Key result
Walking with 1.36 kg hand-held weights at a moderate intensity did not significantly increase energy expenditure during exercise compared to normal walking (5.27 vs 5.44 kcal/min, P=0.103).
Why the study?
Does walking with hand-held weights improve energy expenditure and excess postexercise oxygen consumption in sedentary women?
RCT (n=19)
Open-label
Randomized crossover design
No
Does walking with hand-held weights improve energy expenditure and excess postexercise oxygen consumption in sedentary women?
Absolute Event Rate: 5.27% vs 5.44%
p-value: p=0.103
Walking with 1.36 kg hand-held weights at a constant moderate heart rate intensity does not significantly increase energy expenditure compared to normal walking, but increases perceived exertion and decreases walking speed.
Walking is not only important to assist in performing daily tasks, but also to gain cardiovascular benefits. Further research on walking is needed to examine the physiological responses to improve health and reduce the risks of cardiovascular disease. The purpose of this study was to compare the energy expenditure (EE) during and after walking exercise with versus without hand-held weights (HHW). Nineteen sedentary women (mean standard deviation; age, 21 2.7 years, height, 163.1 6.3 cm; body mass, 66.6 15.1 kg; body fat %, 30.6% 7.43%; body mass index, 25.5 5.7 kg/m 2 ) volunteered walking with versus without 1.36 kg of HHW in two randomized sessions. The study consisted of 30 min of exercise followed b silent sitting for 30 min. The range of motion was set at elbow flexion at 90 while arms were alternated 30.48 cm forward and backward. 1% incline was set for the treadmill grade and speed was controlled to a moderate level of 40%-59% of heart rate reserve. During the 30-min exercise no significant differences were found between the conditions (P> 0.05). The physiological responses were significantly greater directly after exercise compared with baseline as determined from pairwise comparisons collapsed across conditions (P 0.05). Walking with HHW was not substantial enough to raise EE beyond normal walking and led to an increased effort level. Additionally, the moderate intensity of walking was not enough to sustain EE at a surpassing level directly after the exercise.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Campaña et al. (2017) conducted an RCT in Sedentary (n=19). Walking with hand-held weights vs. Walking without hand-held weights was evaluated on Energy expenditure during exercise (kcal/min) (p=0.103). Walking with 1.36 kg hand-held weights at a moderate intensity did not significantly increase energy expenditure during exercise compared to normal walking (5.27 vs 5.44 kcal/min, P=0.103).
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: