Key result
This letter discusses the potential role of positive suggestions during pre-operative anaesthetic visits, noting that existing literature on taped suggestions during anaesthesia is equivocal.
Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Design
Editorial
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The authors acknowledge the potential of positive suggestions during pre-operative visits but note that existing literature on taped suggestions during anaesthesia shows equivocal results.
We gratefully acknowledge the comments by Allan Cyna, who draws our attention to an indeed largely neglected field. Whereas we were only looking for ‘how information was conveyed’ and ‘how physicians respond to patients’ needs’, the writer suggests considering what is said and whether what is said could help convey a positive suggestion, thus increasing postoperative well-being. As we have no experience in the deliberate use of suggestions in pre-operative anaesthetic visits, we can only thank him for his idea to improve the anaesthetists' ability to make use of the stress patients are in prior to an operation, and therefore of a potential increased receptive state to positive suggestions. From the literature we know that the results of studies, which used taped positive suggestions played to anaesthetised patients, are at best unequivocal. While some reported a positive effect of such suggestions in reducing patients' morphine requirements [1], increasing compliance to a postoperative regimen [2], reducing nausea and vomiting [3], and facilitating cessation of smoking [4], others reported no beneficial effects on morphine requirements [5], smoking behaviour [6], or postoperative pain and nausea scores [7]. Another study also reported no effects of positive suggestions made pre-operatively to the awake patient with respect to nausea [8]. However, positive suggestions to the awake patient in the pre-operative period are yet to be explored in greater detail.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Christoph H. Kinder (2004) reported a letter. This letter discusses the potential role of positive suggestions during pre-operative anaesthetic visits, noting that existing literature on taped suggestions during anaesthesia is equivocal.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: