Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Constraints on manpower are intrinsic in the establishment of standards of excellence. When such constraints are exerted by individual Boards, Societies, Colleges or Academies they should act to improve the quality of care; their weakness lies in their lack of control over non-members, or those who have failed to pass the examinations. Such manpower constraints become specific objectives or goals when the number of accredited specialists is specifically related to the size of the population served. Any such manpower planning must recognize the many uncertainties in the future of American medicine, and maintain wide elasticity in the planning process. Social and economic pressures render the consideration of specific manpower goals essential at this time. Data from the national surgical study (SOSSUS) make it possible to consider such goals. Manpower objectives for surgery or any other branch of medicine should be considered as a part of the total medical manpower outlook for the United States. Pressures to reduce the number of surgeons entering practice are notable at this time. These should be evaluated against other pressures to maintain or increase the number of hospital-based specialists in all fields as the total number of practitioners undergoes a major expansion over the next 25 years, and the pressure for speciality care is thereby increased. A reasonable balance between these two pressures would be a manpower goal for surgery that allowed a modest growth rate over the next 25–50 years. An example of such is the goal of limiting surgical practitioner growth to a 1% increase in the ratio to population, every 5 years. This would be in sharp contrast to the continuous explosive growth of numbers of surgeons, since World War II. It is anticipated that Board Certification will be the basic credential for surgical practice over the coming decades and that the Board Certification rate is an accurate reflection of the effective residency completion rate. Although there are 30,000 physicians carrying out surgical operations without the established credential of the Boards, it appears that this number will decline over the coming years because of stricter hospital credentialling, public demand for qualified practitioners, and medico-legal pressures. Even without this cohort of unaccredited specialists, the total of 64,000 Board Certified surgeons (with their trainees) constitutes a number of surgeons that appears adequate for the United States and is an adequate ratio to the population (about 30 specialists—with trainees—per 100,000 population.) Were surgical residency training levels to be maintained at their present numbers without constraint, there would be a continued steep increase in the number and ratio of surgeons. Achievement of this modest growth goal of 1% increase in population ratio every 5 years will require a reduction in the number of physicians entering surgical residencies during the next 2 five-year periods. After that, as population catches up, residency levels would return to their present numbers. Enforcement of any such residency constraints requires strict hospital credentialling, limiting practice of the complicated hospital-based specialties, including surgery, to personnel whose capabilities are established by appropriate training and by the display of nationally acceptable documentation of examination. To implement any such manpower policy, a national data gathering agency is essential. This agency should acquire date from all of the certifying boards annually and make up data projections for the population ratios, nationally. This agency should not become involved in regional predictions or other soft sodo- economic estimates. Foreign medical graduats are automatically included in there predictions, once they have passed the credentialling system. Data so gathered should then be made available to a national public agency that includes all the diciplines of medicine and includes lay representation. Such a national agency should provide general guidelines for enforcement of speciality residency limitations, acting through the residency review boards and the accreditation process. The record of the voluntary sector of the Ameriean medicine and the implementation of policies in medical manpower, is far superior to that of government. The conclusion is offered that the voluntary sector should take a lead in this new regulatory function. Were such manpower polides and contraints to be implemented and enforced through a national voluntary agency, steps should be taken to avoid harassment from government agenaes that consider any manpower limitations to he monopolistic or in restraint of practice. It is cognized that government has an ambivalent view in this area,maintaining a strong pressure to reduce the number of surgmns while at the same time instiluting legal obstacles against manpower restriction. Such federal harassment of manpower policy is lessened when the national agency is broad in its jurisdiction, and would be obviated completely were there to he an enabling directive from appropriate branch of government. The establishment and implementation of manpower goals in surgery is an extremely important aspect of total national medic4 manpower policy at this time.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Francis D. Moore (1976) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: