Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
HIV-seropositive men (n = 250) from San Francisco and New York city completed a self-administered survey assessing healthcare providers’ delivery of safer-sex messages. One out of four men had never received safer-sex counselling from their healthcare provider. Men at highest risk for transmitting HIV were no more likely to have been counselled than men at lower risk. Physicians should regularly provide tailored safer-sex messages to all HIV-seropositive patients who have entrusted them with their care. Physicians and other healthcare providers have a responsibility to counsel HIV-seropositive patients about the risk of transmitting HIV infection to their sexual partners and about using condoms and other safer-sex practices to reduce this risk [1,2]. Studies have assessed the screening and counselling of patients at increased risk of HIV infection, but little research has specifically focused on HIV-seropositive patients [3]. Although most HIV-seropositive individuals perceive a special responsibility for protecting their sexual partners from HIV infection, a minority engage in sexual practices that can transmit HIV [4–6]. Furthermore, HIV-seropositive individuals who engage in unprotected sex may contract sexually transmitted infections that increase the risk of HIV transmission and can adversely affect their own health [7,8]. We examined findings from cross-sectional surveys (June–November 1997) that included an assessment of healthcare providers’ delivery of safer-sex messages to HIV-seropositive men who have sex with men. Men in San Francisco and New York city were recruited from AIDS service organizations, gay community venues (e.g. gay pride events, gay bars), public sex environments (e.g. sex clubs, outdoor cruising areas), and through friendship referrals. Sampling procedures and other methods are described in more detail elsewhere [9,10]. Before implementation, research activities were approved by institutional review boards at participating universities and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Men were eligible if they self-identified as being HIV-seropositive, had had sex with a man during the previous year, and were aged 18 years or older. These men were invited to complete a face-to-face interview and a self-administered survey. The interview and survey addressed issues about sexual practices, substance use, access to healthcare, adherence to treatment, and mental health. The survey also asked about safer-sex messages delivered by the respondent's healthcare provider: ‘Has your current doctor or healthcare provider ever talked with you about safer-sex?'. A total of 250 men completed the self-administered survey. Of these, we excluded 27 (10.8%) from the present analyses because they did not have a healthcare provider (n = 11) or had invalid data for the question about provider-delivered safer-sex messages (n = 16). The demographic characteristics of participants are shown in Table 1. The age of participants ranged from 20 to 66 years (mean 37.5, SD = 8.2). The time since HIV diagnosis ranged from less than one year to 15 years (mean 6.5 years, SD = 3.9).Table 1: Demographic, clinical care-setting, and sexual risk characteristics of all participants and those whose healthcare provider had counselled them about safer sex. One in four (23.3%) HIV-seropositive men reported that their current healthcare provider had never spoken with them about safer sex. The characteristics of those who received counselling were not measurably different from those who did not (Table 1). In particular, men with detectable viral loads or who had been diagnosed with AIDS were no more likely to report having had a discussion about safer sex with their healthcare provider. In multivariate analyses, the type of healthcare setting was the only measure statistically associated with safer-sex counselling. Men who received medical care in ‘other’ settings (e.g. veteran's facilities, hospitals) were less likely than those who received care in public clinics to report that their provider had spoken with them about safer sex [odds ratio (OR) 0.30, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.10, 0.93]. HIV-seropositive men treated by a private physician or health maintenance organization were also somewhat less likely to have been counselled about safer sex, but this difference did not reach statistical significance (OR 0.55, 95% CI 0.26, 1.14). The potential risk of HIV transmission was not associated with having spoken with a healthcare provider about safer sex. Notably, men who had contracted a sexually transmitted disease (STD) since their HIV diagnosis or who reported unprotected anal sex with a partner whose serostatus was negative or unknown, were not more likely to have been counselled than men not reporting these behaviors. These data indicate that healthcare providers are not consistently talking to HIV-seropositive patients about safer sex. One out of four participants had never received safer-sex counselling from their current healthcare provider. This finding is particularly troubling given that most participants (80%) reported one or more sex partners whose HIV serostatus was negative or unknown, and 37% had recently had unprotected anal sex with a potentially uninfected partner. Furthermore, we found no association between self-reported risk behaviors (i.e. STD diagnosis, unprotected anal sex) and the receipt of safer-sex counselling, suggesting that providers are unaware of, or are choosing to ignore information about patients’ risk of HIV transmission. It is essential that healthcare providers routinely assess the sexual behaviors of all HIV-seropositive patients, and that individualized messages and referrals to HIV prevention services be provided to those who most need it. Special attention should be given to patients with STDs or detectable viral loads, as they may be more infectious than other seropositive patients [11,12]. The setting in which participants received medical care was associated with having received safer-sex counselling. Participants treated in ‘other’ settings (e.g. veteran's facilities, hospitals) were less likely to have been counselled than those treated in public clinics. Those treated in private settings were also somewhat less likely to have been counselled compared with those treated in public clinics, but this difference was not statistically significant. The reason for these differences may be related to the nature of the relationship between the patient and the provider, the number of HIV-seropositive patients seen in these settings, the training and types of providers working in these settings, and individual or environmental barriers to safer-sex counselling (e.g. limited time, insufficient reimbursement for counselling, discomfort in addressing sexual issues) [13,14]. Research and clinical practice have enabled HIV-seropositive individuals to live longer, healthier, and sexually active lives. Physicians play a critical role in counselling these patients about the importance of safer sex. Previous research has shown that physicians can successfully integrate HIV risk assessments and counselling into primary care visits [13,15]. In addition, most patients are comfortable with HIV risk assessments and find counselling helpful [15]. For these reasons, physicians should regularly provide tailored safer-sex messages to the HIV-seropositive patients who have entrusted them with their care. Acknowledgements The authors acknowledge the following collaborators from the Seropositive Urban Men's Study for their contributions: Robert Hays, Colleen Hoff (UCSF); Perry Halkitis (New York University); Robert Remien, Michael Stirratt (Columbia University); Ann O'Leary, David Purcell, James Carey (CDC). Ron Stall, Robin MacGowan, Cynthia Lyles and, Dorothy Sussman (all CDC) provided helpful comments. Andrew D. Margolisa Richard J. Wolitskia Jeffrey T. Parsonsb Cynthia A. Gómezc
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Margolis et al. (2001) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: