Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Mixed-methods study reveals institutional spiritual harm in Black Millennials and Generation Z, indicating organizational governance practices drive church disaffiliation.
This article advances a sociotheological account of spiritual harm in Black Church spaces as institutional governance formation—a structurally embedded set of organizational practices through which sacred institutions regulate identity, discipline desire, and secure communal coherence through the conditional extension and withdrawal of belonging. Drawing on a concurrent embedded mixed-methods dissertation study of African American Millennials and Generation Z (N = 173 survey respondents; 8 semi-structured interviews), the article demonstrates that spiritual harm is organizational and covenantal simultaneously: reproduced through institutional grammar, transmitted across generations, and measurable in the gap between participants’ relationship to Christianity as theological tradition (45.1% reporting “good”) and their relationship to the Black Church as a sacred organization (31.8% reporting “good”). Participants were drawn from the historically Black Protestant tradition—congregationally governed Baptist bodies, episcopally governed Methodist bodies, and connectional Pentecostal and Holiness churches—in the Southern United States. The article frames the Black Church as a cultural institution whose governance logics—inherited from colonial-era Christianity and reproduced through intergenerational cultural transmission—regulate belonging, identity, and bodily expression within one of the most enduring cultural formations in the African American experience. An institutional accountability framework grounded in sociotheological analysis is offered, theorizing covenantal breach as both a sociological legitimacy crisis and a theological failure of sacred obligation. The analysis proceeds from a womanist and endarkened feminist epistemology, which treats the researcher’s institutional location as an analytical asset.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Indhira M. Udofia (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: