Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This lecture is dedicated to the memory of Samuel Pruzansky. Therefore, although the whole day is devoted to hereditary deafness, I will briefly introduce the various sensory systems and take this opportunity to link our research to Samuel Pruzansky's work through the discussion of our recent results on a human hereditary olfactory defect named Kallmann syndrome. Then I will move on to the subject of hereditary deafness and comment on the amazing progress that have been achieved in this field throughout the last decade. I will briefly introduce how the inner ear is working and also provide some background information on human deafness, in clinical terms. Thereafter, I will focus on the following points, the causative genes for deafness that have now been identified, the strategy used in order to clone these various genes, and the preliminary data concerning the cell targets of these defects. Last but not least, as this is of the utmost importance, I will describe our understanding of the pathogenic processes concentrating on our recent insights into the pathogenesis of the Usher syndrome. Like any other animal species, our senses are adapted in order to monitor our environment. As diurnal animals, we have color vision; our hearing is tuned to frequencies of speech. We have olfaction and taste (our two chemical senses), vision, audition, sense of balance, and somatosensitivity. Each sensory system responds to a given type of stimulus. Olfaction enables us to distinguish several thousands of odors at very low concentrations of odorants; the use of taste enables to distinguish only the following five flavors: sour, salty, bitter, sweet flavors, and glutamate; vision enables us to detect a great many variety of shapes and colors; audition enables us to detect wave pressures, with frequencies ranging from 20 Hz to 20 kHz. The auditory system is by far the most sensitive system. The energy threshold detected by auditory sensory cells is only 1% of what can be detected by photoreceptor cells. In terms of inherited defects of the chemical senses, no general inherited ageusia has been reported. A specific well-known one is an ageusia to a bitter substance, phenylthiocarbamide (PTC), which involves a taste receptor and, as a matter of fact, contributed to the identification of this family of receptor genes. Anosmias specific to some odors are under-diagnosed as they do not cause sufficient discomfort to attract medical attention. Eight specific anosmias have been described. In addition, one hereditary general anosmia (i.e., anosmia to all kinds of odors), which is part of Kallmann syndrome, has been reported. Kallmann syndrome is defined by the association of an anosmia with an hypogonadism. In patients, the olfactory bulbs are either absent or underdeveloped. Hypogonadism is due to a deficiency in GnRH, the gonadotropin-releasing hormone. In 1991, we and Andrea Ballabio's group independently cloned the gene underlying the genetic form of the syndrome that is linked to the X chromosome, KAL1 [Bick et al., 1992; del Castillo et al., 1992]. We named the encoded protein, anosmin-1. Subsequently, we showed that anosmin-1 is an extracellular matrix component. Anosmin-1 is present in the developing olfactory bulbs. We recently isolated a second gene, which underlies a dominant form of the syndrome. This is the point where our work is related to that of Samuel Pruzansky. Pruzansky's primary interests were related to developmental defects, especially the craniosynostoses [Pruzansky, 1975]. Several forms of craniosynostosis result from gain-of-function mutations in the genes encoding fibroblast growth factor receptors (FGFR). In particular, a gain-of-function mutation in FGFR1 has been reported to be the cause of craniosynostosis. Interestingly enough, we have recently shown that various loss-of-function mutations in FGFR1 are the cause for a dominant form of Kallmann syndrome (KAL2) [Dode et al., 2003]. Other genes for Kallmann syndrome still remain to be identified. However, the present data, as well as several lines of evidence, suggest that anosmin-1 is involved in FGF-signaling. Firstly, we showed that anosmin-1 binds to the cell surface through a direct interaction with heparan sulfate proteoglycans, and these components are known to be required for the dimerization of the FGF–FGFR complex. Secondly, anosmin-1 and FGFR1 are co-expressed in the rostral forebrain at the earliest stage of olfactory bulb morphogenesis. Moreover, a recent study in the mouse has shown that FGFR1 is required for olfactory bulb evagination from the rostral telencephalon. Finally, in Kallmann syndrome affected patients, occasional symptoms, or abnormalities may be present as well, some of which (e.g., mirror movements, palate anomalies) have been reported both in KAL1 and KAL2 patients. Obviously, the next step is to demonstrate that signaling through FGFR1 is indeed modulated by anosmin-1 and to understand the underlying molecular mechanism. I would now like to draw your attention to several interesting similarities and differences between inherited defects of the visual and auditory systems. Both are largely due to peripheral defects; in other words, they result from the occurrence of defects in the sensory end organ and not within the central sensory pathway. In both systems, genetic defects highly heterogeneous, with more than a 100 loci involved in retinal dystrophies and, certainly also more than a 100 loci involved in isolated deafness. However, in terms of experimental approach, the search for the genes responsible for isolated forms of deafness turned out to be much more difficult than the search for their visual counterparts. Consequently, for a long time, the search for the genes responsible for deafness lagged far behind the search for visual gene defects. This is no longer the case. What prevented the successful identification and cloning of deafness genes? Firstly, the segregation analysis of human deafness genes, which is a prerequisite for cloning the responsible genes, was encountering particular difficulties. Secondly, almost no molecular knowledge concerning the inner ear was available; hence no candidate genes for deafness were available either. This lack of molecular information results from the very small number of each cell type in the inner ear, which is a serious obstacle for molecular analysis. For instance, a mammalian cochlea houses about 3,000 genuine sensory cells, whereas the retina contains a hundred million photoreceptor cells. As a result, numerous molecules involved in the phototransduction process have been identified by a biochemical approach and subsequently, the corresponding genes were shown to be defective in retinitis pigmentosa by a direct mutation screening in the corresponding genes. No similar option existed for deafness genes. Conversely, we assumed that the genetic approach, which bypasses the problem of low abundance, would be particularly appropriate in order to decipher the molecular bases of the development and the functioning of the cochlea. Therefore, we undertook to look for the genes underlying deafness in humans with a twofold aim in mind, a medical one and a fundamental one. Let us now provide background information on the ear and more specifically on the histology and the physiology of the inner ear before proceeding with a brief introduction to deafness. As you are all aware, the receptor to sound, the ear, in mammals, is composed of three compartments: the external ear with the auditory canal and the tympanic membrane, the middle ear with the three ossicles (malleus, incus, and stapes), and the inner ear. The inner ear is filled in with liquids. The inner ear is composed of two sensory organs, the balance organ, the vestibule and the auditory sensory organ, the cochlea, which in humans spirals up in approximately two and a half turns. Abnormality in any of the three compartments of the ear or the auditory pathway can result in deafness. Deafness is called “conductive” when caused by external and/or middle ear abnormalities. Deafness is called “sensorineural” or “perceptive” when it is caused by abnormalities of the inner ear and/or the auditory pathway. Sound waves travel in the auditory canal and induce the vibration of the tympanic membrane. These vibrations are transferred to the three ossicles and the last ossicle, the stapes, induces vibrations in the liquids of the inner ear. The bony cavity that houses the inner ear is filled with a liquid, the perilymph. The membranous labyrinth is bathed in perilymph. This membranous labyrinth is filled with another liquid, the endolymph. The endolymph has an unusual ionic composition for an extracellular medium. It is a liquid with a very high potassium concentration (150 mM). The organ of Corti, which is located in the membraneous labyrinth of the cochlea, contains the auditory sensory cells, termed the hair cells, which are fixed to the basilar membrane. There are two types of hair cells, the inner hair cells (IHC) organized in a single row and the outer hair cells (OHC) organized in three rows. Only the IHCs are genuine sensory cells, i.e., they send a nerve impulse to the brain. Let us also consider two other important structures, the tectorial membrane and the stria vascularis. The tectorial membrane is an acellular gel coating the organ of Corti that is involved in the stimulation of the hair cells. The stria vascularis is a specialized epithelium in the lateral wall of the cochlear duct, which has a major role in the ionic homoeostasis of the inner ear. In particular, the stria vascularis secretes potassium into the endolymph that produces the endocochlear potential, i.e., a transepithelial potential difference that contributes to the driving force of the transduction current in the hair cells (see below). Finally, a great variety of nonsensory epithelial cells and several types of fibrocytes are lining the cochlear membranous labyrinth. At the apex of the hair cells, stiff microvilli, the stereocilia, are found which are organized into three and sometimes four rows of increasing length that make up the hair bundle, the mechanoreceptive structure responsible for the perception of sound. Some stereocilia contain more than a thousand actin filaments, hence their stiffness. Electron microscopy analysis has shown that these actin filaments are bridged to the stereociliar plasma membrane by an electron dense material. Within the hair bundle, the stereocilia are connected together by some fibrous links. Some of these links are lateral links that are divided into three subsets according to their position along the stereocilia and their recognition by specific antibodies. In addition, there is an apical link, the tip link, which extends from the tip of a stereocilia to the side of the immediately adjacent tallest stereocilia. Much attention has been devoted to that link. Sound waves induce an up and down motion of the basilar membrane and a radial motion of the tectorial membrane relative to the hair cells, which creates a back and forth movement of the hair bundle. According to the “gating spring” model of mechanotransduction (the conversion of the sound-induced mechanical deflection of the hair bundle into an electric signal, the depolarization of the hair cells), the tip link is thought to be tethered to the mechanotransduction channel. The movement of the hair bundle towards the outside of the cochlea is expected to increase the tension of the tip link, which in turn opens the transduction channel; the potassium of the endolymph flows into the hair cells, leading to their depolarization. Let us now consider human deafness. Deafness is the most frequent sensory defect affecting humans. It can begin at any age with any degree of severity. Its is by the of the hearing defect and the age of In or in than or that is to in the a or hearing in hearing and the of of is far that of hearing In particular, major in to forms of hearing to and to to deafness one out of at It an one out of before and of the between and of age due to The deafness forms are divided into two Some forms are with other they into the of deafness. The in which deafness is the are termed or The isolated forms of deafness are by far more In the forms are almost of genetic for about one of the deafness at forms of deafness have been and about causative genes have been isolated which are involved in a variety of developmental I will focus on the isolated forms of deafness. These forms can be due not only to genetic but also to as well as and may cause deafness. inherited forms are defects that are in of the forms are In increasing to the role of genetic hearing most is a analysis for the isolated forms of deafness has a of deafness can be due not only to genetic but also to Therefore, hearing due to and genetic may within a isolated deafness is a highly with more than a 100 of genes involved for the identification of a causative in most of the only be on the analysis of a single to a Finally, the most point is the high of between in to the that they the specialized and the high of between hearing from as As a result, several deafness genes in these which be they result in hearing that no clinical to This specific problem was by in that these have been by a small number of a single deafness gene is expected to in the affected to the with our from and we were to to human the two genes responsible for forms of isolated deafness et al., our has been to and Other as and in the the approach up and are out of from in order to the deafness genes, most of the to the cloning we due to the genetic of isolated deafness, for most of causative genes, only candidate gene be and we to a candidate gene We that a of candidate genes for the isolated deafness forms would be the genes, which have a or a in the inner ear. These genes which are to a role in the auditory and, when forms of deafness. this we isolated many genes in the inner ear by This approach has us to several deafness genes. Finally, it is to to the recent of the mouse the cloning of the genes underlying deafness in mouse has now an increasing on the of the human deafness genes. the human and the mouse inner are of or from have hearing defects. of are very identified they also have balance due to The study of mouse which the great to provide in most at information on the underlying to the is in the process of a very it human deafness genes due to the of the mouse and the to a candidate gene, by that the Moreover, the search of genes that the of deafness genes, for is in than in humans. loci for isolated forms of deafness have been reported and a of genes have now been identified to the These genes isolated forms of deafness. has identified the genes responsible for forms of human deafness, the candidate gene approach that we have of the identified genes both a dominant and a form of isolated deafness. In addition, genes both isolated and deafness. Finally, what was the most in the field of human deafness was the of the high in of one specific gene the defect of the gene encoding the we and group in found that mutations in the gene for about half of the of deafness in the et al., et al., on these we the of the defects in isolated of deafness which are much more frequent than This study us to that at two of the of isolated deafness are of genetic the cells of the gene defect have been identified in many genetic forms of deafness. the deafness genes identified, a hair cell four of which are also responsible for Usher syndrome type I that deafness with retinitis These genes four and two which are molecules and four with or two a and a factor For out of these genes, either a or or mouse the gene According to some of these genes the growth of the hair cell stereocilia, some are involved in the and/or in the of the hair bundle. Finally, are involved in the or the of the hair cells. It is in order to of the of the information by this genetic approach, that before this genetic approach was only one been identified in the hair bundle, to that genetic approach, a role in the development and/or the functioning of the hair bundle are the other deafness genes with a known cell two and that are present in the tectorial membrane, the acellular gel the auditory sensory and have been identified as underlying nonsensory cell defects in the inner ear. of these genes, encoding an termed is responsible for both a isolated deafness and a deafness syndrome, i.e., deafness with syndrome may for about of the deafness A defect is also frequent in isolated deafness it be involved in of the deafness it is that four genes to the i.e., and mouse from the genes, do The four mouse available have been by Finally, there are deafness genes for which the cells of the defect is not known of a variety of and the two are genes that a and a are with four are the of the These form direct between the of adjacent cells. the of molecules than as and or second as are through these by the recent differences in the of by the various have been with a at the ionic as well as at the of their Moreover, the various have modulated by many are or by In the cochlea, cells with into two to which I will to as to the all cells of the with adjacent epithelial cells. This to form at day The other of the cochlea is a to form at It is composed of fibrocytes cells and also some epithelial cells of the stria vascularis. two for the and genes, that we in with in we that there is no developmental of the cochlea either with or with defects. Conversely, the begin to that is day cell in the sensory leading to that the epithelial between the and the Moreover, in the endocochlear potential is no longer also to a defect in the stria vascularis et al., 2003]. the study of the Usher syndrome, I would like to the in which we to progress in the understanding of the pathogenesis of some forms of deafness, and how these deafness genes can provide to understand the development and/or the functioning of the inner ear, in terms of molecular In as a result of a study with and we identified as responsible for Usher syndrome et al., the most clinical a deafness, a and a retinal The gene also is defective in mouse Moreover, in with we have shown that the gene is also defective in a with balance the et al., In mouse as in the hair bundle is highly and the stereocilia to at various the role of in the hair bundle is throughout In the inner ear is only in the sensory hair cells. is present throughout the the stereocilia. is a As all the other with the of it along the actin filaments towards their end The of as that of the other is expected to be tethered to components on which the force by is These components and, on their as well as on of the and their the will from tension to a long as the understanding of the of the identification of the molecules that to is expected to provide Therefore, we out to search and study these the we out five that to the we with a analysis of one of that we termed to be a with several It is an of and at the apical part of the lateral wall of the hair cells, where they and with the cells. However, is not only but also in the stereocilia of the and is at the of the stereocilia, at the of a of the lateral the links that the of the stereocilia. This that either is a of the links or is with these links. This us to that through to is involved in processes and is to between cells and between stereocilia by a tension force at these et al., together with and we isolated the gene underlying another form of and in et al., et al., a These are known as of membrane There are at that are from into three termed according to the of two or three and the of a and a and a The are the and to be present only in the inner ear. and that is defective in another genetic et al., et al., mouse are also a mutation in the is an but it is an unusual of It has a long extracellular with extracellular of the five of the for as the have highly hair on our as to the role of in the processes as well as to the similar of the and we thought that and may be involved in the molecular mechanism. Moreover, to what with the of not a to a that with a that to the actin However, the a for the which is absent from We undertook to out a study of and As as at day these are in the sensory cells. is present throughout the the hair bundle, whereas and are in the hair bundle. both and will be to the tip of the hair bundle. both in the hair bundle. The similar of and was with an interaction of these and we that binds to the of In addition, we also that but not the two other a and binds to the actin Moreover, induces the of the actin all these results suggest that can to the actin filaments as the for the we where is located in mouse defective in In these is absent from the hair bundle and up at the of the stereocilia. The in order to for this is that to the tip of the hair bundle. This that there is an interaction between and We indeed direct interaction between both these binds to the of was that and three Usher type I are form a that is for the of the hair bundle in the hair In the hair bundle, has two and of some molecules at the tip of the stereocilia. According to the we that other gene may also be involved in this recent results to this in with group in we have identified a with a and three defective in another genetic et al., 2003]. is also defective in a mouse the which is also a highly hair bundle. We have shown that binds to Obviously, a to be in order to understand how this of and, in particular, or not some of to to a and how their are In within to the identification of the of genes responsible for forms of isolated deafness will be almost in genetic the next the identification of the genes involved in deafness underlying forms of hearing the genes responsible for the forms as well as encoding involved in the will to these deafness I consider understanding the pathogenesis of forms of deafness as the to in these genes, as to understand the molecular of development and functioning of the cochlea and to provide on the search of at and of the various deafness
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Christine Petit (2004) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: