Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In 1972, Hal Mooney published a seminal paper that laid the foundation for the emerging field of plant physiological ecology and its focus on carbon assimilation (Mooney, 1972). Mooney argued that environmental and evolutionary constraints on plant growth could be best understood within the context of tradeoffs in the allocation of a limited supply of C among a variety of competing functions. To this day, concepts such as allocation tradeoffs, optimization, resource-use efficiency, marginal gain, storage and other econometrics that describe resource-use patterns have dominated ecophysiology. However, now, wider issues have come to the forefront and are driving change. In this issue of New Phytologist, three Tansley reviews are presented which, together, provide a window on the synthesis that has been going on between the more traditional, theory-based side of the discipline which was reflected in the econometric analogies of the 1960s−1980s, and the newer, societal-based side of the discipline that has emerged from the need to address major environmental issues since the 1980s. ‘For plant ecophysiology, the intellectual core represented by plant carbon relations still stands as a powerful organizing principle’ Ecophysiologists, with their focus on the assimilation and allocation of C, were ideally suited to lead some of the most important studies of environmental issues during the final decades of the 20th century: these included the ecological effects of elevated atmospheric CO2 concentration and the elevated concentration of pollutant oxidants, such as ozone (O3). Key symposium proceedings were published in the early 1980s (e.g. Miller, 1980; Lemon, 1983), defining the nexus between plant function and chemical changes in the atmosphere, with the list of invited contributors reflecting the most prominent leaders in the field of plant ecophysiology at that time. Now, 20 yr later, plant ecophysiologists represent a large portion of the intellectual leadership in the disciplines that cover biosphere–atmosphere interactions and the ecological effects of anthropogenic perturbations (DeLucia et al., 2001; Norby et al., 2001). This new, applied version of ecophysiology still rests firmly on its foundation of plant C relations, providing the basis for truly mechanistic perspectives on some of the hard environmental issues facing society today. Plants produce a variety of secondary compounds primarily for the purpose of protection from biotic and environmental stresses. When oxidized in the lower atmosphere, these volatile organic compounds (VOCs) exert primary photochemical controls over tropospheric chemistry (Monson & Holland, 2001; Monson, 2002). There is reason to believe that fundamental connections exist between evolutionary constraints on C allocation and the emission rate of some compounds (e.g. monoterpenes and sesquiterpenes) and environmental constraints on C assimilation and the emission rate of other compounds (e.g. isoprene and methylbutenol). Such connections should facilitate the coupling of mechanistic photosynthesis models and growth/differentiation tradeoff models to the boundary processes that frame atmospheric chemistry models. The potential of this approach is profoundly synthetic in that it brings together communities of scientists from markedly disparate disciplinary perspectives, and expands C assimilation/allocation theory into a realm that includes issues such as tropospheric ozone production, the lifetime of radiatively active trace gases such as methane, and the production and transport of organic nitrate compounds such as peroxyacetyl nitrate. In a review of the most relevant biological issues on this topic, Lerdau & Gray (pp. 199–211) make clear the differences between VOCs that leak from stored reservoirs of herbivore-deterrent, secondary compounds, and VOCs that volatilize from primary metabolic processes. In physiological terms, these can be categorized as light-independent and light-dependent emissions, respectively. The authors discuss the implications of these different processes to the development of mechanistic emission models, emphasizing the fact that light-independent emissions must be simulated from biophysical processes involving compound solubility and diffusive potential, whereas light-dependent emissions must be simulated from biochemical processes associated with primary biosynthetic pathways; light-independent emissions are separated in time from their biosynthetic origins, whereas light-dependent emissions are tightly coupled in time to their biosynthetic origins. In this analysis, the independent functional ramifications and time constants of C allocation vs C assimilation are clear. Of particular note in the review is the evolutionary perspective on the distribution of certain types of emission, especially those involving methylbutenol, a recently discovered light-dependent VOC emission from certain North American pine species. Using new information on the distribution of methylbutenol emissions, the authors highlight the complex, discontinuous pattern of expression among existing pine clades, leading to the conclusion of numerous independent origins or losses; the phylogenetic situation is similar for the case of isoprene emissions, the dominant form of light-dependent VOC emission found in a broad spectrum of plant taxa, ranging from mosses to angiosperms. They highlight the recent breakthroughs in sequencing terpene synthases, including isoprene synthase, and the potential to add insight into phylogenetic patterns. This is clearly an area for exploitation in the future. One of the big questions remaining in regard to the ecophysiological significance of VOC emissions is the reason for their existence, adaptive or otherwise. One theory that has gained some acceptance in the community involves the possible thermal protective properties of short-chain hydrocarbons that partition into lipid membranes (Sharkey & Yeh, 2001). By stabilizing critical proteins in the photosynthetic apparatus or in other membranes, VOCs such as isoprene may enhance thermal tolerance. Other theories exist to explain these emissions, however, and to date, no single theory has completely captured the discipline (Kreuzwieser et al., 2002; Penuelas & Llusia, 2002; Rennenberg & Schnitzler, 2002). Sometime between the early and late Carboniferous period, at least 450 million years ago, terrestrial plants faced a reckoning with the atmosphere – CO2 concentrations were depleted to the point where photorespiration became a significant C cost and stomata were forced to open to the point where photosynthetic water-use efficiency emerged as a dominant selective agent (Drake, 2001; Medlyn et al., 2001; Morison, 2001). Using the econometric analogies alluded to already, this was the ‘ultimate financial depression’, a time when previously evolved C investment and allocation strategies were put to the true test. Following the decreases in CO2 concentration, and during subsequent secondary decreases, novel mechanisms of C assimilation and allocation evolved, including C4 photosynthesis and active phloem loading (Turgeon, 1996; Sage, 1999; Pataki, 2002). In modern times, the potential fortunes for plants have changed again, with the earth's atmosphere returning toward a state of more abundant CO2. In the recent world, marked by profligate fossil fuel combustion and elevated atmospheric CO2 concentrations, many plants stand to benefit. The obvious question arises, which plants will benefit the most? In other words, what will determine the winners and losers in the competition to capitalize on the sudden increased availability of atmospheric C? In the review by Poorter and Navas (pp. 175–198), the highly successful method of growth analysis that was pioneered by Poorter and coworkers to address the question ‘why do some plants grow faster than others?’ is now applied to the question ‘why do some plants grow faster in elevated CO2 than others’. In many ways, this top-down approach defies the tendencies that developed immediately following Mooney's 1972 paper (i.e. the tendency to focus on processes on the basis of a unit of ‘leaf’, rather than a unit of ‘whole plant’). Poorter & Navas take the latter approach (Saxe et al., 2001; Jablonski et al., 2002). Using a meta-analysis of 350 experiments in which plant responses to elevated CO2 were studied, Poorter & Navas try to explain high-CO2 growth enhancement that ranges from 30% to 300%. Only 18% of the total variance in this response could be explained using species as a random factor – in other words, 82% of the total variance was due to factors other than interspecific variability. Using statistically based models, they show that a large portion of the variance is due to plant-to-plant variation in relative growth rate (i.e. intraspecific variation). There is an important experimental message here – the sampling protocols of most past studies have been inadequate to characterize the true species mean. However, there is also a more fundamental message – intraspecific variability in growth rate is relatively unexplored as an important component in the ecophysiological response of plants to their environment. Clear patterns emerged from the Poorter & Navas analysis with regard to functional groups, and certain traits appeared to correlate more strongly with an enhanced growth response to elevated CO2. In general, C4 plants exhibit less of a growth response to elevated CO2 than C3 plants; this conclusion has been lodged in the ecophysiological conventional wisdom for some time now, but Poorter & Navas provide synthetic validation across an unprecedented number of independent studies. The trait most able to predict a species’ growth response to elevated CO2, whether present in herbaceous or woody species, is the inherent relative growth rate (i.e. species with the highest growth rates in normal CO2 exhibited the strongest growth response to elevated CO2). Presumably, genetic controls over traits such as short cell-cycle time, which underlie rapid growth rates, also facilitate maximum capacities for utilizing increased C assimilation rates. With the correlational framework provided by the Poorter & Navas study, the stage is set for mechanistic probes into the underlying causes of differences in relative growth rate, and thus differences in the response to elevated CO2. The oxidative power of the lower atmosphere is ultimately determined by the tropospheric O3 concentration. It is tropospheric O3 that photolyzes in the presence of UV-B radiation, causing the production of oxidative radical species, such as the hydroxyl radical and hydroperoxide radical, which ultimately drive oxidative photochemistry to form more O3. Basically, ‘it takes a little O3 to make a lot more O3’. The tropospheric O3 concentration has been increasing for several decades (Brasseur et al., 1999). This trend is traceable to human activities, particularly the emission of hydrocarbons and nitrogen oxides during the combustion of fossil fuels and biomass burning. The increase in tropospheric O3 has caused significant detriment to the primary productivity of agricultural and natural ecosystems (Furher, 2002). In a review that emphasizes physiological processes, Andersen (pp. 213–228) makes clear the fact that O3 disrupts the assimilation of C in leaves, as a primary effect, and thus decreases the supply of C to roots, as a secondary effect. In leaves, O3 is known to cause reductions in stomatal conductance and to damage photosynthetic membranes and proteins. In causing secondary leaf responses, O3 damage induces the increased use of carbohydrates to repair damage, synthesize antioxidant compounds and compensate for tissue loss (O3 is also known to inhibit phloem transport, although the causal mechanisms are still unclear). The net result of O3-induced inhibition to these leaf-focused processes is to reduce the rate of carbohydrate transport to below-ground tissues, causing concomitant reductions in root biomass and root carbohydrate storage pools. Andersen spends a considerable portion of his review discussing the potential ramifications of decreased carbohydrate transport to roots on higher–order below-ground interactions, including infection by mycorrhizal fungi, decomposition of leaf litter and integrated connections in soil food webs. Very little research has actually been done on the effects of O3 on these interactions, so Andersen takes the approach of synthesizing fundamental research on the processes that compose the interactions, with clearly articulated hypotheses about the anticipated effect of elevated O3 concentrations. Basic principles underlying C allocation and source–sink dynamics can be used as a predictive framework in this regard, providing the basis for broadly synthetic predictions with wide-ranging ecophysiological effects. It is clear from Andersen's review that synthetic approaches, founded on the economics of C relations, are likely to yield large dividends in the study of the effects of O3, a field that has been hampered by disparate results with few central organizing principles. As an example, consider the issue as to how the formation of mycorrhizas is influenced by, and in turn influences, plant responses to elevated O3. Intuitively, decreases in the rate by which carbohydrates are transported to roots should, in turn, decrease the potential for infection by mycorrhizal fungi. However, Andersen points out that numerous studies have shown an increase in mycorrhizas under O3 stress, although it tends to be a transitory increase. Andersen offers the hypothesis that the transient increase is due to a short-term pulse in the availability of root carbohydrate reserves to mycorrhizal fungi immediately after initiation of the O3 stress. According to the hypothesis, this pulse is an expected response if decreased carbohydrate transport to roots causes the down-regulation of hexose metabolism genes in roots, but the mobilization of root carbohydrate reserves remains constant, or increases. This example makes clear the potential for integrated plant C relations to explain what might otherwise appear to be distinct O3-induced processes (inhibition of photosynthesis and stimulation of mycorrhizas) mitigated by separate above- and below-ground responses. As biology becomes more complex and fractured into subdisciplines, synthetic approaches are all the more needed and appreciated. No field has grown and fractured more than plant ecophysiology – in the mere 30 yr since its emergence from a core of concepts involving plant C and water relations, the field finds itself now as a sphere of widely displaced boundaries, often with little semblance of a core. Ecophysiologists have diffused upward in large numbers to fill mechanistic needs in the fields of biogeochemistry and global earth systems, and downwards to explain the functional significance of sequenced and mapped genes in the fields of genomics and molecular systematics. The societal needs in these areas are immense and pressing, leading to unprecedented funding opportunities for scientists in all disciplines. The intellectual domain of a discipline, however, is only capable of stretching so far as these opportunities are pursued. In the case of plant ecophysiology, the intellectual core represented by plant C relations still stands as a powerful organizing principle, capable of stimulating well articulated foundations upon which some of the most recent, state-of-the-art syntheses can occur. Future progress in deciphering the mechanistic underpinnings of earth processes and their relationship to human-driven change will no doubt receive considerable benefit from intuitive, well-tested concepts that were pioneered during the formative phases of plant ecophysiology.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Russell K. Monson (2003) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: