Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
"Intersubjectivity and Narrative Technique in Of Mice and Men and 'Johnny Bear'"1 Evan Chaloupka (bio) Though central to the American literary canon and high-school classroom, John Steinbeck's Of Mice and Men (1937) has garnered little sustained attention from disability-studies scholars. Jay Dolmage invokes the novella as an example of the "Kill-or-Cure" myth: Lennie must die since his idiocy cannot be overcome (Disability Rhetoric 34). This character is seemingly a textbook example of "narrative prosthesis,"2 what David T. Mitchell and Sharon L. Snyder describe as "a crutch upon which literary narratives lean for their representational power, disruptive potentiality, and analytical insight"; it paradoxically "recurs … as a potent force that challenges cultural ideals of the 'normal' or 'whole' body" and "operates as the textual obstacle that causes the literary operation of open-endedness to close down or stumble" (49–50, emphasis original). Sally Chivers asserts that the disinterest of disability studies in the novella stems from its "simple moral lesson that leaves little room for complex analysis." For Chivers, Steinbeck is culpable for this failure of his story. Steeped in stereotype and negative imagery, it panders to popular fears about people with cognitive disabilities: Lennie is a child or animal in a man's body, a dilemma that can only mean danger. The complexity of disability, she argues, is "deliberately written out of a representational system leaving a gap that is both social and … aesthetic." Sonya Freeman Loftis further examines the extent to which Steinbeck, in his characterization of Lennie, turns away from his real-life interactions with people with disabilities [End Page 403] toward stereotypes. She reveals that Steinbeck embellished, emphasized, and added traits to his memory of a slow-witted ranch hand whom he met in real life. The worker had a much more rational motive for his crime than does Lennie: he killed his boss for firing his friend (Loftis 66). Lennie, by contrast, kills a woman without intention, his characterization drawing on cultural fears of the volatile, dangerous, and sexually aggressive idiot. Lennie and his real-life inspiration meet different ends as well. The latter is sent to asylum, while the former is killed (66). Patrick McDonagh provides insight into the term "idiocy," noting that over the course of history "the idiot has been transformed into a resilient contrast group" essential to defining the normal, rational person (2). This transformation required the disabled subject to be stripped of other human qualities: "People identified as idiots had to become only idiots, and nothing else. But this process occurred over time … and developed according to the demands of a specific social environment" (2, emphasis original). Throughout this essay, the term "idiocy" refers to the historical construction of cognitive disability during the time in which Steinbeck wrote, whereas "cognitive disability" refers to mental differences generally (cog-native disability works better as a term than "intellectual disability" or "developmental disability" since what inspires Steinbeck's narratives is how disabled characters think and perceive, not how smart or developmentally advanced they are). Where and how might a disability-studies scholar find value in Steinbeck's art and process? Read against other modernist representations of cognitive disability, like Faulkner's rendering of Benjy in The Sound and The Fury (1929), Steinbeck's treatment seems to prohibit the reader's intimate engagement with mental difference. However, Steinbeck's contemporaries would be surprised at the tenor of recent criticism, having found the author to devote too much attention to cognitively disabled characters and not enough to normal ones. Ralph Thompson of The New York Times found Steinbeck's interest in idiocy and its derivatives to be a nuisance. In his review of The Long Valley (1938), he portrays Johnny Bear, the title character of Steinbeck's lesser-known idiot narrative, as "dramatic, but hardly scrupulous": "I for one pray that Mr. Steinbeck will avoid cretins, fools, imbeciles, boobies, idiots, dolts, and particular boneheads in the future. He does better with people who are normal or who can pass for such in a sizeable crowd" (29). In response, Steinbeck quipped, "Mr. Thompson sets [End Page 404] rather a task. How can I? There aren't any more in my books...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Evan Chaloupka (2017) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: