Key result
Endovascular abdominal aortic aneurysm repair is an evolving alternative to open surgery, though its long-term effects on renal function and stent placement require ongoing evaluation.
Why the study?
Does endovascular abdominal aortic aneurysm repair affect renal function compared to open surgical repair?
Does endovascular abdominal aortic aneurysm repair affect renal function compared to open surgical repair?
Endovascular repair of abdominal aortic aneurysms requires careful consideration of renal anatomy and function, as stent placement and contrast use can impact renal outcomes.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Requires vigilant post-EVAR renal monitoring; leaves open optimal stent strategies and long-term comparisons to open repair.
Post-operative renal failure is relatively common following aortic aneurysm surgery and is associated with a poor outcome [ 1 , 2 ]. The interdependent relationship of aneurysms and renal failure is well-known to clinicians, leading to close working relationships between vascular surgeons and nephrologists. The traditional method of surgical repair for abdominal aortic aneurysms involves open access to the aorta, the application of vascular clamps and the replacement of the aneurysmal segment by a synthetic graft manufactured from either polyester or polytetrafluoroethylene (PTF) which is sutured into place. In patients with short necks, the clamps may compromise renal blood flow as they have to be applied immediately below, or occasionally above, the level of the renal arteries. There is some evidence that the application of clamps distally to the iliac arteries before clamping proximally may increase the number of atheroemboli detected in the renal arteries. The length of ischaemic time to the limbs may also cause the ischaemia–reperfusion syndrome resulting in a deterioration in the renal function post-operatively. Pre-existing renal failure and renal artery stenosis due to aortic atheroma will increase the incidence of renal failure associated with open surgical aneurysm repair. The endovascular revolution in treating abdominal aortic aneurysms started with Volodos et al . [ 3 ] and Parodi et al . [ 4 ]. They used stent grafts consisting of a metal stent covered with fabric contained within a sheath, which was inserted through the femoral artery. The stent graft was deployed in the neck of the aneurysm, i.e. a healthy segment of the normal calibre aorta below the renal arteries, by withdrawing the sheath and allowing the self-expanding stents to open. The stents were oversized compared with the diameter of the aorta and were held in place by the radial force. The early experiments showed that both the proximal and distal stents were required to exclude the aneurysm. The term endoleak was introduced to describe the continued leak of contrast material into the aneurysm sac outside the device. Aortic tube grafts had an unacceptable incidence of distal endoleak and it quickly became apparent that bifurcated devices were required with the distal landing zones in the common iliac arteries. Home-made aortouni-iliac devices became popular as they were able to treat a wider range of anatomical variations, the drawback being that the contralateral iliac artery had to be occluded and a femoro–femoral crossover graft inserted to revascularize that limb. Commercially manufactured bifurcated stent grafts were developed which were either manufactured in a single piece or had a modular configuration. Single piece devices required that the contralateral limb had to be pulled down into the contralateral iliac artery. This could lead to twisting of the graft material with consequent occlusion of that limb. Modular devices were developed with the contralateral limb being inserted via the contralateral femoral artery, and then positioned in a gate in the main body of the device to form a seal. Several early devices had unacceptable rates of limb occlusion, modular disconnection and migration. The long-term results were relatively poor, with the combination of metal and fabric disintegrating causing pressurization of the sac and subsequent rupture [ 5 ]. The current generation of stent grafts consists of either nitinol or stainless-steel stents covered with either polyester or PTF. Most employ hooks or barbs to prevent distal migration. Some employ suprarenal fixation which consists of having a bare or uncovered part of the stent in the suprarenal aorta. The aorta at the level of the visceral and renal arteries is recognized as the most resistant to dilatation. It is also usually free of atheromatous disease. The evidence for suprarenal stents causing a deterioration in renal function is not supported by the literature. Many studies show that this is a safe procedure [ 6–9 ]. A detailed analysis has recently been published comparing open repair with endovascular repair using suprarenal fixation in a non-randomized study [ 10 ]. The endovascular group had better results initially using serum creatinine concentrations as a marker of renal function, however, there were no differences at 1 year. Interestingly, the incidence of renal artery occlusion was 1% in the endovascular group compared with 1.4% in the open surgery, and the incidence of renal infarction was 1.5 and 1.4%, respectively. A reduction in creatinine clearance was shown in both the groups over 1 year which then stabilized or improved by 2 years for the endovascular group. Placing the most proximal part of the covered device as close to the renal arteries as possible is associated with good results to affect a good seal around the upper neck of the aneurysm. Figure 1 illustrates how close the stent is placed to the renal arteries in a patient with renovascular disease. The use of an uncovered suprarenal stent also reduces distal migration as seen in Figure 1 . Distal migration is a disaster and is the main factor associated with subsequent aneurysm rupture. It is clear, therefore, that the renal arteries may be compromised by stents and by graft material placed unwittingly over the ostia. This can be minimized by the use of excellent imaging in high-quality endovascular suites. Occasionally, proximal migration of a device may occur, especially in a conical neck. Most of the hooks and barbs are designed to prevent distal migration and do not prevent proximal migration of the device. One device with a suprarenal stent has the markers signifying the start of the material 2–3 mm below the edge, thereby allowing inexperienced users to deploy the fabric over the lower part of the renal orifice. The completion angiogram may not show any compromise, but follow-up computerized tomographic (CT) scans will show poor renal perfusion, often within 3 months of insertion. The inadvertent deployment of the device over both renal arteries can occur if the branches of the coeliac artery are misinterpreted as renal arteries. However, if the stent graft is secured with hooks and barbs proximally, these may damage the aorta with disastrous consequences. Immediate conversion to open repair may be the only option in this clinical scenario. Aortic stent deployment in a patient with renovascular disease. Even with optimum placement of a stent graft, renal malperfusion may occur after the procedure. Figure 2 A and B show an aortic stent placed and follow-up CT scans 6 weeks and 1 year after placement. The angiogram shows that renal artery occlusion has occurred in the year after aortic stent placement. The deployment of ostial stents may reperfuse renal arteries that have been partially compromised by suprarenal stents or graft material. Figure 4 illustrates how difficult this can be. The balloon is being deployed through the side of the uncovered part of an in situ aortic stent. This is obviously a technically challenging procedure. Follow-up aortic CT scans 6 weeks ( A ) and 1 year ( B ) after stent placement showing left renal atrophy. Angiography after the 1 year follow-up CT scan in Figure 2 showing occlusion of the left renal artery. Renal artery angioplasty in a patient with an aortic stent. The balloon is passing through the uncovered part of the aortic stent. The nephrotoxic nature of the contrast material may contribute to renal failure at the time of implantation of the endoluminal devices and during their continued follow-up. There is little evidence for the use of N-acetylcysteine to prevent this [ 11 , 12 ]. However, this problem may be overcome by the use of carbon dioxide as a contrast material and intravascular ultrasound as an imaging modality [ 13 , 14 ]. Follow-up using duplex ultrasound and plain abdominal radiography has been shown to be as effective as computed tomography with contrast [ 15 ]. New devices are being developed which will allow aneurysms with short necks to be treated. These include fenestrated and branched stent grafts [ 16 , 17 ]. Most fenestrated devices require an uncovered stent to be placed within the renal artery orifices to ensure correct alignment. Branched stent grafts will allow the endovascular treatment of suprarenal and thoracoabdominal aneurysms. Level I evidence for the use of stent grafts to treat abdominal aortic aneurysms is sparse. However, the multicentre EVAR trials were performed in the UK and the 30 day results have been published for EVAR 1 [ 18 ]. The EVAR 1 trial is a randomized prospective trial of endovascular compared with open surgical repair in patients considered fit for surgery. The EVAR 2 trial compares the best medical treatment with best medical treatment and endovascular repair in patients considered unfit for open surgery. The DREAM [ 19 ] trial has reported an operative mortality of 4.6% for open repair and 1.2% for endovascular repair, although this was not statistically significant. The trial showed no difference in the change in renal function pre- and post-intervention between the two groups. This, however, was only for the pre-operative and day 2 post-operative values, and not long-term data. The interesting recent data is that of Azizzadeh et al . [ 20 ], who have shown that the estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) is a predictor of mortality in endovascular abdominal aortic aneurysm repair. These authors used the Cockroft–Gault equation and quartile segmentation. The actuarial survival was 61.5% for eGFR 7–45 ml/min vs 85.7% for eGFR of >80 ml/min at 4 years. The effect of renal function on the outcome in arterial surgery is not a lesson lost on vascular surgeons. These developments are clearly going to impact upon nephrologists. Up to 50% of infrarenal abdominal aortic aneurysm can now be treated with the current devices and this percentage will increase as advances in technology occur. The long-term effect of endoluminal repair on renal function will be one of great interest. With open repair, any renal damage will be due to peri-operative damage. With endoluminal repair, as discussed, the stent position or aneurysm's size may alter over time. This may alter the relationship to the renal artery ostium and thus, its patency. Trans-renal stent placement offers another differential diagnostic problem in older patients with impaired renal function and an aortic stent. There still remains the dilemma of whether or not an individual with renal artery stenosis needs renal stent placement prior to aortic stent placement. This is technically much easier than when the aortic stent graft is in place and partially covering the renal artery ostium. Renal stent placement through the side of the in situ aortic stent is a challenging procedure. There remains no evidence base for this decision. As always, the interaction between vascular surgeons and nephrologists is stimulating. Conflict of interest statement . None declared. 1Department of Vascular Surgery, 2Department of Radiology and 3Department of Nephrology, Guy's & St.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Taylor et al. (2006) conducted a review in Abdominal aortic aneurysm. Endovascular abdominal aortic aneurysm repair vs. Open surgical repair was evaluated. Endovascular abdominal aortic aneurysm repair is an evolving alternative to open surgery, though its long-term effects on renal function and stent placement require ongoing evaluation.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: