Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
It was estimated that over 44,000 people would be diagnosed with thyroid cancer in the United States in 2010 (1). With appropriate initial treatment, the majority of those patients can expect to achieve good disease-specific outcomes. However, up to 30% of patients (2) will suffer persistent disease or recurrences, the majority of which are fortunately localized to cervical lymph nodes. Although recommendations for the initial management of well-differentiated thyroid cancer are well-formulated and have considerable evidence behind them, gathered over many decades of careful follow-up, recommendations for therapeutic options for recurrent or persistent disease have less clarity. Historically, this has been a difficult literature. There have been variations in surgical technique and shifts in the use of adjuvant radioactive iodine therapy. There have been improvements in thyroglobulin assays over time and thus, changing definitions of biochemical cure. We have shifted paradigms for disease detection modalities, performing more frequent TSH-stimulated thyroglobulin assessments since the Food and Drug Administration approval of recombinant human TSH and have dramatically increased the utilization of high-resolution neck ultrasonography. In older studies, the criteria for cure after surgery was often not rigorous, or detailed information on disease assessment postoperatively was not provided. Furthermore, direct comparison of different modalities of therapy and combinations of therapy (e.g. radioactive iodine and/or surgical resection) have been rare, and those studies, such as Coburn et al. (3), usually were not randomized and suffered from significant selection bias. The 2009 Revised American Thyroid Association Management Guidelines for Patients with Thyroid Nodules and Differentiated Thyroid Cancer recommend surgical management of locoregional disease in the absence of distant metastases with an evidence rating of B (based on fair evidence that the service or intervention can improve important health outcomes) (4). Literature subsequent to that reviewed for the 2009 Revised Guidelines, including the paper by Yim et al. (5) published in this issue of the JCEM, contribute additional information to be considered in the assessment of the efficacy of lymph node dissection for locoregional disease. Specifically, three recent studies suggest that surgical intervention for locoregional recurrence can indeed achieve biochemical remission (undetectable TSH-stimulated serum thyroglobulin). Lymph node dissection achieves a TSH-stimulated thyroglobulin of less than 1.0 ng/ml in 29% of patients (6) and less than 2.0 ng/ml in 41–46% of patients in one to three lymph node dissections (6, 7). Clayman et al. (8) reported obtaining an undetectable thyroglobulin (<3 ng/ml) in 71% of informative cases. The paper by Yim et al. (5) describes a careful analysis of a relatively large series of 83 patients who underwent surgical intervention for recurrent/persistent papillary thyroid carcinoma. The authors report achieving a biochemical remission (undetectable TSH-stimulated thyroglobulin less than 1.0 ng/ml) in 51% of patients and less than 2.0 ng/ml in 61% of patients. Additional important findings in this study were that higher preoperative thyroglobulin levels predicted failure to achieve a biochemical and clinical remission. However, there was only a tendency toward the number of pathological nodes to predict biochemical remission and no impact of the number of removed nodes, number of malignant nodes, extent of reoperation or adjunctive radioactive iodine on achieving biochemical remission or clinical remission. Furthermore, they found that a postoperative stimulated thyroglobulin greater than 5 ng/ml significantly (but not universally) predicted clinical recurrence over the ensuing 5 yr (5). Development of a recurrence portends a higher mortality in many studies (9, 10); however, significant morbidity and mortality are not universal, and long-term survival is common. Furthermore, the impact on outcomes of small volume recurrent disease detected by more sensitive surveillance is not clear. Therefore, recommendation of appropriate therapy is critical to prevent or relieve local symptoms (such as compression of the airway or esophagus) as well as to optimize the chance for a good outcome while adhering to the principle of “primum non nocere.” Understanding the true efficacy of surgical intervention for recurrent/persistent disease is not an academic exercise. Patients have assumptions about the intent and the promise of surgical treatments that may be inaccurate, just as providers are likely to have. It is critical that patients are provided with realistic information and have appropriate expectations of the anticipated result of a lymph node dissection, specifically that a biochemical remission will be achieved only 30–50% of the time. Furthermore, clear information about the surgical risks of hypoparathyroidism, recurrent laryngeal nerve injury, and other local risks is important. To balance that, recent studies have provided important information about the risks of radioactive iodine on long-term cancer risk (11–14). A better understanding of the efficacy of each of the therapeutic interventions, surgery and radioactive iodine, as well less commonly used interventions such as external beam radiation, percutaneous ethanol ablation, and radiofrequency ablation, for achieving a clinical remission is needed. Longer studies are obviously required to assess those outcomes and are difficult in the setting of fluctuating “standard” care. There are additional unanswered questions in regard to the clinical significance of low levels of thyroglobulin and the actual benefit of rendering those undetectable. Current recommendations certainly suggest that conservative surveillance is appropriate in many cases (4). It will only be when data addressing these issues are available that truly informed decisions about the risk-benefit ratio of each of the therapeutic options for recurrent/persistent well-differentiated thyroid cancer can be made. In the interim, the paper by Yim et al. (5) provides additional information about the efficacy of surgical intervention to guide informed decision making about the management of recurrent/persistent disease. Disclosure Summary: No conflicts of interest exist.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kathryn G. Schuff (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: