Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Four Americans and three Germans recently died of rabies after organ transplantation from two donors who experienced animal bites. The clinical and pathological findings of the American victims were recently described.1 The American donor presented 4 days prior to hospital admission to an emergency room with nausea, vomiting, and difficulty swallowing. His drug screen was positive for cocaine and marijuana. He was subsequently admitted to a different hospital with fever and altered mental status and required intubation. His mental condition was attributed to a subarachnoid hemorrhage caused by hypertension and drug abuse. The patient’s condition deteriorated rapidly over the next days, and he was declared brain dead and cleared as a tissue donor. Five recipients were transplanted with kidneys, liver, lung, and an iliac artery segment. Four of them died of rabies over the next weeks, while the patient who received the lung died of operative complications. An investigation by the Arkansas Department of Health determined that the 20‐year‐old American had recently been bitten by a bat.2 The 26‐year‐old German female donor first went to see a doctor because of severe headache, fever, mental changes, and aggressive behavior. A drug screen was positive for cocaine, and she was believed to have a toxic psychosis. She soon suffered a cardiac arrest and was pronounced brain dead and cleared as a tissue donor.3 Six patients were given organs (corneas, liver, lung, kidney, and kidney‐pancreas); three of them died during the following weeks.4–6 The bat bite in the American case and the recent visit to a rabies‐endemic country with history of dog bite were not elicited or not considered important. Three German organ recipients survived. One had rabies vaccination some years before and was found to have detectable rabies‐neutralizing antibodies in his serum prior to liver transplantation. The transplanted corneas were removed and revealed no demonstrable rabies virus. Rabies can be difficult to diagnose where it is a rare disease. There is also lack of awareness of early‐onset rabies as a cause of obscure behavioral and neurological manifestations. A rabies‐infected person might be considered as an organ donor when admitted in a brain‐dead state without a complete occupational, travel, and past medical history. A street person was hit by a truck and admitted at a tertiary care hospital brain dead. No history was obtainable, and his corneas were immediately transplanted. Both recipients died of rabies (H. Wilde, unpublished). It is tragic that organ transplant rabies has not been as rare as one might suspect7–11 (Table 1). We suggest that additional cases may have remained undetected or unpublished. We reviewed the literature as well as our own experience with intravitam diagnosis of rabies in 115 patients (80 furious and 35 paralytic) and present suggestions for the prevention of such tragedies in the future.12 Reported rabies cases due to tissue transplantation Reported rabies cases due to tissue transplantation Rabies is an acute viral encephalomyelitis that is virtually 100% fatal. The disease is most prevalent in developing countries where it is underreported. Several large canine rabies‐endemic nations (among them India and Pakistan) do not include rabies among notifiable or reportable diseases, and the actual incidence is not known. It is estimated that over 55,000 humans die of rabies worldwide every year.13,14 Most known rabies deaths occur in Africa and Asia where dogs are the major reservoir and vector. Frugivorous and insect‐eating bats are now recognized as an additional worldwide risk. Bat rabies variants of genotype 1 differ genetically and also in tissue tropisms.15 Patients with bat lyssavirus variants may show clinical manifestations different from what is commonly seen in humans infected with canine rabies. However, all reported cases developed neurological symptoms.16–19 There have been five documented survivors of rabies. Four had received immunization prior to onset of symptoms, and only one had a complete recovery.18 A recent patient has survived a bat rabies infection without pre‐ or postexposure prophylaxis and appears to be fully recovering.17 This patient, a 15‐year‐old girl, was unique in that she exhibited high serum and central nervous system (CNS) fluid‐neutralizing antibodies on admission. No viable virus could be isolated from her, suggesting that her immune system had already been able to control infection. Because of increasing numbers of tourists traveling to rabies‐endemic regions in Asia, Africa, and South America, more imported cases of human rabies must be anticipated.20,21 Bat contacts present a hidden risk in relatively developed regions such as the Americas, Europe, and Australia, which had been previously considered rabies free.22 Rabies is most common due to bites from an infected mammal, usually a canine, feline, raccoon, skunk, mongoose, or bat. The virus may remain latent near the inoculation site, then replicate in muscle fibers or dermal cells (in the case of some bat variants).23,24 Only amputation or neurectomy of the sciatic nerve has been shown to stop progression.25–27 Dorsal root ganglionitis is responsible for prodromal symptoms such as neuropathic dysaesthesias in one third of cases regardless of clinical types. This stage is rapidly followed by the classical furious or paralytic (Guillain‐Barré syndrome‐like) clinical presentations. Atypical forms can occur and may be more common with bat‐derived virus.28 After entering the CNS, virus spreads centrifugally along neural pathways to other organs. Terminally, all major neural and nonneural organs may contain virus.24 The mechanism by which the virus can infect vascular tissues and solid organs, as shown in the organ donors, is intriguing.29 There are highly sensitive and specific tests for the postmortem diagnosis of rabies.30,31 Organ transplants are carried out at tertiary care centers that should have access to fluorescent microscopy and molecular technology. Laboratory studies such as antibody testing in serum and cerebrospinal fluid are of less value because they are slow to appear and rarely present on admission of the patient.32 Corneal smears are not reliable.33 Magnetic resonance imaging can be helpful but is not pathognomonic for rabies.34–36 While reverse transcription–polymerase chain reaction (RT‐PCR) was positive for rabies in 10 of 10 saliva samples of one study, another revealed lower sensitivity.37 Nucleic acid sequence‐based amplification detected rabies virus RNA in saliva, urine, or CSF and in extracted hair follicles in 21 of 23 confirmed rabies patients on the first day of hospitalization.38 Nevertheless, if test results on the first day are negative, serial collection and antigen testing is required because of the known intermittent nature of viral shedding, particularly in saliva.32,38 Immunofluorescence testing performed on frozen sections of nuchal skin exhibited high sensitivity in combination with RT‐PCR. It was positive in all of the nine confirmed cases of human rabies tested.37 Brain tissue examination for rabies as well as other emerging neurotropic viruses (rabies, Nipha, Hendra, West Nile etc) must remain the gold standard for exclusion of transmissible CNS infections. Our animal bite clinic and rabies diagnostic laboratory sees rabies‐exposed patients daily. Patients often bring animals responsible for a possible exposure to our diagnostic laboratory. We then complete fluorescent antibody testing (FAT) of brain tissue within 3 hours. This allows our clinic staff to determine whether postexposure rabies prophylaxis is indicated. Our FAT study of 8,987 canine, feline, and human brains revealed no false‐negative results.31 Another FAT study from New York reported 802 of 804 mammalian rabies brain specimens as positive. Insufficient sampling was considered responsible for the two false‐negative cases.30 However, limited biopsy of brain tissue from temporal or frontal lobe yielded positive results in only two of three confirmed rabies patients based on FAT.39 False‐negative results may be explained by the predilection of rabies virus for brain stem, spinal cord, and thalamus during the early noncomatose stage of the disease. These sites are usually not biopsied. Brain‐dead potential donors usually have been in coma for some time, thus allowing rabies virus to disseminate throughout the whole neural axis by the time they are considered. Several samples examined by FAT, together with molecular techniques, should yield the highest sensitivity for antemortem rabies diagnosis in such a patient. However, even this cannot assure 100% sensitivity, and we do not advocate it. The recent transplant cases demand reevaluation of strategies for screening organ donors presenting with neurological symptoms. A potential donor with a comprehensive history and no neurological symptoms or signs should not pose a diagnostic problem and would not need extensive rabies laboratory testing. The symptoms and clinical signs in the recent donors were consistent with a diagnosis of rabies. They should have alerted the clinicians, who should have excluded the patients as donors. Immediate effort to obtain detailed histories (from the patient, relatives, or friends) should have revealed the dog and bat bite histories and recent travel to India. If transplantation is being considered in a patient with not fully explained neurological symptoms or signs, exhaustive studies for neurological infectious diseases (not only rabies) are mandatory. We believe that there are no 100% sensitive in vivo tests that exclude rabies in a donor. The safest strategy is to exclude any donor with neurological symptoms and signs altogether, unless these are clearly explained by history, physical signs, and reliably performed diagnostic tests.40,41 This essay is the combined effort of staff from the Rabies Diagnostic Unit of the Thai Red Cross Society (Queen Saovabha Memorial Institute, QSMI), the Neuroscience Laboratory for Molecular Biology, King Chulalongkorn Memorial Hospital. J. B., H. W., T. H., V. T., and B. L. are recipients of an ongoing Thai Government research grant (National Center for Genetic Engineering and Biotechnology). J. B. was a visiting scholar in Bangkok under a grant of the German Navy Medical Corps. We appreciate the support that we received from Professors Visith Sitprija, director of Queen Saovanha Memorial Institute, and Narongsak Chaiyabutr, dean of the faculty of veterinary science. The authors state they have no conflicts of interest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bronnert et al. (2007) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: