Key result
SimVascular and OpenFOAM produced similar flow rate, pressure, and vorticity results up to 0.25 seconds of simulated time, but wall shear stress values differed significantly.
Why the study?
Computational fluid dynamics provides non-invasive, patient-specific information for cardiovascular diagnosis and treatment, motivating a direct comparison between SimVascular and OpenFOAM blood flow simulations.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
SimVascular and OpenFOAM provide comparable hemodynamic results for early simulation times, but differences in fluid property models and numerical stability highlight the need for careful software selection and validation in patient-specific CFD modeling.
Applications of computational fluid dynamics (CFD) techniques to aid in the diagnosis and treatment of cardiovascular disease have entered the research domain in recent years, due to their ability to provide valuable patient-specific information without risks associated with highly invasive procedures. SimVascular [1] [2] is an open-source software which allows streamlined processing and CFD blood flow analysis of medical imaging data. OpenFOAM [3] is a proven open-source software which allows for versatile modeling of various fluid dynamics phenomena. In this study, both SimVascular and OpenFOAM simulations are set up with identical computational mesh, similar numerical schemes, boundary conditions, and material properties, to model blood flow in the coronary artery of a 10 year old patient with Coarctation of the Aorta (CoA) who underwent end-to-side anastomosis. Difference in the flow fields such as flow rate, pressure, vorticity, and wall shear stress between SimVascular and OpenFOAM are analyzed. Similar results are obtained in both simulations up to a certain model time, before the results become drastically different. Both the similarities and differences are documented and discussed.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Yogeswaran et al. (2021) studied Aortic Coarctation (n=1). OpenFOAM simulation vs. SimVascular simulation was evaluated on Difference in flow fields (flow rate, pressure, vorticity, and wall shear stress). SimVascular and OpenFOAM produced similar flow rate, pressure, and vorticity results up to 0.25 seconds of simulated time, but wall shear stress values differed significantly.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: