Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
With the publication of Meigs' (1) paper in 1947, in which he reported 91 operations of the Wertheim-Taussig type for cancer of the cervix with no mortality, interest in attempted surgical cure of this disease was revived. No one since has worked more industriously or with greater surgical acumen to establish surgery as a method of choice in cervical carcinoma. Many have failed, however, to heed Cade's warning (2) that this operation is admittedly not one for the “occasional hysterectomist,” and as many have neglected to follow Meigs' selectivity in choice of patients, with dire results. The operation as now performed, Meigs (3) writes, does not compare to surgery performed early in the series. The newer operation is attended by a higher incidence of nerve injuries to the bladder than the earlier procedure. As described by Meigs, his new operation could be done only in a department that has large grants for cancer research, or is similarly endowed; the preoperative preparation of the patient, the surgical teamwork, the nursing aftercare, and follow-up are fabulous. According to him, the total number of cases in which the procedure has been used is too few for sweeping deductions, but it is evident that surgical treatment alone, as far as cure is concerned and in respect to results in patients with positive nodes, is as good as and even slightly better (italics ours) than combined treatment with radium or x-ray and surgery. Liu and Meigs (4), in a recent report on 344 patients with primary invasive carcinoma of the cervix, selected 193 who had been operated upon and followed for five years or more. One hundred and thirty-nine were classified clinically as Stage I; 53 as Stage II; 1 as Stage III. Among this total of 193 cases were 49 with regional lymph node metastases, showing a 35 per cent five-year survival (17 patients); 144 had no lymph node involvement, with an 81 per cent five-year survival (116 patients). We see no evidence here that surgery is superior to radiation. One argument for surgery has been that radiation does not affect the pelvic nodes. Accumulated evidence now controverts this old idea. Graham and Graham (5) state that metastases from uterine cervical cancer occur with greater frequency in the regional nodes than more distantly. They review the work of Morton, Gorton, Cherry, Glücksmann, Dearing, and Way and conclude that the array of evidence thus obtained suggests that radiotherapy does control regional node metastases in cervical cancer in part of the patients. Glücksmann (6), in 1941, in a preliminary report from the Strangeways Research Laboratory, Cambridge, described a method by which the effects of radiation on malignant cells in vivo are measured quantitatively.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
O'Brien et al. (1956) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: