Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Presented at the 2004 BTLS International Trauma Conference. Chicago IL October 2004. INTRODUCTION The origins of modern tactical emergency care arguably date back to 1792 and the work of Baron Dominique Jean Larrey, Surgeon-General to Napoleon's Army of the Rhine [1]. In addition to developing the guiding principles of modern field triage, Larrey developed a dedicated corps to treat and evacuate casualties during battle. At Konigsberg, Larrey personally led the ambulance volantes into the field. Unfortunately, this innovative approach was not adopted in the United States, and in 1862, approximately 3000 wounded troops were left untreated for 3 days during the second battle of Bull Run [1]. By Vietnam, the concept of casualty care under fire and rapid evacuation and resuscitation, coupled with appropriate field triage, help reduce mortality rates to 1%, down from 4.7% in World War 2 [2]. Despite both advances in military casualty care and the development of civilian law enforcement tactical units, little thought was provided towards dedicated medical care under fire in the civilian setting. In a survey of special weapons and tactics (SWAT) teams operating in the 200 largest U.S. metropolitan areas, 69% of unit commanders indicated that casualty care was managed by civilian ambulance crews on stand-by in a secure location [3]. In 94% of cases, prehospital care providers had no specialty training and were unable to enter the so-called “hot-zone”. During the Columbine tragedy, tactical operators were forced to extract victims to a more Resident And Faculty Involvement In Tactical Emergency Medical Support: A Survey Of U.S. Emergency Medicine Residency Programs 2 of 9 secure location for EMS triage and treatment [4]. Tactical emergency medical support (TEMS) has been defined as “comprehensive out-of-hospital medical support of law enforcement tactical teams during training and special operations” [5]. The first formal TEMS training course was held in 1989, and co-sponsored by the Los Angeles Sheriff's Department and the National Tactical Officer's Association [6]. Since that time, there has been a tremendous growth in the field, including the development of the Department of Defense-endorsed Counter Narcotics Tactical Operations Medical Support Program (CONTOMS), numerous private TEMS training programs at the national and international levels, and the development of the emergency medical technician – tactical (EMT-T) standard [7,8,9,10]. TEMS has become an integrated aspect of some emergency medical systems (Figure 1). Figure 1 Figure 1: Acceptance of TEMS Within Mainstream EMS. Metro Toronto EMS ALS ambulance with formal “tactical” designation. Such units respond to routine EMS calls, but are diverted to tactical operations when they arise. The role of physicians in the development and maintenance of TEMS programs has increasingly come to the forefront [9,10,11,12]. In January 1999, the National Association of EMS Physicians established a task force to exam TEMS-specific issues [13]. The American College of Emergency Physicians, in June 2004, recognized TEMS as “essential component of military and tactical law enforcement teams” [14]. Similarly, the Emergency Medicine Resident's Association endorsed a resolution on the importance of TEMS in May 2004 [15]. In light of recent awareness of both TEMS and the role of physicians in TEMS, we attempted to determine faculty and resident physician involvement with TEMS at accredited U.S. allopathic emergency medicine residencies. METHODS In November and December 2003, a 12 question emailbased survey was sent to all 126 accredited allopathic emergency medicine residencies in the United States, as determined by the Society of Academic Emergency Medicine (SAEM) residency web site. Follow-up email was sent to non-respondents 3 weeks after initial contact. Data were tabulated in a Microsoft Excel spreadsheet (Microsoft Corp, 2000). Response data was analyzed using descriptive statistics. For categorical variables, chi square and Fisher's exact test were used, and a P value of less than or equal to 0.05 deemed to be statistically significant. All analyses were performed with SPSS for Windows 9.01 Standard version (SPSS inc 1989-1999). The study was reviewed and approved by the Mayo Clinic Institutional Review Board. RESULTS A total of 82 programs replied to the email survey, for a response rate of 65%. Of the responding programs, 51% and 28% of programs reported faculty and resident involvement with TEMS respectively. The majority (74.5%) of program directors viewed physician involvement in TEMS as either positive or very positive (Table 1). Program directors felt that physician involvement in TEMS was viewed positively by their institution 51.1% of the time (p = 0.89, two-tailed t test). Fifty-five percent of program directors felt that the local community viewed physician involvement in TEMS favorably (p = 0.74, twotailed t test). Figure 2 Table 1: Emergency Medicine Residency Program Director View of Physician Involvement in TEMS. Nearly one third (31.1%) of respondents reporting using Resident And Faculty Involvement In Tactical Emergency Medical Support: A Survey Of U.S. Emergency Medicine Residency Programs 3 of 9 TEMS opportunities as a resident recruitment tool during the application and interview process. Of these programs, 100% reported faculty involvement in TEMS while 85.7% reported resident involvement. In contrast, 67.9% of programs who did not utilize TEMS opportunities as a recruiting tool reported faculty involvement (p = 0.48, Chi square), while 32.1% reported resident involvement (p = 0.10, Chi square). Fifty-seven percent (57%) of programs with emergency medical services (EMS) fellowships provided TEMS exposure. No statistical difference existed between programs with and without EMS fellowships for faculty (p = 0.3, Chi square) or resident (p = 0.6, Chi square) involvement. Six programs reported offering TEMS-specific fellowships. Nine programs expressed an interest in developing TEMS opportunities. Cited advantages of TEMS involvement were community service, improved interactions with law enforcement, and expanded educational opportunities within emergency medicine (Table 2). A number of individuals viewed no specific advantage from physician involvement in TEMS. The most frequently cited disadvantages were time commitments, expense, and the hazardous nature of TEMS (Table 3). One residency program director felt that TEMS conflicted with “sound physician ethics.” Table 2: Advantages of Physician Involvement in TEMS, as Perceived by Residency Directors Community service, support for EMS and law enforcement, new way to teach EMS to residents, application of disaster and WMD skills, use combat medic skills with new technology transferred from military use, and basis for new breed of pre-hospital provider ready for terrorism first responder situations. I don't know enough sounds interesting Opportunity to participate in another amazing facet of EM
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
A 2005 study studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: