Key result
Anxiety-provoking cognitive events produced significant increases in heart rate, whereas relaxing cognitive events produced significant decreases, independent of digital heart rate feedback.
Why the study?
Do cognitive events (anxiety-provoking or relaxing instructions) and biofeedback affect heart rate?
Do cognitive events (anxiety-provoking or relaxing instructions) and biofeedback affect heart rate?
Cognitive events such as anxiety or relaxation can produce significant directional changes in heart rate comparable to biofeedback, accompanied by parallel changes in respiratory rate.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May warrant cognitive strategies for acute HR modulation; leaves open comparative efficacy versus biofeedback in clinical populations.
In Experiment 1, 23 males were given instructions to think about anxiety‐provoking cognitive events (n= 12) or relaxing cognitive events (n= 11) during 20 30‐sec training trials. Significant pretrial‐to‐trial increases in heart rate were noted during anxiety instructions and significant pretrial‐to‐trial decreases in heart rate were detected during relaxation instructions. In Experiment 2,39 males were again given instructions to think about anxiety‐provoking events (n= 19) or relaxing events (n= 20) during 20 30‐sec training trials. In addition, half of the subjects in each of these instructional conditions were given digital heart rate feedback consistent with their instructions (e.g., were reinforced for heart rate increases during anxiety instructions), whereas half of the subjects in each instructional condition were given feedback inconsistent with their instructions (e.g., were reinforced for heart rate decreases during anxiety instructions). As in Experiment 1, significant pretrial‐to‐trial increases in heart rate occurred during anxiety instructions and significant pretrial‐to‐trial decreases in heart rate were noted during relaxation instructions. The type of feedback which subjects received had no effect on the heart rate changes. The heart rate changes in both experiments were generally accompanied by parallel changes in respiratory rate but not by changes in chin muscle tension. It appears that cognitive events can produce increases and decreases in heart rate which are comparable in magnitude to those noted during biofeedback.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
McCanne et al. (1980) studied this question. Anxiety-provoking cognitive events vs. Relaxing cognitive events was evaluated on Changes in heart rate. Anxiety-provoking cognitive events produced significant increases in heart rate, whereas relaxing cognitive events produced significant decreases, independent of digital heart rate feedback.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: