Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
To the Editor: Hospital at Home may be advantageous in the care of acutely ill older persons, but its economic value is unclear.1–3 In 1996, the Geriatric Home Hospitalization Service (GHHS) at S. Giovanni Battista Hospital in Torino, Italy, initiated a Hospital at Home program to treat first acute ischemic stroke. This model and its clinical outcomes have been described previously.4 In brief, 120 older patients admitted to the ED of the hospital with first acute uncomplicated ischemic stroke were randomized to home treatment by the GHHS or to the general medical ward (GMW). There was no difference in neurological outcomes between the two interventions, although GHHS patients had better depressive scores and lower rates of admission to nursing home than GMW patients. GHHS patients had a significantly longer length of stay than GMW patients (38.1±28.6 vs 22.2±11.5 days, t=3.995, P<.001). The GHHS intervention includes acute and rehabilitation care, whereas hospital care usually includes only treatment of the acute phase of the disease and the early steps of a rehabilitation program, which is often followed by a further period of care in rehabilitation facilities. The aim of this letter is to compare the costs of GHHS for the treatment of first ischemic stroke with the costs of GMW care. Costs for the original/acute episode were calculated, comparing only the direct health costs of GHHS interventions with those of GMW care. The costs were calculated in euro and converted to U.S. dollars using an exchange rate of 1 euro=$1.30. The 62% of daily GHHS costs was represented by costs for geriatricians, nurses, physiotherapy, speech therapists, occupational therapy, psychologists, dietitians, and social workers, calculated according to the amount of time spent with patients and including a cost for noncontact time. The remaining 38% included costs for drugs, diagnostic procedures, medications, and nonstaff costs. Daily GHHS cost per patient did not include costs for food, laundry, heating, or lighting, which patients paid. Data on hospital costs were collected from the official hospital medical cost charts, including direct medical costs for beds, staff, examinations, medications, rehabilitation, and miscellaneous expenses. Cost of management for each patient in the emergency department was $293.8, on average, and it was the same for all patients in both settings, because it was derived from an evaluation made before randomization. In the GMW, the mean length of hospital stay was 22.2 days, whereas in the GHHS, it was 38.1 days. The mean total cost was $6,413.5 for each patient treated at home and $6,504.8 for patients treated in the hospital. On a cost per patient per day basis, GHHS costs were $163.0±20.5, compared with $275.6±27.7 for GMW patients (P<.001). Considering the length of stay, it is important to highlight that all patients discharged from GHHS had completed their rehabilitation program at home, whereas 50% of GMW patients continued their rehabilitation program in rehabilitation facilities after hospital discharge, with an average daily cost of $162.5 for a period of approximately 24.2±7.6 days. Hospital at Home treatment for first acute ischemic stroke is cost effective when compared with usual hospital care. Each patient-day of at-home care cost is about half of the cost of a day in a traditional hospital setting, and total costs for GHHS, including the rehabilitation component, were comparable with usual hospital costs that include only a part of the rehabilitative costs. The specific elements responsible for lower costs of GHHS, indirect costs of care, or out-of-pocket costs that may have been incurred by families of GHHS patients were not evaluated. Financial Disclosure: Nicoletta Aimonino Ricauda, Vittoria Tibaldi, Renata Marinello, Mario Bo, Gianluca Isaia, Carla Scarafiotti, and Mario Molaschi did not have any financial support for this research. Author Contributions: Nicoletta Aimonino Ricauda and Vittoria Tibaldi: study concept and design, analysis and interpretation of data, preparation of manuscript. Renata Marinello, Carla Scarafiotti, and Mario Bo: analysis and interpretation of data. Gianluca Isaia: acquisition of subjects and data, analysis and interpretation of data. Mario Molaschi: study concept and design, preparation of manuscript.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ricauda et al. (2005) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: