Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
It is February 1998. I am sitting in the office of a United States Senator in Washington D.C., about to discuss the U.S. Endangered Species Act, and wondering what I—a conservation biologist with training in freshwater fish ecology but no political experience or inclinations whatsoever—am doing in such a place. My graduate training in evolutionary and population ecology certainly did not anticipate this or prepare me for this day. As I rush from one Congressional office to another to speak to our elected representatives or their “staffers,” I feel ill-prepared to influence national policy. Far out of my home range and native habitat, with my customary jeans and casual shirts in my home closet, wearing my only business suit (reserved for politicking and funerals), I dutifully try to convince those in power that reauthorization of a stronger Endangered Species Act is critical and that certain provisions of the proposed law are weak and scientifically indefensible. Overall, the effort goes well and people seem to listen, but my first foray deep into the jungles of Washington politics left me with more questions than answers and more convinced than ever that conservation scientists need to inject good science into policy, and do it very quickly. But therein lies the rub: largely, we do not know how to do this; largely, we are naive to the process. I suggest that if we—the premier conservation scientists in the world who seek and possess the best scientific information on the state of nature—do not actively and aggressively put our knowledge to use in development of public policy and legislation, and do not do it soon, then we are failing society and posterity in what should be a major responsibility. Some argue that as scientists we simply should generate the information and leave it for society to pick and choose what they need, that we should stay out of the policy realm and go about our business as we always have. I disagree. The stakes are too high and the needs too great to pretend that we solely can be objective and dispassionate observers of the world without using our scientific knowledge to shape our destiny. The time has long passed when we could merely pontificate in our journals, impress our colleagues, and proclaim that we are above the political fray. Most conservation biologists have made the transition from staid observer to participant at some level. Whether writing letters to the editor of our local newspapers, giving environmental talks to civic organizations, or actively protecting natural areas, we have tried to influence how society perceives the natural world and behaves toward it. Some have gone further: they have entered the policy realm by testifying before government committees, advising the legislative or executive branches of government, or accepting leadership positions in management and research agencies. But to a large extent the challenge yet remains for most conservation biologists individually, and especially the field collectively, to determine our proper roles in helping to develop scientifically sound environmental policy, and to learn how to do it effectively. We are, I think, on the cusp of a major historical shift in the role our science plays in the world, a shift that will place us squarely in the hotbeds of decision making. The scientific information we have to offer is too central, too important, and too desperately needed by society for us not to become major players. But do we know what to do and how to do it? As we move into the policy arena we are struggling to become effective. As scientists, we generally are not trained in such areas and do not think in ways that predispose us to be successful in the world of the “policy wonks.” We are making mistakes but we also are learning from them. And we had better learn quickly. I predict we will experience a rapid change in our relationship to policy making in the next few years and that we will become intimately involved as the complexity and difficulty of the issues demand that science and objective knowledge be used and effectively incorporated into policy. Based on my limited experiences to date (including a second trip in April 1998 with six other scientists to help advance an ancient-forest biodiversity bill), I offer a few personal observations regarding the policy process: it is messy, confusing, slow, painful, frustrating, illogical, and fraught with human foibles and biases. The old adage that “those who like laws and sausages should not watch either one being made” is absolutely true. Unconditional persistence is needed, as is an understanding of the world of policy makers and a willingness to work within it and follow its (to us) strange rules. The policy process simply does not function as science does: logical deduction and induction, experimental manipulation of single parameters, determination of relationships among dependent and independent variables, conclusions drawn from objective data analysis, and other such foundations of scientific thought hold minor importance in a world driven by voter satisfaction, campaign dollars, demands of constituents, the power of special interests, and political relationships. The ecological incongruity of, for example, a “no surprises policy” that provides decades-long guarantees to private landowners in habitat conservation plans in the United States, despite the known presence of continual ecological change and surprises, matters little to an elected official merely trying to strike a compromise that will satisfy his constituents while maneuvering a bill through Congress. If we expect logic and scientific evidence to hold primacy over political intricacies, we will make little progress. We have to learn the rules of the political road, work hard to introduce our science on those terms, and weave it into the larger complexities of politics. Although this is a daunting task, we do have a major advantage: science is held in high regard by society and most political leaders, and they are quite receptive to our messages. Over the last few years, sign-on letter writing has become one popular way for scientists to engage in policy. I frequently receive from colleagues a letter via FAX or email urging me to sign a letter to the President, members of Congress, or other high officials regarding environmental policy. I have even written and circulated some of these letters myself, and I believe some have been effective in gaining the attention of the right people at the right time to either stop bad policy or improve it. But there is a danger to these sign-on letters: they are a bit too easy and we may be seeing too many. As we barrage Washington, D.C., or other world capitals with such efforts, I fear their effect will become diluted. I also believe that some letters have not been well done or have been misinformed on the issues; there is in fact no formal peer review process or quality control for these letters, and a few have more closely resembled activist rather than scientific positions. We need to be careful not to simply take the easy way out and send off a letter any time an issue arises; we must think deeply and determine the most effective routes. Letters are only the first step; we need to move to other levels of engagement as well, such as serious education of the press (including press conferences to release scientific information on important issues), direct discussions with political leaders, and perhaps permanent, organized, and funded scientific presences in national capitals where policy is constantly being forged and modified. This latter point is especially important, I have learned, because a major component of political effectiveness is developing and maintaining networks, contacts, and personal relationships over the long haul. We had better learn to do this effectively or our science will be left out. This interface between science and society is the most critical endeavor we can collectively pursue over the coming decades. Our best science must be made accessible to and understandable by society at large and policy makers in particular. Our knowledge must be put to good use in forging more sensible relationships with the natural world, rather than simply remaining in journals that ultimately collect dust on library shelves. How can we as a scientific society become more effective and influential in using science to inform policy? I invite a dialogue in this journal on how we can make such a transition and thus improve the chances for a sane and livable world for humanity and biodiversity.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gary K. Meffe (1998) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: