Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In the Sixth Edition distal clavicle resection (resection arthroplasty of the acromioclavicular joint) results in ratable impairment. However, only a single diagnosis within a region may be rated. Therefore, if another impairing condition is present in the shoulder region, such as impingement syndrome or rotator cuff disease, only that resulting in the greatest causally-related impairment is rated.The rating for distal clavicle resection is based on loss of the distal-most clavicle and hence acromioclavicular joint (ACJ). However, in the setting of an occupational or other compensable injury or illness, causation of the impairment is often an important issue. Typically only impairment causally-related to the injury is rated. Assume for example a lifting injury at work caused a tear in a rotator cuff tendon already attenuated by repetitive impingement on inferiorly projecting spurs from longstanding degenerative arthritis of the ACJ. The rotator cuff tear was repaired, and distal clavicle and osteophytes were excised. However, the ACJ arthritis itself was neither caused nor worsened by the injury. In this example, it would be appropriate to rate impairment due to the rotator cuff tear, and explain that the distal clavicular resection was not rated since the condition was not causally-related to the subject injury.In other claims where the only pathology is ACJ arthritis and distal clavicular resection is performed, causation analysis is again necessary to determine whether the resulting impairment is causally-related to the subject injury or illness. If the arthritis was not caused or permanently worsened by the injury or illness, depending on the jurisdiction it may be appropriate to simply state no impairment resulted there from, or provide a rating for the distal clavicular resection but explain why it is causally unrelated to the injury or illness in question.Acromioclavicular joint arthritis is common, and frequently occurs in conjunction with shoulder impingement and rotator cuff disease, all of which become increasingly more prevalent with age. Resection of the distal clavicle may be performed if the ACJ itself is symptomatic and/or inferiorly projecting marginal osteophyte(s) cause impingement on the underlying rotator cuff tendons.Distal clavicular resection or resection arthroplasty of the ACJ was not listed in the first three editions of the Guides. A rating for this surgery first appeared in the Fourth Edition on page 61in Table 27, Impairment of the Upper Extremity After Arthroplasty of Specific Bones or Joints, and was for “isolated” distal clavicular resection. The Fourth Edition, published in June 1993, was written before arthroscopic shoulder surgery became popular, and when most orthopedic surgeons were using the classic open Mumford technique that removed the distal 2.5 cm of the clavicle. This is a different operation than the current arthroscopic distal clavicular resection that removes a lesser amount of bone, usually at most 1.5 cm.The Sixth Edition approach to the evaluation of impairment from distal clavicle resection is based on Section 15.2, Diagnosis-Based Impairment (6th ed, 387), and Section 15.2e, Shoulder (6th ed, 390). In Table 15-5, Shoulder Regional Grid, the section on Ligament/Bone/Joint (6th ed, 403), for the Diagnosis “Acromioclavicular (AC) joint injury or disease” there is a class 1 rating for “status post distal clavicle resection”. This yields a default rating of 10% upper extremity impairment. The standard adjustments impact the ultimate rating based on functional history, physical examination, and clinical studies. Range of motion impairment for the shoulder can be considered in certain cases, if this results in a greater impairment.Unlike past editions of the Guides, in the Sixth Edition only one methodology or diagnosis-based impairment can be chosen for the final rating of a shoulder injury. For ACJ arthroplasty, this is stated on page 387, right column, paragraph 4:It is usually easy to tell from medical records whether the ACJ surgery was incidental, or primary. If the surgeon's preoperative office notes list a diagnosis of rotator cuff or glenohumeral joint pathology (eg, labrum tear), that is usually the primary diagnosis. Similarly, the primary diagnosis is usually listed as diagnosis #1 on the operative report. By contrast, if the distal clavicular resection was performed for ACJ joint dislocation or arthritis, in the presence of a normal glenohumeral joint and rotator cuff, it is appropriate to rate the impairment for resection of the distal clavicle using the Sixth Edition.In the Fifth Edition, impairment due to distal clavicle resection could be combined with any ratable motion loss. In the Sixth Edition, these methods cannot be combined. The primary or most impairing diagnosis that is causally-related is to be used as the basis for impairment. Causation remains a critical component in rating. The Sixth Edition states:Therefore, in cases which have multiple diagnoses involving the same body region, but different causes, whether injury and/or illness, only those diagnoses specifically related to the claim should be part of the final rating. Pre-existing conditions would not be rated unless aggravated (permanently worsened) by the injury.Questions often arise about the etiology of shoulder symptoms and functional loss; eg, whether there is a causal relationship between an injury and ACJ arthritis, and by extension whether the impairment resulting from distal clavicle resection is compensable.ACJ pathology often presents with persistent shoulder pain, and has a significant role in impingement syndrome. At the time of subacromial decompression this pathology may be managed by distal clavicular resection, beveling of the anterior-inferior acromion (acromioplasty), and/or excision of marginal osteophytes. However, the ratings provided for distal clavicular resection do not apply to the latter two procedures which do not involve the actual resection of the ACJ. Hence acromioplasty and/or cheilectomy (excision of bone spurs from the inferior acromion and/or clavicle) should not be rated as distal clavicular resection. Other rating methodologies should be considered in those cases.It is equally important to differentiate the cause of rotator cuff disease from that of ACJ degeneration. The etiology of rotator cuff tendonopathy is multifactorial including mechanical attrition due to chronic impingement of the rotator cuff between the greater tuberosity and undersurface of the acromion, trauma, poor vascularity, occupation, aging, smoking, genetics, and histologic tendon degeneration.2,3,4,5,6 Mechanical impingement occurs as the rotator cuff contacts the coracoacromial arch with shoulder elevation, particularly in internal rotation.7 The narrowing of the supraspinatus outlet by inferiorly projecting marginal osteophytes from the ACJ has been associated with subacromial impingement.8 Repetitive shoulder motion may result in mechanical attrition of the supraspinatus tendon.Osteoarthritis of the ACJ may be atraumatic or post-traumatic. Age-related ACJ degeneration is well documented, with DePalma demonstrating arthritic changes in all specimens after the fifth decade.9,10,11,12 ACJ arthritis and distal clavicle osteolysis may reflect chronic overuse.13 Repetitive overhead upper extremity activity may cause mechanical wear of the articular cartilage. Fractures of the distal clavicle and AC subluxations or dislocations may cause posttraumatic arthritis of ACJ.Since the Sixth Edition recommends rating the most impairing, causally-related condition in any one body region, and because ACJ arthritis is usually not caused or aggravated by a specific injury, distal clavicular resection is generally not the most appropriate means to rate shoulder impairment. As implied in the aforementioned example, if surgery was performed for a traumatic rotator cuff tear, and the distal clavicle was also resected due to preexisting ACJ arthritis, the latter surgery would not be considered related to the injury and would not be rated. The distal clavicular resection may have been warranted to diminish pain due to ACJ arthritis and/or eliminate the distal clavicle as a source of impingement, but was not necessary for the injury per se, the rotator cuff tear. The impairment in most cases should be based on the rating for a rotator cuff tear or impingement.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Uejo et al. (2009) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: