Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Where Are We Now? Rotator cuff tears are common and increase with age, with up to 80% of patients 90 years of age or older having asymptomatic tears [15]. They can occur as a result of trauma in younger patients or be degenerative in older patients. Most tears are asymptomatic, but asymptomatic tears frequently become symptomatic in 36% to 46% of patients within 3 to 5 years [12, 17]. Additionally, patients 66 years of age and older with symptomatic rotator cuff tears have been demonstrated to have a 50% likelihood of having a contralateral rotator cuff tear, which is often unbeknownst to the patient [22]. Because the incidence and cost of treatment of rotator cuff disease is rising, elucidating risk factors is important. Earlier detection and modification of risk factors may prevent or limit their progression. Previous studies have found that older men, dominant arm involvement, trauma, heavy labor, acromial impingement, and genetics are risk factors for rotator cuff tears [23]. However, these studies were limited in sample size and evaluated relatively specific subpopulations. Other studies have reported conflicting results as to which factors are associated with rotator cuff tears [18]. A greater critical shoulder angle (CSA; > 30°-35°) has been shown to result in greater shear force, which may increase supraspinatus workload [6], but studies have both supported [16, 24] and refuted this [2, 3]. Acromial index is another measure that studies have suggested a value over 0.6 to 0.7 can result in progression due to greater ascending force in the subacromial space during abduction [1], but this has also been refuted [10]. Excessive glenoid retroversion has been reported as a risk factor for full-thickness and degenerative rotator cuff tears due to increased shear stress of the supraspinatus, with 2.6° of retroversion being designated as the cutoff in one study [8], and like the previously mentioned measures, this has been supported [19, 20] and refuted [4, 10]. In the current study, Zhao et al. [25] conducted a meta-analysis of 26 studies evaluating risk factors for symptomatic rotator cuff tears with a total of 9809 patients. Seventeen risk factors were identified, among them older age, greater BMI, smoking, dominant arm involvement, greater height, heavier weight, traumatic events, and hypertension. Greater CSA, greater acromial index, and excessive glenoid retroversion were also associated with tears. From a preventative standpoint, the results show that patients with asymptomatic rotator cuff tears can be counseled in an effort to prevent progression. When I see a patient who I suspect has a rotator cuff tear, is sufficiently impaired, and has any of the aforementioned risk factors, I try to obtain advanced imaging or initiate treatment (whether nonoperative or operative) in the hopes of improving patients’ outcomes and decreasing time to recovery. For patients undergoing rotator cuff repair, preoperative measurement of CSA and acromial index guide my intraoperative decisions because acromioplasty has been shown to decrease both of these values in studies and may lead to lower recurrence [7]. Where Do We Need To Go? Patients presenting for evaluation of asymptomatic tears are rare. If this elusive patient did present to my office, I would counsel that person on the modifiable risk factors (elevated BMI, smoking, and hypertension) in an effort to prevent progression. However, I am still not convinced that this will be effective. But good research leads to more questions than answers. While the shoulder anthropometric findings shed light on shoulder biomechanics, how does adding increased glenoid retroversion as a risk factor impact my treatment options? I will certainly not be performing any glenoid neck osteotomies in an effort to decrease rotator cuff strain, especially since the authors found the difference to be 1.3° between groups. However, the finding that CSA greater than 30° to 35° and acromial index greater than 0.60 to 0.64 increases the risk is something I need to keep an eye on. Studies have supported that these ranges are modifiable with acromioplasty and may prevent recurrence (ie, retear) or improve patient-reported outcomes in patients undergoing rotator cuff repair. Despite this, there continues to be debate over whether CSA and acromial index can be corrected with acromioplasty or whether it improves outcomes, and we should strive to answer these questions in future studies. A better understanding of whether intervening on modifiable risk factors would be beneficial to primary care providers and musculoskeletal specialists alike. While we understand that, for example, smoking is harmful for many reasons, we still don’t know with certainty whether patients should, for example, stop smoking to decrease their risk of developing a symptomatic rotator cuff tear. The same goes for the other modifiable factors identified by Zhao and colleagues [25]. How Do We Get There? With the large number of risk factors identified for symptomatic rotator cuff tears, will this information change our clinical practice? Maybe or maybe not. Unfortunately, a randomized controlled trial of asymptomatic patients with rotator cuff tears that evaluates whether weight loss, smoking cessation, or antihypertensives lead to a decrease in the evolution to symptomatic rotator cuff tears would be nearly impossible to carry out without exhaustive resources. A large retrospective comparative study between patients who attempted to modify these risk factors and those who did not might shed some light on the topic. But are we barking up the wrong tree? For a long time, there has been debate as to whether rotator cuff disease is simply a part of the normal aging process, just like male pattern baldness, thinning or graying hair, and skin wrinkles. We know that up to 80% of patients 90 years of age and older have asymptomatic tears and that the vast majority of these develop from chronic “wear and tear” [15]. To not sound completely nihilistic, I would say that even though I certainly prescribe to the notion that rotator cuff disease is part of normal aging, this doesn’t eliminate the fact that treatment may still me necessary for many of these people who develop symptoms. This can range from nonsurgical care with activity modification to physical therapy to surgery. Although many patients can cope with their rotator cuff disease, some cannot, and therefore, may be indicated for surgery. What about smoking and weight loss? Although there are certainly a multitude of reasons for people to be nonsmokers and ideal weights, we really do not have a clear answer as to whether smoking cessation and weight loss counseling strategies are effective on a provider-to-patient or population level. In a real-world situation, I know that telling my patients that they need to lose weight or quit smoking or risk developing a painful rotator cuff tear and shoulder weakness will be highly ineffective and probably not drive change. Although I believe that the shared decision-making approach should be utilized whenever possible in discussing treatment with patients, requiring patients to lose a certain amount of weight or quit smoking robs patients of autonomy and their ability to decide on their personal risk in the vast majority of scenarios. In the United States, only one out of six adults who have been overweight or obese were able to accomplish long-term weight loss maintenance of at least 10% [13], and the majority of people who attempt smoking cessation fail [21]. What about things that we can potentially change to improve outcomes? A cadaveric study [11] has shown that CSA can be reduced with acromioplasty and lateral acromial resection without harming the deltoid origin. Does this make a difference clinically? Possibly, with two studies showing acromioplasty can decrease the CSA while lowering the risk of retear and increasing abduction strength [1, 5]. However, MacLean et al. [14] found no change in CSA or acromial index after arthroscopic acromioplasty. One study has pointed out a weakness that these studies all likely suffer from, and that is inconsistency in radiographic projections and measurements of CSA. Kaiser et al. [9] found that scapular rotation had a significant impact on CSA, ranging from -6° to 16°. The authors concluded that for accurate comparison of CSA, patients should have identical lateral anteroposterior radiographs, and I hope that future studies use these results to conduct true comparisons of CSA. Future studies would inform surgeons as to whether we can alter a patient’s anatomical risk factors, and if this improves validated patient-reported outcomes, risk of retear, and shoulder abduction strength.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
A 2021 study studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: