Key result
Preoperative ACE inhibitor treatment is associated with improved preoperative renal function and does not independently contribute to low postoperative creatinine clearance after aortic surgery.
Why the study?
Does preoperative ACE inhibitor treatment cause postoperative renal dysfunction in patients undergoing elective aortic surgery?
Does preoperative ACE inhibitor treatment cause postoperative renal dysfunction in patients undergoing elective aortic surgery?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This letter challenges the conclusion that preoperative ACE inhibitors independently cause postoperative renal dysfunction after aortic surgery, suggesting fluid imbalance is the primary mechanism.
ACE Inhibitor and Postoperative Renal Dysfunction To the Editor: Cittanova et al. (1) have recently addressed the issue of preoperative risk factors of renal dysfunction after elective aortic surgery. Chronic inhibition of angiotensin-inhibiting enzyme (ACE) was the only factor significantly associated with postoperative renal impairment. The mechanism of renal dysfunction after aortic surgery is multifactorial, related to preoperative risk factors like cardiac and renal dysfunction, intraoperative management (aortic cross clamping time, fluid loading, transfusion requirement) and postoperative incidence of multiple organ dysfunction (2,3). The unique responsibility of the preoperative ACE inhibitor treatment for postoperative renal impairment appears thus surprising and may not be actually supported by the data shown in the article. There are at least three major arguments against the authors’ conclusions. First, the univariate analysis between patients with and those without a postoperative decrease in renal function (PORD) identifies two factors: preoperative creatinine clearance and ACE inhibitor treatment. However the preoperative creatinine clearance is significantly more rapid in the patients with PORD. Then, in the multivariate analysis, only preoperative treatment with ACE inhibitor was significantly associated with a postoperative decrease in renal function. The multivariate analysis result suggests that the better preoperative glomerular filtration rate in the patients who develop a PORD is related to the ACE inhibitor treatment. Second, fluid imbalance is the primary mechanism of renal impairment in patients treated with ACE inhibitors. Intravascular fluids are given for the intraoperative period, but the amount given postoperatively is not known. Moreover, without any data about renal function between POD0 to POD7, it is not possible to know whether the renal dysfunction is related to the intraoperative period or to the first postoperative days. The fluid balance during the first postoperative days is a crucial point for the renal function a fortiori when the ACE inhibitor treatment is resumed early in the postoperative period of an abdominal surgery. Third, besides the serious limitations exposed above, a postoperative decreased renal function as assessed by a creatinine clearance <60 mL/mm is not related to the preoperative ACE inhibitor treatment but to factors already identified in the literature (age, increased preoperative plasma creatinine level) (2,4). Therefore the data presented by Cittanova et al. show that ACE inhibitor is associated with an improved preoperative renal function and does not contribute to a low postoperative creatinine clearance. However, the treatment should be managed with a particular attention to the fluid balance when it is resumed early in the postoperative period. Pascal Colson Frédérique Ryckwaert
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Frédérique Ryckwaert (2002) conducted a letter in Postoperative renal dysfunction after elective aortic surgery. Preoperative ACE inhibitor treatment vs. No preoperative ACE inhibitor treatment was evaluated on Postoperative decrease in renal function (PORD). Preoperative ACE inhibitor treatment is associated with improved preoperative renal function and does not independently contribute to low postoperative creatinine clearance after aortic surgery.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: