Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Theoretical analysis reveals that freeing marked points resolves cycle obstructions in quadratic maps, highlighting how critical constraints collapse rational curves into rigid algebraic sets.
This paper is the fourth ( and I hope the last) autonomous article extracted from the broader developing corpus "Remanent Tomography of Multiplicative Structures by Dynamic Collisions". The preceding articles isolate three complementary mechanisms: multiplier–Galois–Kummer towers, a depth obstruction for collision methods, and the affine holonomy governing the lift from q to q². The present work asks a deliberately simple question: what happens to the last obstruction if the marked point is no longer forced to be the critical point? For the quadratic family x² + c, allowing the marked point to move changes the geometry completely. The main construction is to place that point directly on a fixed point. This immediately turns the fixed-point equation into an explicit parametrisation, while the cycle multiplier becomes a free coordinate. The lifting problem then reduces to a one-dimensional affine return map on the fibre above the cycle. This is the first key proof mechanism: once the multiplier is zero or has odd multiplicative order, the affine lift cannot introduce an even factor into the terminal period. Choosing the multiplier appropriately gives closed-form witnesses for every odd prime; three elementary cases according to q modulo 8 cover all but the small prime q = 5, which is handled separately by a short explicit orbit modulo 25. The more interesting part is not that the free problem is easy, but why the same construction collapses when the marked point is required to be critical. On the full plane of marked quadratic pairs, the locus where the marked point is fixed is a rational curve with q points over the finite field, and the multiplier runs through the whole field. On the critical line, that curve meets the line only at the trivial point. To make the critical orbit reach a fixed point at a later time, one must impose an additional algebraic condition. Here a second proof trick appears. Because the quadratic map is even, the first arrival of the critical orbit at a fixed point must pass through the opposite point one step earlier. This “signed landing gate” converts an orbit-accessibility problem into a single polynomial equation. At depth n its degree is 2ⁿ⁻¹ − 1. The first nontrivial case gives c = −2, recovering exactly the distinguished residue q − 2 and multiplier 4 found in the preceding lift article. At greater depth, however, the free rational curve has been replaced by a finite algebraic set. The reductions of that set are controlled by Frobenius, and the requirement that the multiplier have odd order becomes a splitting/Kummer-type condition rather than an explicit choice of coordinate. This makes the localisation precise. The difficulty is not caused by quadratic degree, by the passage from q to q², or by multiplier arithmetic in themselves. It appears when one free coordinate is lost because the marked point is required to coincide with the critical point. The paper also shows that replacing x² + c by the full family x² + ax + b with marked point 0 does not evade the obstruction: after an affine change of coordinates, this larger family is exactly the same free-marked-point plane in disguise. The result therefore gives a geometric diagnosis of the remaining unicritical difficulty. It identifies not merely a failed method, but the exact codimension-one restriction where an explicit q-point family collapses into finite Frobenius-controlled algebraic data. S.Geffroy 2026
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sylvain Gefffroy (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: