Key result
The combined spinal epidural (CSE) technique provides rapid pain relief for women in early labor, while the specific risk of meningitis from dural puncture versus epidural placement remains unclear.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The authors argue that the combined spinal epidural technique offers rapid and reliable pain relief for parturients in early labor, and that the risk of meningitis is low and difficult to attribute solely to dural puncture.
We read with interest the study by Dr Price et al. (Anaesthesia 1998; 53: 951–5) and would like to make a few observations. In their introduction, the authors inferred the potential for meningitis as a risk factor in the CSE technique, based on a previous case report. Although more recently, there does seem to be an increase in the reporting of meningitis following regional anaesthesia [1, 2], both epidural and CSE techniques have been implicated. It is difficult to determine what may constitute the risk for infection in a combined approach − the spinal or the epidural component. It is also unlikely that future studies can differentiate between epidural placement and dural puncture as independent risk factors for the development of meningitis owing to the very low incidence of this complication. Therefore, we believe it is more relevant to teach proper clinical skills relevant to aseptic technique when utilising any regional anaesthetic. During our practice in the USA, the CSE technique offered certain advantages to a subset of women in early labour. Very young teenage mothers and drug abusers admitted in extreme distress, often with no antenatal care, were sometimes very difficult to manage. A consistently rapid and reliable technique that ameliorates pain was urgently required in order to allow assessment of labour. A simple, single-shot subarachnoid bolus achieves this. Rapid improvement in the parturient's pain control ensures that the anaesthetist and obstetrician rapidly gain their confidence. This concept has recently been highlighted in a case report where intravenous remifentanil was used to achieve the same purpose [3]. Delay in commencing the epidural infusion following a subarachnoid dose is sometimes a common practice, but we have resorted to commencing the epidural infusion immediately following an epidural test dose and find this to be effective. It avoids waiting for the spinal to wear off and the patient becoming uncomfortable. A test dose is usually given through the catheter following a single subarachnoid dose of sufentanil or bupivacaine/fentanyl mixture. Our practice ensures we review the parturient 4-hly thereafter to detect any potential problems. Therefore, we believe the CSE technique offers particular benefits in a subgroup of parturients in early labour and that the risk of meningitis has not and probably never will be demonstrated to be due to dural puncture rather than epidural placement itself.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Olufolabi et al. (1999) conducted a letter in early labour. Combined spinal epidural (CSE) technique was evaluated on meningitis. The combined spinal epidural (CSE) technique provides rapid pain relief for women in early labor, while the specific risk of meningitis from dural puncture versus epidural placement remains unclear.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: