Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
During the years 1990-1994, our center tested 652 patients, with a broad range of referral indications, for fragile X syndrome using either cytogenetic analysis alone (Protocol 1) or more recently, a combination of DNA analysis and routine karyotyping (protocol 2). The overall positive rate for fragile X was 3.1% with an incidence of other chromosomal abnormalities (OCAs) of 3.2%. Breakdown of cases using each testing protocol along with percent positives is: [table: see text] Use of Protocol 2 yielded only definitive fragile X results, while more than half of the "positives" using Protocol 1 were equivocal. Historically this has been problematic for both the laboratory and physician since interpretation is often dependent on an equally equivocal clinical picture. Protocol 2 eliminates these diagnostic dilemmas without compromising detection of other chromosomal abnormalities, the incidence of which appears to be unaffected by testing method used. The overall incidence of OCA of 3.2% underscores the value of routine karyotyping in this referral group and likely reflects the phenotypic variability of fragile X and its clinical overlap with other chromosomal abnormalities. We believe that a fragile X testing protocol combining routine karyotyping with definitive molecular technology represents the most cost-effective diagnostic approach to this clinically challenging patient population.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Marini et al. (1997) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: