Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The HFE gene mutation designated C282Y (g.5474G→A; GenBank accession no. Z92910) is usually detected by the primers described by Feder et al. (1) in a PCR to amplify genomic DNA followed by restriction enzyme cleavage based on the production of either a SnaB1 (2) or a Rsa1 (3) cut site. A polymorphism (5569G/A) located five nucleotides within the 3′ end of the binding site for the antisense primer has been reported to lead to false-positive results for C282Y homozygosity (4). The false-positive result occurs in analysis of a C282Y heterozygote compound with the 5569G/A polymorphism because of selective amplification of the C282Y-containing allele. A new antisense primer (5′-TACCTCCTCAGGCACTCCTC-3′) that did not bind the 5569G/A site was designed (4). We developed a Rsa1 genotype assay (5) with the primers used by Feder et al. (1) and established the PCR conditions by assessing the genotype results in a group of hemochromatosis cases diagnosed by strict phenotypic criteria. The PCR cycling conditions included a lower annealing temperature (55 °C) than reported previously (2). The conditions were as follows: 94 °C for 3 min, and then 35 cycles of 94 °C for 60 s, 55 °C for 45 s, and 72 °C for 1.5 min, and finally 72 °C for 2 min. The 25-μL reaction volume contained 50 ng of DNA and 5 pmol of each primer. In response to the possibility of false-positive results for C282Y homozygosity, our Rsa1 genotype assay was validated by two approaches. In the first approach, we reamplified 112 DNA samples reported previously as C282Y homozygotes by substituting the newly described antisense primer (4) for the Feder et al. (1) primer in our Rsa1 method. All 112 samples were confirmed as C282Y homozygotes, indicating that results obtained with the Rsa1 method were unaffected by the 5569G/A polymorphism. In the second method, to test for the presence of the 5569G/A polymorphism, DNA from 86 samples reported previously as C282Y heterozygotes was reamplified using the Feder et al. (1) primers and PCR conditions described above, except that the annealing temperature was raised to 62 °C. One C282Y heterozygote sample out of the 86 tested apparently changed genotype to homozygous for C282Y. Sequence analysis of the genomic DNA confirmed that this sample was a C282Y/5569A compound heterozygote. Single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) occurring at primer binding sites are potentially a serious problem, and the overall genomic prevalence is estimated to be between 1 in 300 and 1 in 1000 bases (6). Testing for occult SNPs that may lead to false-positive or -negative results in a new diagnostic PCR assay is a critical but neglected task. The gold standard for detecting interfering SNPs is to sequence the region under the primers from a large number of subjects. An alternative approach is to perform each PCR reaction twice, using two different sets of nonoverlapping PCR primers. This would double the cost of the PCR analysis but provides added confidence in the results. The possibility of occult SNPs interfering with primer binding should be excluded before introducing PCR-based genotype assays into routine diagnostic practice. We have demonstrated that the presence of the 5569 G/A polymorphism did not produce false-positive results in our Rsa1 genotype assay when the primers described by Feder et al. (1) were used. Binding of the antisense PCR primer to genomic DNA containing the 5569A polymorphism was not affected when the annealing temperature was 55 °C. However, we have shown the new antisense primer (4) functions well in the Rsa1 method, and we advocate its use to avoid any problems caused by the 5569G/A polymorphism.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Chin et al. (2000) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: