Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Techno-economic modeling reveals hydrogen achieves the highest exergy efficiency while electrofuels carry heavy cost penalties in long-haul trucks, indicating biodiesel is the nearest cost competitor.
Five pathways—diesel, renewable hydrogen, green ammonia, Fischer–Tropsch e-diesel, and B100 waste cooking oil fatty acid methyl ester (WCO-FAME)—were compared on a common service basis using a reduced-order engine exergy model, a partial techno-economic cost model, and 10,000 Latin hypercube simulation samples; each alternative was paired with diesel by sample index. The results were normalised to 1 kWh of net brake work (kWhb) and 1000 tonne-kilometres of freight work (1000 tkm). A carbon balance back-calculation from European Commission Vehicle Energy Consumption Calculation Tool (VECTO) monitoring data for subgroup 5-Long Haul (5-LH; a 4 × 2 tractor–semitrailer) yielded 89.31 kWhb/1000 tkm; first-order payload penalties increased this requirement to 94.79 kWhb/1000 tkm for hydrogen and 91.97 kWhb/1000 tkm for ammonia. Deterministic central-case exergy efficiencies were 43.02% for hydrogen, 39.67% for e-diesel, 39.35% for diesel, 37.56% for B100, and 33.81% for ammonia. The study-specific partial cost was expressed in 2025 EUR per 1000 tkm and included delivered fuel, maintenance, and annualised incremental vehicle capital; common fleet costs, including driver, tyre, toll, insurance, and tax costs, and externalities were excluded. Therefore, this metric was not a full freight cost or tariff. Deterministic central-case costs were EUR 25.85/1000 tkm for diesel, EUR 26.72/1000 tkm for B100, EUR 58.64/1000 tkm for hydrogen, EUR 59.84/1000 tkm for ammonia, and EUR 67.44/1000 tkm for e-diesel. Hydrogen exceeded diesel in exergy efficiency in 96.50% of the paired simulation samples; all three electrofuel pathways were costlier than diesel in every paired simulation sample, whereas B100 was cheaper than diesel in 35.62% of the paired simulation samples. Thus, hydrogen led in exergy efficiency, diesel in cost under the defined partial economic boundary, and B100 was the closest cost competitor. These are conditional model-screening results rather than a completed comparative life-cycle assessment: no quantitative life-cycle impact assessment (LCIA), environmental ranking or marginal abatement cost result is reported.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Oğuz Kürşat Demirci (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: