Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Panel study finds simple persistence models outperform machine learning algorithms during final holdout testing, indicating that complex environmental models do not consistently beat historical...
Monthly PM 10 prediction was evaluated for Istanbul and Ankara with a 2020 − 2023 city-month panel combining air-quality, meteorological, and traffic-intensity variables. The calendar index comprised 96 city-months, of which 92 had observed PM 10 . Missing PM 10 targets were excluded from scoring. The primary analysis required an observed one-month PM 10 lag; a sensitivity analysis permitted linearly interpolated values only for lag construction. Persistence, city-specific AR(1), and Random Forest models were assessed in five expanding-window rolling-origin folds and a ten-month chronological holdout. Predictive R 2 was calculated as 1 − SSE/SST. In pooled cross-validation, Random Forest achieved RMSE = 6.89 µg/m 3 , MAE = 5.53 µg/m 3 , and R 2 = 0.50; corresponding values were 7.40, 5.68, and 0.43 for AR(1), and 8.65, 6.65, and 0.22 for persistence. In the final holdout, persistence achieved the lowest error (RMSE = 4.57 µg/m 3 ; MAE = 3.71 µg/m 3 ; R 2 = 0.55), followed by Random Forest (5.87, 4.71, and 0.26) and AR(1) (6.20, 5.14, and 0.17). Block-bootstrap intervals supported an AR(1) RMSE reduction in pooled cross-validation; holdout differences from persistence included zero. Model ranking therefore varied between development and final holdout periods, with persistence providing the strongest holdout performance.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hümeyra BOLAKAR TOSUN (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: