Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Thin films are materials with an important role in modern science since they give the possibility to engineer materials with specific properties otherwise unreachable by common means. Controlling thickness, growth architecture, morphology and microstructure makes them unreplaceable in many fields [1,2]. Thin films can act as coating against physical or chemical degradation, making them available for application that would prove detrimental to other kind of materials, substituting them or improving their performances[3,4]. We tested three different titanium thin films samples for possible biomedical applications, focusing on how they respond to aggressive environments such as the ones of the human body. To produce them, Glancing Angle Deposition technique (GLAD) was used [5]. This technique allows to obtain complex structures and to control morphology. It works by creating a vapor flux from a target of the selected material towards a substrate, the angle between substrate and target changes the growth dynamics of the thin film. In GLAD a mechanism call atomic shadowing governs growth of the vertical structures, materials reaching the substrate tends to create nucleation islands, that grow due to the way the material reaches the substrate’s surface. The vertical growth of these islands blocks growth of smaller close ones, developing a porous structure with inclination depending on the set deposition angle. Mechanisms such as surface diffusion, shadowing effect and angle between substrate and target allows for structures with different roughness, density or geometry [6,7]. Knowing that thin films grown with zigzag structure work against corrosion, we decided to test three different samples with 1, 2 or 3 zigzags on the same column. Thickness was maintained the same in all samples (1.3 ± 0.1 μm), XRD was used to check the crystal phase, they were tested for corrosion in Ringer solution. GLAD was used in a specifically made DC reactive magnetron sputtering system to produce the samples, glass was used as substrate. The process works by positioning target and the substrate at a set angle and turning the substrate of 180° depending on the amount of zigzag requested. Before the deposition the substrates undergo first ultrasound cleaning, then sputter-cleaning in low pressure plasma cleaner, useful to also induce nano roughness which increases adhesion and surface energy. Thickness of 1.3 ± 0.1 μm was maintained for all samples with a deposition angle of 85°. Three samples were produced, namely Ti1ZZ, Ti2ZZ, Ti3ZZ, associated with 1,2 and 3 zigzags on the vertical structures. To analyse crystallinity Bruker D8 Focus diffractometer with θ–2θ con ration, 0.02° step size at 0.2 seconds counting time with 2θ range from 20° to 80° was used. Corrosion testing was done in an electrochemical cell filled with Ringer Solution to mimic body fluids. Biologic SP-150 potentiostat with EC-Lab® v9.55 software allowed data plotting and analysis. Measurements followed ISO 16773-1–4:2016 normative, with a 10−2 to 105 Hz single sine wave perturbation [8]. XRD analysis shows presence of 101 crystal plane peak in all samples and a small peak of 002 crystal orientation in Ti3ZZ (Fig. 1). The 101 orientation is achieved as a consequence of the complexity of the film deposition. The high oblique angle used for deposition causes specific growth dynamics. Shadowing effects leads to formation of isolated zigzag structures due to the way adatoms reaches the surface. Preferential growth towards the incoming flux is pushed and because columns growing towards it are more likely to catch incoming material empty areas round them start appearing. Because of these conditions and of the low substrate temperature used in GLAD deposition, surface diffusion is less relevant and growth shift to a kinetically dominated process, leading to the 101 crystal orientation. Corrosion resistance was tested with different methods like Open Circuit Potential (OCP) technique, Potentiodynamic polarization and Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS). In OCP all samples present the same curve pattern, increasing the value of corrosion potential with time, this indicates the formation of a very noble and stable oxide layer. While Ti1ZZ and Ti2ZZ seems to stabilize after 1 hour, corrosion potential in Ti3ZZ keeps rising, meaning the oxide layer was still growing even after one hour, see Fig. 2. In Fig. 3 curves of EIS are shown, Fig. 3 (b) shows two distinct frequencies ranges, the high frequencies range (102-105 Hz) is associated with the impedance of the solution. Lower frequencies region (10-2-102 Hz) indicates capacitive behavior, associated with the impedance of the oxide layer, the higher value is reached by Ti1ZZ indicating a passive layer more effective against corrosion. In Fig. 3 (c) at low frequencies (10-2-100 Hz) all samples exhibit low phase angle (-70° to -75°) typical of dense passive layer. Potentiodynamic polarization curves were used for Tafel fit analysis. Since samples were produced in the same conditions, corrosion behavior comes mainly from the geometry of the samples. Table 1 shows that Ti2ZZ sample has the lowest value of corrosion current and corrosion rate, indicating the formation of a more effective passive layer than the other samples. The material behaviour was simulated using RS(CPE1||R1)(CPE2||R2) equivalent circuit, simulating a material made of two layers (Table 2). RS is the resistance of the solution, the two parallels of constant phase element and resistance are associated to a passive more external layer and an inside layer untouched by oxidation. With these results, we can say that corrosion behaviour in our thin films shows the existence of a critical amount of zigzag for anti-corrosion optimization. The relevance of this finding comes from the fact that it demonstrated that it’s not necessary to overcomplicate film’s structure in order to achieve a more effective protection against corrosion. XRD analysis of the three samples showing the various crystal orientation detected Curves of Corrosion potential over time Curves of Nyquist (a), Bode impedance (b), Bode phase (c) of Titanium thin films with different amounts of zigzags Corrosion parameters of Titanium thin films analyzed with Ringer Solution Parameters from equivalent circuit fitting
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bertapelle et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: