This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
The celebrated Beveridge Report was published in the UK during the Second World War in 1942 and captured a widespread desire for reconstruction or social progress following the wartime privations.1 He identified five giant evils that beset British society: squalor which referred to inadequate housing and environment, ignorance, want – a lack of the means for health subsistence, idleness or unemployment and disease. Following the war, a number of major developments, including the creation of the British National Health Service, attempted to address these evils in what is now commonly referred to as the welfare state. Almost ever since, governments of different political persuasions have been accused of attempting to dismantle the welfare state. What Beveridge and his committee got right was that dislocation and despair had many causes and that societal reconstruction and social progress required concerted action on a number of fronts. While we can argue about the extent of inequities in Australian society, these five ‘giants’ have not been slain, and major reforms in education,2 health3 and other fields are being discussed, and in some cases, implemented. We still rely, perhaps overly so, on committees and groups of formally appointed experts to address social problems, interpret available evidence, recommend policies and sometimes to delay decisions. We hope that evidence will inform action and those actions can in due course be evaluated and reconsidered. One such group has been established led by Simon McKeon. The Strategic Review of Health and Medical Research in Australia is expected to report in late 2012.4 The review group is charged with examining whether Australia's investment in health and medical research is appropriate given the changes in society and its needs and developments in the research sector such as the rise of large research institutes, collaborative national and international research networks, and the development of research from a cottage industry to a multinational enterprise. Consideration of society's needs is an interesting question. Clearly, a cure for cancer would bring huge benefits. Such research objectives catch the public imagination and result in major public, private and philanthropic investments. New discoveries are reported on the nightly news, and we are familiar with the ubiquitous pictures of laboratory staff using pipettes to place unknown substances in test tubes for analysis. Australian society has other concerns including the health disparities suffered by its rural and remote communities, the rise of chronic diseases and the increasing recognition of co-morbid mental and physical disease. Rural and remote populations are ageing, have poor access to specialist and sometimes primary health care services and we have relatively poor health outcomes. To what extent are these needs being met by health and medical research and could the research system be better tuned to address societal requirements? Around 30% of Australians live outside the State capital cities in communities categorised as rural, regional or remote. These residents have poorer health outcomes, and there is little evidence that these disparities are improving. It follows to this writer that these communities are not best served by service models based on metropolitan assumptions. If these disparities are to be addressed, research is needed in the fields of population health and health services research that incorporates an understanding of the importance of context and culture on health. Some of this research will require novel methods drawn from the social sciences, public and population health, health services research and implementation science. It will need to address the issue of small numbers and the challenges of mixed methods and qualitative research as well as the challenge of community participation in research design, conduct, reporting and translation. Research funding will need to adapt to these realities or risk being largely irrelevant to rural Australians. Considerable investment has been made in rural research capacity in the last 20 years, and it is important to build upon these investments. The University Departments of Rural Health have researchers who are resident in most rural and some remote Australian communities. The groups work alone and in collaboration with other rural and remote researchers. While it is helpful to work with ‘missionary’ researchers from metropolitan institutions, an authentic rural and remote research capability is essential to achieving improved health outcomes in rural and remote Australia. The costs of collaboration for rural and remote researchers can be ameliorated by the coming of the National Broadband Network, but for many, that is still some years off. These costs are high and real and require further infrastructural investments. The project-based funding endemic in the research sector does not sit well with the need to research long-term diseases, health behaviour change or system change, and the number of tenured rural health researchers in Australia is very small. To improve rural and remote health outcomes, more attention is needed to build relationships between rural health researchers, policy-makers, clinicians, managers and communities to facilitate evidence-based policy, systems and care. Developments in rural health policy and practice require routine, high-quality and transparent evaluation, and if the old solutions are not working, we need to find new ones. Strategic Review of Health and Medical Research in Australia4 must not restrict itself to metropolitan interests and assumptions and must embrace the needs of rural and remote Australians. Perhaps we could learn from Beveridge and his recognition that social progress is complex. While the giants of squalor, ignorance, want, idleness and disease can dress differently, they have not disappeared. In Australia, rural health research is an important part of the solution.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
David Perkins (2012) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: