Key result
Reading echocardiogram recordings with knowledge of sequence overestimated the change in left ventricular mass compared to blinded reading.
Why the study?
Does the mode of reading echocardiographic tracings (blinded vs unblinded to sequence) affect the measured regression of left ventricular mass in patients with LVH?
Observational
Blind to treatment and sequence
Does the mode of reading echocardiographic tracings (blinded vs unblinded to sequence) affect the measured regression of left ventricular mass in patients with LVH?
Echocardiographic evaluation of left ventricular mass regression in clinical trials should be performed blinded to the sequence of examinations to prevent significant overestimation of treatment effects.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Blinded echocardiogram reading prevents overestimation of LV mass regression; confirms requirement for sequence blinding in all future LVH trials.
OBJECTIVE: Large trials on left ventricular hypertrophy (LVH) regression are indispensable to allow accurate evaluation of the different classes of treatments. Such a trial, the LIVE study, gave us the opportunity to examine the influence of the mode of reading of the echo tracings on results and to underline the value of two initial recordings performed at entry. METHODS: The LIVE study was designed to compare 1.5 mg indapamide SR with 20 mg enalapril on the regression of LVH evaluated echocardiographically. M-mode tracings of the left ventricle were performed at selection and after a 2 week placebo run-in. Recordings were read by investigators and by three experts all through the study, and finally read again by the three experts blind to treatment and sequence. RESULTS: The two initial examinations produced an estimate of the reproducibility of the measurement of the left ventricular mass (LVM) that can be proposed as an indicator of overall quality provided no patients are excluded. The standard deviation of the differences between these two estimates of LVM was 52 g. These two examinations may also help quantify regression to the mean, which was not significant for the whole group. Knowledge of the sequence of examinations overestimates the change in LVM with treatment, as shown by comparison of measurements carried out during quality control with the measurements made blind (-19 +/- 52 versus -6 +/- 53 g, P <0.01). CONCLUSIONS: The comparison of two initial echoes at entry allow one to define a quality criteria for such trials and to quantify a possible regression to the mean. The reading of recordings with knowledge of sequence significantly overestimates LVM variations on treatment.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gosse et al. (2003) conducted an observational in Left ventricular hypertrophy (LVH). Reading of recordings with knowledge of sequence vs. Reading blind to treatment and sequence was evaluated on Change in left ventricular mass (LVM) (p=<0.01). Reading echocardiogram recordings with knowledge of sequence overestimated the change in left ventricular mass compared to blinded reading.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: