A humorous anecdote highlighting the unexpected sources of appreciation for surgical skills.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Unexpected praise from nonclinical sources may reflect lay views of skill; leaves open whether such anecdotes shape feedback or training.
During my specialist registrar rotation in obstetrics and gynaecology last year, I was posted to a busy district general hospital in Northern Ireland. One on call session was particularly busy. From Friday morning I attended more than 10 deliveries and performed four caesarean sections. By the early hours of Saturday morning, I was exhausted and praying that there would be no more operative deliveries before my replacement arrived. Unfortunately, a patient arrived at 6 am who needed almost immediate caesarean section. I hurriedly gulped a cup of tea while the spinal anaesthesia took effect and braced myself for another section. The patient and her husband were told about the need for the operation and the risks involved before the procedure started. The husband was present in the operating room, sitting beside his wife and reassuring her. At the same time he was watching the operative procedure enthusiastically, though I did not notice his keen observation until he started talking to me. Over the next half hour, he complimented me on my operative skills, starting with my preparation of the patient to the aesthetic wound closure using subcuticular stitches. He praised my speed of opening the abdomen, technique of delivering the baby, detailed knowledge of the anatomy, meticulous haemostasis, handling of instruments, tying of knots, and cosmetically beautiful closure. He was most impressed by my gentle tissue handling. Although tired, I was delighted with his explicit and generous compliments. His comments not only boosted my morale but also seemed to enhance my prestige among the other theatre staff, who were also listening to him. With his knowledge of abdominal organs, I was sure that he belonged to the medical profession but could not tell what branch of surgery he was in. In my experience, surgeons are rarely so appreciative of other surgeons' technical skills, and I was pleasantly surprised by his kind gesture. At that moment, genuine appreciation by the patient and her relatives was possibly the biggest reward for an overworked and tired junior doctor like myself. After completing the procedure, I had returned to the doctors' rest room when the husband walked in to thank me for a final time. I thanked him in return but could not resist asking him whether he was a doctor and which specialty he practised. Slightly embarrassed, he replied, “Oh no. I'm a butcher.”
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Yashashri Choudhari (2001) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: