Key result
The long axis in-plane approach for ultrasound-guided internal jugular vein cannulation achieved a 98% success rate, significantly higher than the 77% success rate of the short axis approach.
Why the study?
Although ultrasound guidance is preferred for internal jugular vein cannulation, the optimal real-time 2-dimensional ultrasound approach to improve success, decrease complications, and shorten procedure time remained unclear.
Does the long-axis in-plane (LAX-IP) or oblique-axis in-plane (OAX-IP) approach improve procedural success and reduce complications compared to the short-axis out-of-plane (SAX-OP) approach for ultrasound-guided internal jugular vein cannulation in adult patients?
RCT (n=120)
Computer generated random numbers table
No
Does the long-axis in-plane (LAX-IP) or oblique-axis in-plane (OAX-IP) approach improve procedural success and reduce complications compared to the short-axis out-of-plane (SAX-OP) approach for ultrasound-guided internal jugular vein cannulation in adult patients?
The long-axis in-plane (LAX-IP) approach for ultrasound-guided internal jugular vein cannulation provides higher success rates and fewer complications compared to short-axis and oblique-axis approaches.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Supports preferring long-axis in-plane for IJ cannulation; extends prior data with this RCT comparison.
Background: Ultrasound (USG) guided Internal jugular venous (IJV) cannulation is preferred than traditional approach due to increase in success rate, reduction in time taken and attempts of successful cannulation and less complications. The purpose of our study was to observe and compare three different real time 2-dimensional US-guided approaches and to determine which approach improves rate of successful cannulation, decreases complications along with shorter average time taken for the procedure. Primary outcomes of the study were venous access time, catheterization time and success rate. Secondary outcomes were number of patients requiring second attempt and complications observed. Methods: 120 adult patients were randomly divided into three groups according to real time US guided cannulation done with SAX-OP approach, LAX-IP approach and OAX-IP approach. Parameters like venous access time, catheterization time, number of patients requiring second attempt and complications were noted. Results: Venous access time was shortest in LAX group 21.84±3.67 seconds which was just significant statistically. Catheterization time was shortest in LAX group 241±123 seconds. Cannulation success rate was highest in LAX group 98% and was statistically significant. Patients requiring second attempt was least in LAX group 2.5%. Posterior IJV wall puncture was observed in 10% patients in SAX group and none in LAX and OAX group which was statistically significant. Conclusions: LAX-IP showed better performance in terms of higher cannulation success, lesser average venous access time and catheterization time and lesser complications. On toggling USG probe, both IJV and carotid artery can be differentiated and carotid puncture could be avoided. Hence LAX approach is safer and effective approach.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Mahajan et al. (2021) conducted an RCT in Requirement for internal jugular vein catheterization (n=120). Long axis in plane (LAX-IP) ultrasound-guided approach vs. Short axis out of plane (SAX-OP) and Oblique axis in plane (OAX-IP) approaches was evaluated on Cannulation success rate (p=<0.0001). The long axis in-plane approach for ultrasound-guided internal jugular vein cannulation achieved a 98% success rate, significantly higher than the 77% success rate of the short axis approach.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: