblastoma, and ganglioneuroma (Table 1), Bar-Ziv and Nogrady4 found that neuroblastoma was associated with indistinct borders (ghost like) and more pronounced spreading of the ribs, with or without bony erosions. Though the presence of calcifications may distinguish neurogenic lesions from other posterior mediastinal masses, this feature does not help differentiate ganglioneuroma from ganglioneuroblastoma or neuroblastoma.1 Ganglioneuromas tend to be flat and elongated, with tapered borders.15 On computed tomography (CT) scans (Table 1), a ganglioneuroma is usually of low (30%) to intermediate (70%) attenuation, and between 20 and 42% will have calcifications (80% punctate, 20% coarse).1,16 Schwannomas typically show contrast enhancement, and central areas of low density on contrast images often characterize these lesions.16 Atypical features in a ganglioneuroma, such as soft tissue density and coarse calcifications, may suggest that a component of the lesion is higher grade (ganglioneuroblastoma).16 Bar-Ziv and Nogrady concluded that it was impossible to distinguish between ganglioneuroma, ganglioneuroblastoma, and neuroblastoma based solely on CT findings.4 Findings on MRI in ganglioneuroma (Table 1) include a low T1 signal, a high T2 signal, and a gradual increase in enhancement on dynamic images.16,41 The intensity on T2-weighted images provides qualitative information on the contents of the cellular and extracellular components.41 Lesions that are very high on T2 have a higher content of myxoid stroma, with a corresponding decrease in the cellular and fibrous elements. In contrast, those with an intermediate T2 signal typically have a greater cellular component. Magnetic resonance imaging is most helpful in defining the extent of tumor in the spinal canal, and a CT myelogram is an acceptable alternative.1 Scanning with 131MIBG (metaiodobenzylguanidine labeled to iodine-123) does not reliably differentiate between ganglioneuroma and neuroblastoma.14,24 This substance is a catecholamine analog and is taken up by tumors that produce catecholamines. Up to 70% of neuroblastomas and ganglioneuroblastomas may have positive scans. Geoerger et al13 found a positive scan in 57% of patients with ganglioneuroma. A normal 131MIBG scan does not rule out any of these tumors. The standard evaluation of a posterior mediastinal mass also shows levels of urine vanillylmandelic acid and urine homovanillic acid. Ninety to 95% of neuroblastomas or ganglioneuroblastomas will secrete catecholamines, yet patients rarely develop symptoms of catecholamine excess.22 Meyer et al reported an elevation in catecholamine metabolites in one of four patients with ganglioneuroma.24 The recommended treatment for a mature ganglioneuroma is marginal excision, as the anatomic location usually precludes achieving a wide margin.22,23,38 Multiple areas in each specimen should be studied microscopically to rule out the presence of a higher-grade component. Adjuvant therapy (chemotherapy or radiation therapy) is only indicated should a section of the pathologic specimen show a higher-grade component, and such cases must be treated on an individual basis. Recurrence may be seen, but growth is typically slow. Once the diagnosis is established, these lesions may be treated by observation. Symptomatic recurrences, or those in which the rate of growth is a concern, should be treated by repeat biopsy and/or excision. In the current case, had the mediastinal mass not been identified on the plain radiograph, an MRI scan of the neural axis might have been justified on the basis of atypical features in this right thoracic curve pattern.37 Relative to historic controls,6,19,26,28 the end vertebrae and apex are higher than expected for the typical right thoracic curve. A shift in the end vertebrae or apex of a curvature makes the curve appear higher, lower, longer, or shorter than we might expect to see in an idiopathic curvature. In addition, there is more vertebral wedging at the apex than might be expected based on the degree of rotation. Asymmetry in vertebral shape presumably results from a localized increase in blood flow to that portion of the vertebra adjacent to the lesion.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Spiegel et al. (2006) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: