Key result
Carotid stiffness increased more rapidly with age in women than in men, crossing over around age 45, whereas aortic and femoral stiffness showed no significant age-sex interaction.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The relationship between arterial stiffness, age, and sex differs depending on the arterial site, highlighting the need for comprehensive reference values to better assess cardiovascular risk.
The determination of aortic stiffness, through the measurement of carotid–femoral pulse wave velocity (PWV), has been recommended by the 2007 European Society of Hypertension (ESH)/International Society of Hypertension (ISH) Guidelines for the Management of Hypertension [1] in order to assess arterial damage, evaluate the level of cardiovascular risk and adapt the therapeutic strategy. Aortic stiffness was introduced into the list of subclinical organ damage [1] of these recommendations because of the large number of epidemiological studies showing its independent predictive value for cardiovascular events [2]. The measurement of carotid–femoral PWV has been considered as the ‘gold standard’ of arterial stiffness in a recent expert consensus document [3] for various reasons. It is generally accepted as the most simple, noninvasive, robust and reproducible method to determine aortic stiffness. It is a direct measurement, and it corresponds to the widely accepted propagative model of the arterial system. Measured along the aortic and aortoiliac pathway, it is the most clinically relevant, as the aorta and its first branches are what the left ventricle ‘sees’, and are thus responsible for most of the pathophysiological effects of arterial stiffness. Finally, carotid–femoral PWV has been used in epidemiological studies demonstrating the predictive value of aortic stiffness for cardiovascular events. Carotid–femoral PWV evaluates a mixed elastic/muscular behavior of the arterial tree, as it takes into account large elastic proximal arteries and distal muscular arteries. Its predictive value for cardiovascular events may differ from that of more muscular pathways. Indeed, PWV measured outside the aortic track, at the upper (carotid–radial PWV) or lower limb (femoral–tibial PWV), has no predictive value in patients with end-stage renal disease (ESRD) [4]. These discrepancies may be due to the different impact of cardiovascular risk factors on arterial stiffening according to the site of the arterial target. It has been recently reported that the aorta stiffened more than the carotid artery with age and other cardiovascular risk factors in patients with either hypertension or diabetes or both [5]. By contrast, in a small number of healthy individuals used as controls in the above study, carotid–femoral PWV and carotid stiffness provided similar information on the impact of aging on large artery stiffness [5]. Whether this later conclusion applies to a larger cohort of healthy individuals, and to other sites of measurements, remained to be determined. In addition, sex, which has proved to influence cardiovascular outcomes, may act as a confounding factor for arterial stiffening and the age–sex interaction needs to be assessed. These aspects have been carefully examined in the paper by Vermeersch et al.[6] published in this issue of Journal of Hypertension. These authors studied a large cohort of apparently healthy individuals and observed that carotid stiffness showed a significant age–sex interaction, with carotid stiffness increasing more rapidly with age in women than in men, crossing over around the age of 45. By contrast, the increase in aortic stiffness with age did not differ between men and women. In addition, no age–sex interaction was evident at the femoral site. Aortic stiffness, which is calculated through carotid–femoral PWV, is the resulting measure of various segments of the arterial system: the proximal elastic carotid artery and thoracic aorta; and the distal, more muscular, abdominal aorta and femoral artery. Thus, the lack of any significant age–sex interaction at the femoral site is consistent with the lack of age–sex interaction for carotid–femoral PWV. The article by Vermeersch et al.[6] has several strengths. First, it takes advantage of the ASKLEPIOS study [7], which investigates the arterial properties of a large number of individuals free from overt cardiovascular disease: 1131 men and 1064 women were included in this study, and benefited from a noninvasive investigation of the aorta, the carotid and the femoral arteries. Second, homogeneity and repeatability of measurements were high, as all vascular echography and applanation tonometry data were collected by a single operator in a single center. The Gent center is well known for its methodological work on the noninvasive measurement of arterial stiffness and central blood pressure (BP). Third, not only aorta and carotid arteries but also the femoral artery, a distal muscular artery prone to atherosclerosis, were investigated. Finally, gold standard measurements were performed according to consensus recommendations [3], including the calculation of carotid and femoral stiffness using local pulse pressure. Particularly, local stiffness was calculated from cross-sectional distensibility using the Bramwell–Hill equation, and put into the same unity as carotid–femoral PWV [5,6]. Thus, the main conclusion of the article by Vermeersch et al.[6], that the relation with age and sex of local and central stiffness measures is not the same over the range 35–55 in apparently healthy men and women, is well taken. This study, although conclusive, exhibits several limits. A major limitation, underlined by the authors, is the narrow age range. This may have masked a possible age–sex interaction, which would have been obvious in a broader age-range population. In addition, the upper limit of 55 may have been not high enough to allow determining the effects of menopause (mostly occurring between 45 and 55 years) on arterial stiffness. The findings of the present study by Vermeersch et al.[6] and previous related papers [6–8] provide an interesting basis for establishing normal values of arterial stiffness. The ASKLEPIOS study brings additional data to those already gathered by the Anglo-Cardiff study [9] and some others. Indeed, the measurement of aortic stiffness is recommended by the 2007 Guidelines for the Management of Hypertension, and a threshold value of 12 m/s has been selected from epidemiological studies in hypertensive patients. Whether this value applies to healthy individuals, and allows detecting patients at high cardiovascular risk despite a low score of classical cardiovascular risk factors, remains to be determined. Very likely, a lower threshold value is desirable. Large cohorts of apparently healthy individuals are needed to establish the influence of cardiovascular risk factors not only on aortic stiffness but also on local stiffness (carotid and femoral) and indices of wave reflections, including central pulse pressure and augmentation index. A broad age range, a balanced sex ratio and a large geographical area are needed to ensure the best application to the European population. The ‘Working Group on Arterial Structure and Function’ of the ESH started such a project last year and named it ‘Reference value project’. Reference values of arterial stiffness should indeed be given not only for individuals free from overt cardiovascular disease but also for patients according to their level of BP, the number of cardiovascular risk factors, and the presence/absence of metabolic syndrome, type 2 diabetes and target organ damage, consistently with the stratification of cardiovascular risk detailed in the 2007 Guidelines for the Management of Hypertension [1]. Finally, a longitudinal follow-up of these large cohorts during several years, and their meta-analysis in individual data, is the only means for determining which arterial parameter has the strongest predictive value for cardiovascular events, and which threshold value should be used for determining an excess risk in apparently healthy individuals considered as at low risk according to classical risk scores.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Stéphane Laurent (2008) conducted an editorial in Healthy individuals (n=2,195). Age and sex was evaluated on Age-sex interaction on carotid, aortic, and femoral stiffness. Carotid stiffness increased more rapidly with age in women than in men, crossing over around age 45, whereas aortic and femoral stiffness showed no significant age-sex interaction.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: