This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
HISTORY AND PHYSICAL EXAMINATION A 30-year-old man presented with limping, intermittent local pain, and swelling in the left lower leg. The pain had been present about 2 years, but the swelling had been obvious for only about 6 months. The patient denied any history of major fevers. Ten years before presentation, he had a right femoral fracture due to a motor vehicle accident and underwent surgery with a locked femoral nail, which resulted in complete healing. Physical examination revealed a tender, tough, immobile mass with a diameter of about 9 cm placed in the middle of the anterior crural area. Radiographs and computed tomography (CT) scans were obtained (Figs 1, 2). The thorax and abdomen were scanned for any primary or secondary lesions.Fig 1A: B. (A) Anteroposterior and (B) lateral radiographs of the left tibia taken preoperatively reveal the multiloculated, or bunch of grapes, appearance of the lesion.Fig 2: A preoperative CT scan of the left lower leg shows the bone is diffusely expanded and the cortex is thinned at all margins. Note the endosteal irregularity, expansion of the bone, and the combined bone-soft tissue islands with calcifications in the medullar cavity.Based on the history, physical examination, and imaging studies, what is the differential diagnosis? IMAGING INTERPRETATION There was a multiloculated mixed lytic and sclerotic lesion in the midshaft of the tibia with a somewhat wide zone of transition, expansile deformity, and areas of prominent endosteal thinning but no obvious cortical destruction or fracture. The lesion measured approximately 12 × 3 cm and the lytic component resembled a “cluster of grapes” (Fig 1). Axial CT images demonstrated expansile deformity of the involved tibia with infiltration of the marrow space by a mixed attenuation mass with some linear areas of calcification. There was cortical thinning with areas of irregular endosteal erosion but no significant periosteal reaction or cortical destruction. There was prominence of the surrounding soft tissues particularly anteriorly with some suggestion of cystic changes (Fig 2). DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS Ewing's sarcoma Fibrous dysplasia Osteofibrous dysplasia Adamantinoma Hydatid disease Desmoplastic fibroma We performed histologic evaluation of samples obtained intraoperatively (Figs 3, 4). ptl]Based on the history, physical examination, imaging studies, and histology, what is the diagnosis and how should this lesion be treated?Fig 3: An intraoperative photograph shows the multiple vesicular masses in the bone. The outer membranes of the cysts were smooth and thin.Fig 4A: B. (A) A histologic section of the splenetic lesion shows the inner lining of the cyst wall composed of the germinative membrane (white arrows) in contact with daughter embryos (black arrows) (Stain, hematoxylin and eosin; original magnification, ×100). (B) A histologic section of the tibial mass shows the lamellar structure of the cyst wall, the daughter embryos (black arrows), and sequestrated structures (white arrows) (Stain, hematoxylin and eosin; original magnification, ×200).See page 251 for diagnosis and treatment. Continuation of ORP conference from page 250. HISTOLOGY EVALUATION Macroscopic evaluation revealed multiple cysts of variable size with a thin, smooth outer membrane (Fig 3). Sections of the splenetic lesion stained with hematoxylin and eosin (Fig 4A) revealed the inner layer of the cyst wall (germinal membrane) in contact with daughter embryos. Sections of the bone lesion stained with hematoxylin and eosin (Fig 4B) revealed the laminar cyst wall composed of a layer of dense fibrous tissue. There were also daughter embryos in the inner layer of the cyst. DIAGNOSIS Hydatid disease of the spleen and tibial shaft DISCUSSION AND TREATMENT Hydatid disease is a zoonotic infestation caused by the tapeworm echinococcus. Two species, Echinococcus granulosus and Echinococcus multilocularis, are known to affect humans.26,27 E. granulosus is the most common and E. multilocularis does not affect the bone.27 The disease is endemic and more commonly seen in people in rural areas. The lung and the liver are the most commonly affected organs. Primary splenic involvement is rare and accounts for less than 2% of patients.12,19 The incidence of skeleton involvement is reported to be between 0.5% and 4% from different countries.1,14,15,26,30 The spine is the most common location involved in the skeleton, followed by the pelvis and the skull.6,13,15,26 Only about 28% of bone hydatid cases involve the long bones.30 The initial lesion is almost always metaphyseal or epiphyseal.31 Pure diaphyseal involvement is extremely rare. Ewing's sarcoma is a highly malignant primitive neuroectodermal tumor.18 It is mostly located in the diaphysis with a radiographic appearance of a lytic, centrally located lesion that causes multilayered periostitis, or the so-called “onion skin reaction.”18,20 The microscopic appearance of Ewing's sarcoma is one of densely packed, small blue cells with little cytoplasm, packed in sheets.20 Primary non-Hodgkin's lymphoma of the bone often mimics Ewing's sarcoma and shows a destructive osseous pattern, such as cortical erosion, periostitis, and soft tissue invasion.10 However, in our patient, the chronic nature of the process and the absence of a periosteal reaction excluded both Ewing's sarcoma and primary lymphoma of the bone. Fibrous dysplasia is a common benign skeletal lesion, which can be seen in either monostotic or polyostotic forms. Lesions show varying degrees of hazy density with a ground-glass quality, although some may appear almost completely radiolucent or sclerotic.7,9 Bowing of the weightbearing bones are common.20 Fibrous dysplasia can closely resemble long-standing cases of hydatosis, in which the marrow cavity is extensively invaded by the parasite and the cortex is thinned.21,31 Histologically, fibrous dysplasia is characterized by immature, woven bone that is unable to differentiate into organized lamellar bone and the presence of irregular trabeculae.18 Osteofibrous dysplasia is another cause of osteolytic lesions of the tibial diaphysis. Pathologic specimens from sites affected by osteofibrous dysplasia show bland fibroblastic tissue associated with immature woven bone rimmed by osteoblasts.16 However, the disease is mostly seen in skeletally immature patients.20 Adamantioma is a rare, low-grade malignant neoplasm, which should be suspected in a lytic “bubbly” diaphyseal lesion, particularly in the middle third of the tibia.5,18 The lesion is usually multiloculated and expansile, occupies the medullary cavity, and thins especially the anterior cortex.18,20 Satellite lesions are common and aid differential diagnosis from other tumoral conditions.20 However, these satellite lesions can be easily confused with the bunch of grapes appearance of hydatid disease of the bone. Distant metastasis is common and biopsy is needed for an exact diagnostic differentiation from other osteolytic lesions of the tibial diaphysis.5 Desmoplastic fibroma is a rare, locally aggressive tumor. Although most frequently reported in the mandible, desmoplastic fibroma is seen in the long bones.28 On plain radiographs, these fibromas are seen as expansile radiolucent lesions with thinning of the cortex and a well-defined margination.22 Many have a honeycombed appearance because of internal bony septations.11,28 However, diaphyseal involvement of this tumor is extremely infrequent. These tumors generally have a narrow zone of transition,28 which permitted differentiation from our case. Histologically, the tumor is composed of fibroblasts and collagen fibers forming wavy bundles.22 Hydatid disease of the bone is mostly asymptomatic until the disease advances.1,2,27 Transient pain is the most frequent symptom.2 Pathologic fracture is a common presentation. The diagnosis can be easily overlooked unless there is a strong element of suspicion and is usually determined and confirmed only after surgery or biopsy.30 The delay and the lack of preoperative diagnosis affect the outcome of the treatment by making preoperative planning impossible. The appearance of hydatosis in bone is nonspecific and mimics tumoral and other inflammatory conditions.8,12 Direct radiographs, CT, and magnetic resonance imaging are the imaging tools for the diagnosis of hydatid disease of the bone.13,24 In plain films, hydatid disease in bone produces a well-defined, multiloculated, expansile, osteolytic lesion.19 In advanced stages, periosteal thickening and perilesional sclerosis are seen.15,21 Recurrence of hydatid bone disease is very common.2,27,30 The overlooked primary focus may be a causative factor for recurrence or reinfestations. Scanning of the chest, abdomen, and pelvis by CT and bones by bone scintigraphy is mandatory. Echinococcus hemagglutination and total and specific immunoglobulin E levels are considered preoperative diagnostic parameters of the disease.15,25 These tests are frequently false negative in the early stages of the disease.17 Treatment should be combined with albendazol before and after surgery if possible.1,13-15,27 Albendazole is a benzimidazole derivative, which kills the germinative membrane and daughter cells of echinococci by limiting glucose uptake.27 Chemotherapy before surgery is desirable but usually not possible, as most patients are only diagnosed during surgery. In our patient, echinococcus hemaglutination tests were positive preoperatively, so albendazole was initiated at a dosage of 10 mg/kg/day 1 month before surgery. The thorax, abdomen, and pelvis were scanned by CT and scintigraphy was used to evaluate any other bony invasion. The abdominal CT revealed a 5 × 4 cystic lesion in the spleen (Fig 5). The combined surgery was planned together with general surgeons. In the first operation, the weakened bone from the anterior region of the tibia was sacrificed. The medulla was filled with a membranous and vesicular mass (Fig 3). Cautious aspiration of the fluid was carried out with drainage needles. Curettage and swabbing with 20% saline solution was applied, leaving only the posterior wall of the tibia at the midshaft of the bone. Curettage was continued to approximately 5 mm of healthy bone. The cavity was filled with slow- polymerizing polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) when it was semisolid. After applying heat for about 3 minutes, the PMMA was removed before it was solid and the remaining cement was curetted with bone. A femoral cortical allograft measuring 12 × 3 cm covered the anterior window of the defect area as a support. The splenectomy was performed at the same session.Fig 5: A multilocular lesion measuring 5 × 4 cm was found in the spleen, as shown in this abdominal CT scan.There was no sign of radiographic union with the cortical allograft 6 months after the surgery, so a second operation was planned (Fig 6). In the second operation, nonunion of the cortical allograft was confirmed. Unreamed locked intramedullary nailing and a mixture of cancellous autograft from the innominate bone and 30 mL of demineralized bone matrix were applied. The pathologic assessment indicated no signs of hydatosis at this procedure. After 3 months, weightbearing was encouraged. After 4 months, the defect began fill with callus. After 12 months, the defect was completely filled with new regenerated bone and there was no functional deficiency. At the latest visit, 34 months after initial treatment, the absence of relapse was taken as an indication of complete healing (Fig 7).Fig 6: A radiograph taken 6 months after the first operation shows nonunion with the cortical allograft. Based on this evidence, the patient underwent a second procedure.Fig 7A: B. (A) Lateral and (B) anteroposterior radiographs of the left tibia taken 34 months after the initial treatment show complete healing.The lesion's multiloculated, or cluster of grapes, appearance without sharp margins and calcifications in the surrounding soft tissue were sufficient cause for suspicion in our patient (Fig 1). However, pure diaphyseal involvement is extremely rare for bone hydatosis and was confusing in our case. The spleen was also an unexpected site as a primary focus, instead of the liver or the lungs. It would probably have been even harder to preoperatively diagnose hydatid disease if this case had not been seen in Turkey, a Mediterranean country placed in the endemic area. Magnetic resonance imaging is also important in demonstrating the expansion of the lesion.13,24 However, we were unable to use this diagnostic tool as our patient had implants of stainless steel due to a contralateral femoral fracture. Bone grafting is recommended by various authors,4,14,17,26 although there is disagreement as to whether the parasite may invade the graft.30 Using hypertonic saline solution in intraoperative irrigation of hydatid cysts is a common procedure, which affects by killing the cyst wall and daughter cysts.23,29 Treatment with PMMA has been used by several published authors.3,29,30 The predicted invasions of the graft induced these authors to use PMMA as a space filler in bone hydatosis. However, when the defect is excessively large, as in our patient, the cortical weakness would result in a pathologic fracture. We believe the permanent use of bone cement in extensively large bone defects is a not good option, as it does not prevent pathologic fracture. We recommend the temporary use of PMMA for its necrotizing thermal and chemical effects in these challenging cases, although this method has not been reported in the literature for hydatid disease of the bone before. It may also minimize the risk of recurrence without excessive resection of the healthy bone, as in our patient. In our patient, a locked intramedullary nail was used prophylactically, as there was an excessively large bone defect. In surgical treatment, there is a risk of encouraging further dissemination if the antigenic hydatid fluid escapes into surrounding tissues.27 The use of hardware may also increase the risk of recurrence in the same way and may carry the infestation along the tract of the implant, although this was not been stressed previously. Specifically, the intramedullary course of a nail may have a high risk of spreading the infestation distally. We suggest the use of intramedullary nails should be delayed until the absence of new cyst formation in the former cavity is confirmed, at least 3 months after systemic and local therapy. Both the diagnosis and the treatment of hydatid disease of long bones are challenging. As the disease may occur in various forms and mimics multiple diseases, the surgeon and radiologist should be aware of its unusual sites and skilled in its differential diagnosis. The orthopaedic surgeon has to make efforts to regain a weightbearing bone while attempting to heal the hydatid disease. Acknowledgments The authors thank Professor Dr. Nevres Hürriyet Aydoğan for contributions in both planning and application of the treatment and Dr. Talip Kara for his help in preparation of this report.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Alemdaroğlu et al. (2007) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: