Behavioral study reveals distinct crossmodal workflows between web search and generative AI in student translators, suggesting performance depends on tool coordination rather than modality dominance.
This study examines crossmodal interaction between web search and GenAI chat during translation. Thirty-six participants completed a translation task with access to both modalities. Queries and prompts were coded using the Community of Inquiry framework and analyzed using lag sequential analysis and epistemic network analysis; translation quality was assessed with COMET and human ratings. Based on interaction-time shares, participants were classified as Web-dominant, GenAI-dominant, or Balanced. Web-dominant users followed an augmentative pattern, verifying via search with minimal social presence; GenAI-dominant users displayed an assimilative pattern, converging on GenAI with active feedback; while Balanced users demonstrated an integrative dual-hub workflow, circulating between web verification and GenAI synthesis. Overall quality and task time did not differ significantly across categories, though Balanced users showed the highest cultural-adequacy ratings. Exploratory PCA indicated category-specific quality-related behaviors, suggesting that performance depends more on how modalities are coordinated than on modality dominance itself.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Cai et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: