Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The purpose of this study is to reveal the structure and property of mutual reference among municipalities regarding local sports policies using social network analysis, and provide insights for the advancements of research and policy innovation.A questionnaire survey asked local sports policy departments for five frequently referred municipalities, their sport promotion plan, their latest budget, and their new projects over the past three fiscal years (2018)(2019)(2020) .The data was obtained from 248 municipalities.The referred and referring municipalities as nodes, and social network analysis measured the number of nodes, ties, cliques, network density, and degree centrality.The reference relationships visualized by NetDraw, consisting of 460 nodes and 507 ties, and identified 47 reference cliques involving three or more municipalities.The 66 highly referred municipalities with a degree centrality exceeding 7 were compared with the 248 less referred municipalities with 3 or less in terms of municipal classification and the promotion plan, budget, and new project.The geodesic distance, calculated between two municipalities in reference relationship from their latitude and longitude, was averaged 37.13±97.27km (mean±SD) , with over 90% of reference relationships (470 types) being within 86 km.Nine reference relationships exceed 177 km.Municipal classification and promotion plan are significantly related to high and less referred municipalities, but not to new projects.The average budget of highly referred municipalities (1.368±1.947millionyen) was significantly higher than that of less referred municipalities (0.393±0.612 million yen) .The national visualization revealed that mutual references were largely shaped by geographical proximity or similarity in scale, rather than by policy innovation.Nonetheless, a subset of references appeared to be informed by specific policy content.These suggested the importance of further empirical studies on policy transfer and other factors in policy innovation, and strategic approaches in policy innovation and diffusion.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Waku et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: