Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This volume summarizes nearly three decades of Nissinen’s careful scholarship on the topic of ancient Near Eastern prophetism, which in recent years has expanded to include ancient Greece as well. Chapter 1 addresses questions of definition and method. While “prophecy” is a scholarly construct, access to diverse sources that emically address the phenomenon helps anchor modern constructs in a historically reliable manner (p. 5). Nissinen retains the helpful distinction between technical divination (which is acquisition of the divine secrets through inductive, skill-based practices) and prophetic divination (which is an intuitive cognition of a divine message), recognizing that in some instances the boundary blurs (pp. 19–20). The definition of prophecy, advanced by M. Weippert in 1988, remains serviceable: a cognitive experience of divine revelation with a commission to transmit the message to a third party (pp. 20–21, my distillation). He nuances Weippert’s definition, among other ways, by recognizing a distinction between written prophecy and literary prophecy (p. 22). Substantial summary of the various ancient terms for prophetic functionaries comprises the bulk of the chapter, which concludes with comments on the comparative method.Chapter 2 covers ancient Near Eastern sources (lexical lists and omen texts, legal and administrative texts, ritual texts, letters, written oracles, literary prophecy). Regarding literary predictive texts, Nissinen rightly distinguishes them from prophetic documents, even in the sense of Fortschreibung (pp. 112–13). However, his comparison of literary predictive texts to the scribalization of prophecy in the Hebrew Bible (pp. 114–15) depends on the disassociation of prophetic literature from prophetic functionaries themselves (more below). I wish Nissinen had considered Egyptian records of divine speech addressed to the king in a context of live ritual performance, which show patterns of speech that are difficult to explain as mere answers to binary queries (although see p. 42). In addition, the Egyptian Archive of Hor should be included in the discussion, since it reports divine speech received in a dream oracle to be delivered to a third party.Chapter 3 overviews Greek sources (oracle collections from Dodona, Didyma, Claros, and citation in literary sources from these as well as Delphi). While these function much like Mesopotamian binary queries, they flow from intuitive divination and so are akin to prophecy. Of particular interest is Nissinen’s discussion of the role of “chresmologues,” who functioned as inspired interpreters of oracular tradition with all the attendant issues involving social authority (pp. 137–43).In ch. 4, Nissinen discusses the uniquely complex literary form of prophecy in the Hebrew Bible, which he maintains is the product of scribal creativity not connected with the historical prophets themselves. He correctly notes that the historical phenomenon of ancient Hebrew prophecy is not the same thing as biblical prophecy, and scholars should not by default make assumptions about historical authorship, early dating, or textual unity (pp. 144–45). He argues that “literary prophecy, that is, thoroughgoing reinterpretation of the written remains of the traditional prophetic phenomenon, became a powerful method of scribal divination.” But the original oral performances “cannot even be recognized in the text” (p. 155).However, I punctuate the evidence differently; more-positive assessments about authorship, dating, and textual unity are not uncritical conclusions. Evidence shows a cultural proclivity to maintain continuity between prophets and texts, and prophets collaborating with scribes. The latter were not authorized to take a free hand in fabricating or misrepresenting prophetic material. After all, prophecy was diplomatic discourse, the violation of which would be religious-political treason (compare the censure of Greek chresmologues who fabricated or took undue liberty with oracle collections). Some divine letters show awareness that prophecy could be textualized directly. Scribal divination of the intuitive type, as described by Nissinen, is unknown until late Second Temple times, and even then, the scribal functionaries were themselves duly recognized as prophetic authorities. If preexilic Judah and Israel had the inclination and capacity to produce any literature, then prophetic literature linked with historical prophets is unsurprising.Chapters 5–8 consist of comparative essays: prophecy and ecstasy, prophets and temples, prophets and kings, prophecy and gender. Nissinen stresses the complex nature of ecstatic phenomena and cautions against undue reductionism (pp. 183–84). What is important is the role of patterned behavior in the social recognition and authorization of prophets (pp. 183, 187, 200). Near Eastern temples provided one venue in which prophetic performance could be authorized (p. 204), and conversely, prophets contributed significantly to the flourishing of the cult. This symbiosis is even more evident in Greece (p. 224). Due to the nature of the biblical sources, the relationship between Hebrew prophets and cult is more ambivalent (pp. 242, 247–48). Nissinen rightly qualifies the oft-cited antagonism between prophet and cult (pp. 253–54). Differences between biblical and extrabiblical prophets in their relationship to royalty is more a matter of degree than quality (pp. 261–62, 291). While Greek evidence shows less royal connection, it may be due to the nature of the sources (pp. 285–86). Gender diversity among prophets enabled both male and nonmale persons to exercise a degree of “actorship in their societies” (p. 325).In ch. 7, Nissinen offers a helpful and interesting comparative reconstruction of prophecy. In most ways, ancient Israel shared similar phenomena with its Mediterranean neighbors. However, “when it comes to the Hebrew Bible, the most blatant characteristics that set it apart from other Near Eastern sources are, first, the irreconcilable dichotomy between the God of Israel and other gods, and second, the nature of the textual transmission concomitant to this ideological framework of the Hebrew canon” (p. 343).In conclusion, let me express my own debt of gratitude to Prof. Nissinen, without whose contributions my own work over the years would not have been possible. This latest work is a comprehensive and fair-minded assessment of the “state of the question” that should serve as the starting point for all future discussions of the subject.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
John W. Hilber (2019) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: