Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
A 12-year-old girl with juvenile rheumatoid arthritis presented with signs of infection of the proximal interphalangeal joint of her left great toe 1 week after a flu-like illness. Several joints and one bone were subsequently found to be infected with group A beta-hemolytic streptococci. Despite appropriate antibiotic therapy, synovial fluid cultures remained positive for 2 weeks. We believe that the antiinflammatory medications, including etanercept (a tumor necrosis factor antagonist), used to treat this patient’s arthritis contributed to the severity and unusual course of her infection. Advances in immunomodulating medicines have led to significant clinical improvement in children with diseases such as juvenile rheumatoid arthritis (JRA). These types of medications generally work by modulating the body’s overreactive inflammatory response that is often present in rheumatologic disorders. However, although suppressing the inflammatory response, these agents can suppress the body’s ability to fight infections and the usual signs and symptoms associated with infections. This may result in uncommon presentations and more severe infections by organisms that usually cause relatively minor disease. The following is a case report of multifocal septic arthritis and osteomyelitis caused by group A beta-hemolytic streptococci (GABHS) that could have resulted from immunomodulating therapy for JRA. Patient report. A 12-year-old girl with a history of polyarticular JRA developed pain in the great toe of her left foot 3 days before admission. The day after her pain began, she was evaluated by her primary physician, who noted only localized tenderness with no redness or swelling. At that time serum chemistries, liver function tests, a complete blood count and radiographs of her left foot were normal. Two days later the patient returned to her physician reporting worsening pain, fever to 102.4oF and swelling and redness of the toe extending over the dorsum of the foot. Additional history revealed a 48-h flu-like illness with vomiting, cough, malaise and sore throat but without fever that occurred 1 week before the toe pain. Her past medical history is significant for polyarticular JRA diagnosed 3 years earlier. A pediatric rheumatologist was currently treating her with etanercept (Enbrel; Immunex Corp., Seattle, WA), a tumor necrosis factor (TNF) antagonist (sTNF receptor), which she received as a 25-mg subcutaneous injection twice a week. She also took daily oral naproxen and weekly oral methotrexate. This regimen maintained her arthritis under good control, with a baseline erythrocyte sedimentation rate between 20 and 40 mm/h. Physical examination revealed significant swelling of the left great toe with erythema covering the entire toe and streaking proximally up the foot. The toe was warm to the touch and exquisitely tender to palpation around the proximal interphalangeal (PIP) joint. The remainder of the physical examination, including all other joints and her pharynx, was normal. Laboratory data obtained at this time revealed a white blood cell count (WBC) of 11 900/mm3 with 86% mature and 8% immature polymorphonuclear cells, hemoglobin 12.8 g/dl, platelets 160 000/mm3 and an erythrocyte sedimentation rate of 83 mm/h. Blood cultures and a throat culture were obtained. A bone scan demonstrated increased uptake of 99mTc diphosphate in the soft tissues of the left great toe and a small focus of increased uptake at the proximal end of the first metatarsal. This was interpreted to be consistent with cellulitis but indeterminate for osteomyelitis or septic arthritis in any of the bones or joints of the foot. The patient was admitted and given cefazolin intravenously. Naproxen was continued, but methotrexate and etanercept were stopped. The proximal interphalangeal joint space of the left great toe was incised and drained by a podiatrist, and a swab culture was obtained. Fluid was not obtained from the joint. The next morning, the throat culture, both blood cultures and the culture from the PIP joint of the left great toe were positive for GABHS. The cefazolin therapy was then changed to ampicillin and clindamycin given intravenously. On Hospital Day 2 the patient’s previously normal left knee was swollen, erythematous, warm and tender. A joint aspiration by an orthopedic surgeon produced 15 ml of purulent, blood-tinged fluid. Cell count analysis revealed 26 400/mm3 red blood cells (RBC) and 16 533/mm3 WBC, which were predominately polymorphonuclear cells. The synovial fluid glucose was 54 g/dl compared with a serum glucose of 138 g/dl, and a Gram-stained smear revealed numerous Gram-positive cocci in chains. An MRI of her left foot and knee demonstrated extensive soft tissue inflammation around her left PIP and knee joints as well as early osteomyelitis of the head of the left first phalanx extending proximally from the PIP joint. There was no evidence of bony involvement of the knee. Incision and drainage of the left knee yielded synovial fluid that grew GABHS on culture. On Hospital Day 3 the patient’s previously normal right elbow was swollen, erythematous, warm and tender. A joint aspiration produced 3 ml of purulent looking fluid. Cell count analysis revealed 755 200/mm3 RBC and 589 300/mm3 WBC with predominance of polymorphonuclear cells, and the Gram-stained smear revealed Gram-positive cocci in chains. Her right elbow was incised and drained, and the synovial fluid grew GABHS. A blood culture 24 h after initiation of cefazolin therapy was sterile. The organism was susceptible to clindamycin and erythromycin by the Kirby-Bauer disc technique. By E test the MIC was 0.016 μg/ml for penicillin and 0.023 μg/ml for cefotaxime. The patient was transferred to the children’s hospital at the University of California at San Francisco on Hospital Day 4 where she remained for another 13 days. On arrival at the children’s hospital, the ampicillin was changed to penicillin G given intravenously. The clindamycin was discontinued on Hospital Day 6. Mild pain and trace edema were noted in the left wrist and right ankle. On Hospital Day 15 an abscess formed in the same left great toe that had been previously drained. The toe was incised, drained and packed. Also at this time the left wrist was incised and drained, and the right ankle was aspirated. Cultures from the toe and the wrist were positive for GABHS, whereas the culture from the right ankle was sterile. The patient was discharged home on Hospital Day 17 to complete 6 weeks of intravenous penicillin therapy. She continued to receive naproxen for her JRA at the time of discharge, but the etanercept and methotrexate were not restarted. She was enrolled to receive extensive physical therapy and rehabilitation. Two months later there were no signs of continued or recurrent infection, but there was still decreased range of motion in her right elbow and left wrist compared with her preinfection baseline. Discussion. Although GABHS is not an uncommon cause of septic arthritis, 1 the disease is usually monoarticular and only rarely multifocal. 2 This patient’s complicated course and multiple joint and bone involvement may have been related to the immunosuppressive medications that she received for her JRA. Patients with JRA have increased risk of infections, especially septic arthritis. 3 It is unclear whether this increase is caused solely by the immunosuppressive drugs or whether the disease itself predisposes patients by injuring the joint capsule and facilitating entry of bacteria. This patient had suffered from chronic arthritis in the knees, elbows and wrists but had never before complained of pain in the toes. Various cytokines such as TNF-alpha play an important role in the stimulation of an inflammatory and an immune response to protect against invading bacteria. Serious bacterial infections have been associated with the use of TNF-alpha antagonists, especially with the monoclonal antibodies to TNF such as infliximab. 4–6 Etanercept is not a monoclonal antibody but rather a soluble TNF receptor that binds TNF and prevents it from interacting with cell surface TNF receptors. This prevents TNF from accomplishing its functions in the inflammatory response and innate immunity. 6, 7 In early postmarketing surveillance of etanercept, 30 of >25 000 patients were reported to have developed serious infections, 6 of whom died. Although many of these patients had comorbid conditions predisposing them to infections, this observation led to additional labeling cautions about serious infection. 4, 5 A recent published report describes a fatal case of pneumococcal sepsis in a 37-year-old patient with long-standing rheumatoid arthritis who was treated with etanercept. 8 To our knowledge there have been no prior reports of serious bacterial infections in pediatric patients treated with etanercept. The use of nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) has also been controversial in patients with GABHS infections. Some reports have indicated that patients treated with NSAIDs, such as ibuprofen, are at an increased risk of developing streptococcal toxic shock syndrome or soft tissue necrosis. 9, 10 This is hypothesized to be secondary to the suppression of granulocytic functions (chemotaxis, phagocytosis, oxidative burst and bacterial killing) as well as the increased production of cytokines like TNF. Increased TNF has been associated with development of shock. Another study showed that children with varicella infections complicated by GABHS and treated with ibuprofen did not have an increased incidence of necrotizing fasciitis, but there was a statistically significant increase in the number of nonnecrotizing severe GABHS infections. 11 It is generally accepted that NSAIDs decrease the signs and symptoms of infections such as fever, myalgia and arthralgia, possibly leading to delayed diagnosis and treatment. 9–11 Although naproxen has not specifically been implicated as a risk factor for invasive GABHS, the mechanism of action could be similar to that of ibuprofen. It is remarkable that after 2 weeks of appropriate parenteral antibiotics cultures from joints from this patient continued to grow GABHS. Several studies have shown that the antibiotics that were used for this patient (cefazolin, ampicillin, clindamycin and penicillin G) readily diffuse into the joint space, achieving concentrations severalfold higher than the known MICs for GABHS. 12, 13 Another possibility for drug failure in pyarthrosis that has been suggested in the literature is the inability of an antibiotic to work against a large dormant population of bacteria within an enclosed space. 12 The patient may have had an abscess in the PIP joint that was insufficiently drained at first, thus allowing bacteria to persist for a prolonged period of time despite the use of antibiotics. In retrospect she may have benefited from a longer course of clindamycin together with the beta-lactam antibiotic while hospitalized. Clindamycin has been shown to achieve higher concentrations than penicillin in infected joints (probably because of its lipophilicity), and it has better activity against dormant bacteria. The long and variable half-life of etanercept may have been another contributing factor. A half-life of 102 ± 30 h is reported in one study of adult rheumatoid arthritis patients. 7 Half-lives as long as 300 h have been noted. 4 The half-life has not yet been well-studied in children (especially those <4 years old). The long half-life may explain the prolonged masking of inflammatory symptoms and the persistence of the infection. It is likely that this patient had GABHS pharyngitis the week before presentation that went unrecognized in part because of her immunomodulating therapy. This allowed the organism to enter the bloodstream and spread to multiple joints and bone. This case is presented to demonstrate the unusual course that may develop from relatively common infections in patients on antiinflammatory medications. Acknowledgment. Special thanks to Helen Emery, M.D. for her help in the care of this patient.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Elwood et al. (2003) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: