Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
During the revisions leading to the current diagnostic classifications ICD-10 (1, 2) and DSM-IV (3), the WHO ICD-10 Advisory Group and the DSM-IV Task Force convened for a number of meetings and discussions in order to agree and harmonize, if possible unify, the diagnostic categories and their criteria. As we know, in spite of some progress no unification was obtained. The two major classificatory systems had different aims and priorities to follow. The WHO ICD-10 had to reach an international consensus in order to be accepted by the member countries and the DSM-IV gave priority to scientific evidence and validity. The basic object of the WHO to provide a worldwide common language in psychiatry with one only, universially accepted psychiatric classification was not achieved. The two major classificatory committees agreed to disagree and let time, that is validating evidence, show which of the categories in the two systems are the most valid, having ensured satisfactory reliability of the categories by comprehensive trials of both systems (3, 4). Since the introduction of ICD-10 in 1992 and DSM-IV in 1994, validation studies of the various categories have been requested. Now a decade later still very few such studies have appeared. We therefore welcome the studies in this issue of the Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica on the classification of obsessive-compulsive disorder in childhood and adolescence and on somatoform pain disorder. The ICD and DSM classifications both have separated categories specific to childhood and adolescence, `usually first diagnosed in infancy, childhood and adolescence'. All other disorders are supposed to be identical with adult psychiatric disorders and are defined by their respective diagnostic criteria. Karl Steinberger from the Vienna University Medical School Department of Neuropsychiatry of Childhood and Adolescence has investigated the validity of the ICD-10 and DSM-IV diagnostic criteria for obsessive-compulsive disorder in 61 out-patient children and adolescents. He found low agreement (concordant validity) between the two systems. Particularly, the ICD-10 diagnostic criteria did not take the age and intellectual development of children and young adolescents into consideration and were unable to diagnose more than half of the sample by the prober category. The DSM-IV criteria fared much better and were found superior to the criteria in ICD-10 (5). All in all results which will have to be taken into consideration in future revisions. The paper by Birket-Smith and Mortensen demonstrates difficulties in differentiating DSM-III-R somatoform pain disorder from conversion disorder in a study of 127 patients with unexplained physical symptoms from non-psychiatric departments. The paper questions the clinical validity of the DSM-III-R and DSM-IV in the differentiation between the various subcategories of patients with somatoform symptoms which mainly are separated by predominance of certain symptoms and by exclusion criteria (6). Following the usual time intervals between the revisions of about 10 years for ICD-10 and 7 years for DSM-IV the revisions for ICD-11 and DSM-V would be expected soon. At a recent WHO/WPA symposium in London, July 2001, the validity of the current classifications were reviewed with reference to the coming revisions. The lack of sufficient validation evidence contributed to the decision to postpone revision for another 8–10 years. The American Psychiatric Association wanted to await the promising development in molecular genetics for validation of the major psychiatric categories. WHO realized that a considerable number of member countries still had not taken the ICD-10 into use and therefore a revision had to await contributory experience from these countries. This give us another decade for accumulating validating evidence. Validation studies are urgently needed and should be encouraged and promoted to ensure the progress in psychiatric classification, remembering Karl Jaspers' descriptive definition: `Sie ist eine Fiktion, die ihre Aufgabe erfült when sie die zur Zeit relative richtigste ist' (It is a fiction which fulfill its object when it is the relatively most correct (valid) at the time being) (7).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Aksel Bertelsen (2002) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: