Key result
Patient-rated severity of postoperative complications was discordant with provider-derived grading systems, as patients rated grade 1 complications similarly to grade 5 and higher than grades 2 and 3.
Why the study?
Although provider-derived surgical complication severity grading systems exist, little is known about the patient perspective.
Does patient-rated severity of postoperative complications concord with provider-derived grading systems?
Cross-Sectional (n=168)
No
Does patient-rated severity of postoperative complications concord with provider-derived grading systems?
Patient perceptions of postoperative complication severity differ significantly from provider-derived grading systems, highlighting the need to incorporate patient perspectives.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Patient-rated complication discordance cautions against sole reliance on provider scales; leaves open integration of patient perspectives in future validation studies.
Background: Although provider-derived surgical complication severity grading systems exist, little is known about the patient perspective. Objective: To assess patient-rated complication severity and determine concordance with existing grading systems. Methods: A survey asked general surgery patients to rate the severity of 21 hypothetical postoperative events representing grades 1 to 5 complications from the Accordion Severity Grading System. Concordance with the Accordion scale was examined. Separately, descriptive ratings of 18 brief postoperative events were ranked. Results: One hundred sixty-eight patients returned a mailed survey following their discharge from a general surgery service. Patients rated grade 4 complications highest. Grade 1 complications were rated similarly to grade 5 and higher than grades 2 and 3 ( P ≤ .01). Patients rated one event not considered an Accordion scale complication higher than all but grade 4 complications ( P < .001). The brief events also did not follow the Accordion scale, other than the grade 6 complication ranking highest. Conclusion: Patient-rated complication severity is discordant with provider-derived grading systems, suggesting the need to explore important differences between patient and provider perspectives.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rendell et al. (2019) conducted a cross-sectional in Postoperative complications (n=168). Patient-rated complication severity vs. Provider-derived grading systems (Accordion Severity Grading System) was evaluated on Concordance of patient-rated complication severity with the Accordion Severity Grading System (p=<0.01). Patient-rated severity of postoperative complications was discordant with provider-derived grading systems, as patients rated grade 1 complications similarly to grade 5 and higher than grades 2 and 3.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: