Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Qualitative study reveals career stage influences professional identity negotiation during curriculum reforms in England, highlighting generational shifts in perceived teacher autonomy.
Curriculum reform in England has increasingly framed teaching through discourses of knowledge transmission, accountability and performativity. While existing research has examined the effects of these reforms on practice, less attention has been paid to how they shape teachers’ professional identities within subject-specific contexts. This paper explores how English teachers negotiate professional identity in relation to the “knowledge-rich” curriculum across different career stages. Drawing on semi-structured interviews with eight secondary English teachers in England: two retired, two experienced, two early career and two trainee teachers, critical discourse analysis is employed to examine how teachers position themselves in relation to curriculum reform, policy expectations and disciplinary knowledge. The findings reveal that professional identity negotiation is shaped by career stage and professional memory. Retired and experienced teachers draw on discourses of autonomy and loss, while early career and trainee teachers are more likely to normalise performativity and prescription as features of professional competence. Across all stages, a tension emerges between resistance to policy discourse and its simultaneous reproduction. The paper argues that identity negotiation under performative conditions involves adaptive, discursively mediated forms of agency. Implications are discussed for teacher education and professional learning across the career span.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gordon Baillie (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: