Why the study?
Does deep water running alter maximal physiologic responses compared to treadmill running in trained men and women?
Does deep water running alter maximal physiologic responses compared to treadmill running in trained men and women?
Deep water running elicits lower maximal heart rates and VO2max than treadmill running, suggesting caution when using land-based heart rate targets for water training.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Attenuated maximal HR and VO2 in deep-water running may warrant adjusted targets; leaves open optimal intensity prescriptions for aquatic training.
Maximal physiologic responses to treadmill running and deep water running using a flotation device were compared in 12 trained men and 12 trained women. Although the men had significantly higher ventilation volumes, VO2max (liters of oxygen per minute and milliliters of oxygen per kilogram per minute), there were no significant differences in maximal heart rates or respiratory exchange ratios between the sexes. Significantly lower ventilation volumes, VO2max (LO2.min-1 and mlO2.kg-1.min-1), and heart rates were obtained in response to maximal water running compared to treadmill running, regardless of gender. Neither the men's nor women's maximal respiratory exchange ratios were significantly different between modes. The analysis of variance indicated that there were no significant interactions for any of the maximal responses to the tests between the sexes. The magnitude of these differences is similar to that found between treadmill running and cycling ergometry and should not preclude deep water running as a training technique. Caution, however, is advised if the training intensity is to be prescribed on the basis of land-determined heart rates.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Butts et al. (1991) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: