Key result
Expanding context-specific, competency-based training for nurse anesthetists in Kenya successfully increased the density of anesthesia providers and surgical volume in rural hospitals.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Training nonphysician anesthesia providers, such as nurse anesthetists, using a context-specific and competency-based curriculum can effectively increase surgical capacity and anesthesia provider density in rural areas of low- and middle-income countries.
See Article, p 1387 GLOSSARY AIC = Africa Inland Church; DA = Diploma in Anesthesia; KRNA = Kenya Registered Nurse Anesthetist; LCoGS = Lancet Commission on Global Surgery; LMICs = low- and middle-income countries; MMed = Master of Medicine; NPAP = nonphysician anesthesia providers; SAO = surgeons/anesthesiologists/obstetricians; WFSA = World Federation of Societies of Anaesthesiologists; WHO = World Health Organization Five billion people do not have access to safe, affordable surgical and anesthesia care when needed.1 Low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) that contribute over 30% of the world population account for only 6% of the 313 million major surgical procedures performed globally each year.1 It is estimated that an additional 143 million operations per year are required to meet the need.1 Safe surgery is not possible without safe anesthesia, and sufficient numbers of trained anesthesia providers are needed to provide for the increase in surgical volume. The Lancet Commission on Global Surgery (LCoGS) suggested that a minimum workforce of surgeons/anesthesiologists/obstetricians (SAO) of 20/100,000 population is required. In 2017, the World Federation of Societies of Anaesthesiologists (WFSA) suggested as an interim that 5 of the 20 SAO should be anesthesiologists.2 More recently, using a similar methodology to that used by the LCoGS, a minimum density of specialist anesthesiologists of 4/100,000 was recommended by Davies et al.3 These authors acknowledge that, for LMICs—many with an anesthesiologist density of well under 1/100,000, this aim is aspirational due to a shortage of doctors. Without an increase in the output of medical schools, the suggested densities of anesthesia and surgical specialists will not be reached by 2030. Therefore, well-trained nonphysician anesthesia providers (NPAP) are needed to fill the workforce gap and especially to provide services in rural areas. There are many models for NPAP training but there is no uniformity of background, curriculum, or length of training. Little is known about the quality and impact of training and subsequent service delivery. In this issue of Anesthesia & Analgesia, Umutesi et al4 report a preliminary assessment of the impact of the training of Nurse Anesthetists in western Kenya. Since 2006, the Kenya Registered Nurse Anesthetist (KRNA) training program based in Kijabe has trained over 100 Nurse Anesthetists. The KRNA training program at the Africa Inland Church (AIC) Kijabe Hospital is specifically aimed at training nurse anesthetists for rural hospitals. The curriculum is competency-based and context-specific so that graduates are well prepared for their future scope of practice. With the success of the training in Kijabe, it is not surprising that an expansion of training facilities to another region in Kenya was started in 2015. This article describes the impact of KRNAs trained in Kisumu and Kijabe and posted to rural hospitals in western Kenya. For comparison, the study matched a hospital where a KRNA was based (intervention) with a hospital where they were not posted. They found that, in the intervention hospitals, the density of anesthesia providers was higher and the surgical volume was greater. The KRNAs felt that their education had provided them with sufficient training and leadership skills. The authors describe the increase in surgical work at the intervention sites, which was largely ascribed to greater confidence in caring for surgical patients and improved obstetric surgical care. The survey also showed a decrease of referrals to next tier hospitals, and in some cases, an increase in referrals from other hospitals thought to be due to improved anesthesia capacity. The authors rightly point out that one of the most important obstacles for the development of anesthesia services is the shortage of skilled providers. They also emphasize the uneven distribution and the resulting greater shortages in rural areas where anesthesiologists are rarely available. Expanding an established training program to another site using KRNA educators trained in Kijabe is a good model that was applied in a supported manner to ensure multiplication of impact. We believe that all of us should be encouraged to ensure that some of the providers we train will also become trainers. There is no global agreement on whether PAPs task sharing with NPAPs is a viable alternative to an anesthesiologist only model. Definitions of different providers are not uniform and there is no universally accepted curriculum for training and criteria for qualification. Recently, Morriss et al5 have published a Global Anesthesia Training Framework that considers some of these questions. The findings of Umutesi et al4 are significant for a number of reasons. First, expanding an existing training model to other parts of the country using educators trained at Kijabe has been successful. However, this does not mean that a training program can be exported to another country without adaptation to the new context. Second, it is vital that new graduates, after acquiring enough experience, become trainers so that multiplication of training can occur. Third, the new graduates felt confident to take on leadership roles and may have acted as catalysts for others in their hospital to improve care. And fourth, the KRNAs felt that their training had prepared them well for the clinical tasks of a rural nurse anesthetist. This is in stark contrast to other reports where the interviewees felt inadequately prepared for the tasks that awaited them in the districts.6 One of us (E.V.) has observed in Sierra Leone and Timor-Leste that the differences in the conditions between the training hospital and the district hospitals have led to the nurse anesthetists not always being fully prepared for working in the rural hospitals with fewer resources. This, sometimes coupled with a low surgical volume, has led to loss of skill and confidence. The KRNA training at Kijabe and Kisumu has specifically avoided these pitfalls. It seems reasonable to assume that an increase in anesthesia providers will increase access to surgery and consequently decrease morbidity and mortality due to surgical disease. In western Kenya, additional KRNAs did increase access to surgery as evidenced by the increase in surgical volume. The authors did not set out to assess the quality and safety of anesthesia provided by the KRNAs; thus, no conclusion can be drawn. It is important to focus not only on numbers but also on quality because low quality, unsafe anesthesia may lead to poor outcomes with increased morbidity and mortality. A recent World Health Organization (WHO)/World Bank publication asserts that low-quality care is no care and may increase the burden of disease.7 Several hospitals and KRNAs reported an increase in income, which is interesting, but unfortunately not the case in other countries. From personal observation, we know that nurse anesthetists are often not remunerated appropriately and may leave the profession or their country for better opportunities. Faced with this shortage of anesthesia providers, it is tempting to take shortcuts and produce providers who have received minimal training as a stopgap.8 There are 3 fundamental problems with this approach. First, if there are poor patient outcomes, access to surgical services and anesthesia care may be negatively impacted. Second, it gives a signal to surgeons, hospital administrators, and governments that anesthesia is a minor event and that there is no need for well-trained and qualified specialist—be the physicians or nonphysicians. This will perpetuate the poor image of anesthesia. Third, it seems inevitable that minimally trained providers will stray outside of their scope of practice leading to increased morbidity and mortality. We strongly advocate that attention is focused on promoting the training of qualified providers and the establishment of real task sharing where physicians and nonphysicians have specific roles and work as a team.9 There is not a universal model for the ideal anesthesia team, but if task sharing is to function well, the NPAPs must be supported. This includes appropriate remuneration, professional development, and a career structure. It should also include clinical support from anesthesiologists, either working together in the same hospital or with more remote supervision. In addition, regular visits by the anesthesiologist to handle difficult cases together will increase the skills and confidence of the nurse anesthetists. Without strong advocacy and leadership by senior anesthesiologists, tasks will not be shared but shifted and nurse anesthetists will continue to work in isolation. A stark message from this article is the absence of physician anesthesiologists in the rural hospitals. If we are advocating for task sharing, we should work to support both physician and nonphysician training programs. This also implies that more should be done to promote anesthesia as an essential medical specialty and to increase the training of anesthesiologists who should become the leaders and teachers of future anesthesia providers. To increase the number of physician anesthesia providers in rural areas, general medical officers can be trained to a level below that of a full Master of Medicine in Anesthesia (MMed) or Fellow. Some countries offer the Diploma in Anesthesia (DA) or Membership of a College, which prepares these doctors to provide safe anesthesia for most procedures in district hospitals. They too can be an important part of the anesthesia team as they work together with the nurse anesthetists in the rural hospitals. The LCoGS suggested 3 bellwether procedures: cesarean delivery, laparotomy, and open fractures.1 We believe that, at the very minimum, rural anesthesia teams, physicians, and NPAPs should be able to provide anesthesia for these procedures. The KRNA training programs in Kijabe and Kisumu demonstrate a good model of nurse anesthesia workforce building. Especially important are the context-specific, competency-based training and the inclusion of leadership and management skills. We should all learn lessons from these examples. Going forward, further research, including morbidity and mortality studies, on the quality and impact of training programs is required. What is also needed are clear definitions of the cadres and description of roles of the anesthesia team. Ultimately, each country will have to decide the optimal composition of its anesthesia team and provide the necessary training, support, and legislation. There is light at the end of the tunnel. DISCLOSURES Name: Eric Vreede, FFARCSI. Contribution: This author conceived the outline, helped with writing, and edited the final version. Name: Fred Bulamba, MMed. Contribution: This author helped with writing and referencing. Name: Edson Chikumba, MMed (Anaesthetics). Contribution: This author helped with writing. This manuscript was handled by: Angela Enright, MB, FRCPC.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Vreede et al. (2019) conducted an editorial in Anesthesia workforce shortage. Training of nonphysician anesthesia providers (nurse anesthetists) was evaluated. Expanding context-specific, competency-based training for nurse anesthetists in Kenya successfully increased the density of anesthesia providers and surgical volume in rural hospitals.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: