Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Pseudopathology in paleontology refers to postmortem bone alteration mimicking osseous features of disease. Differentiating pathologies from pseudopathologies is critical in the investigation of paleopathology, as misattribution can produce erroneous conclusions regarding diseases and life history. In this paper, we describe several examples of pseudopathologies from a Cretaceous commingled monospecific bonebed of Edmontosaurus annectens (Lance Formation, WY). In addition to 96 documented real pathologies or injuries uncovered in examination of over 3000 fossil bone specimens, multiple pseudopathologies were observed. Most of these were bone fractures or patterned erosions of bone material resulting from most likely taphonomic processes. Bone proliferation characterizing the living response to premortem injuries is one clue. Absent this response, perimortem injuries and postmortem changes due to scavenging, weathering, and other factors should be considered. CT imaging of one astragalus showed intense focal radiodensity surrounding the two large lesions, sharply distinct from the surrounding bone. When compared against histological thin sections and SEM-EDS scanning, what appeared in CT as dense sclerotic reactive bone suggested postmortem migration of minerals subsequent to erosive insect boring, a gradient potentially related to the unique microenvironment thereby created affecting subsequent permineralization. Evidence from our analysis of this assemblage supports that even diagnoses supported by non-invasive imaging such as CT scans should, when possible, be tested by histological analysis. Otherwise, a distinctly and disturbingly non-zero number of erroneous conclusions are to be expected from any survey of paleopathology, particularly given the numbers of intervening processes separating a fresh carcass from permineralized bone.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Siviero et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: