Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Infertility is a growing problem among couples trying to conceive; in the past the female partner was singled out as the primary reason for being unable to bear a child. Research now reveals that male infertility may contribute in up to two thirds of all couples who seek treatment for infertility. For many years a conventional semen analysis (concentration, motility, and morphology) was seen as sufficient to diagnose male infertility; however, scientific examination must now take into account 2 different kinds of DNA that have been proven to contribute to this diagnosis. Nuclear DNA (nDNA), contained in the head of the sperm, is responsible for packaging all of the paternal genetic information that will be needed for the fertilized egg. nDNA can be damaged or compromised via 4 interrelated courses: defective chromatin packaging, apoptosis, oxidative stress, and genetic lesions. Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) is located in the midpiece of the sperm; when coupled with the tail, it is responsible for mobilizing the sperm toward the egg for fertilization. Scientists are only beginning to comprehend the relationship and interaction between these distinct DNA molecules and how they both contribute to male infertility. As the worldwide community continues to expand, an emerging subpopulation of couples has begun experiencing a common problem in making their contribution to the populace. These couples are experiencing a major health crisis, commonly referred to as infertility. Infertility is classically defined as a state in which a couple desiring a child is unable to conceive following 12 months of unprotected intercourse (Seshagiri, 2001). It affects approximately 15% of couples who seek clinical treatment to conceive a child, and recent studies show that the number of infertile couples in the general population is growing (Feng, 2003). In infertile couples, responsibility for the lack of conception is generally divided into thirds, with one third due to male factors, one third due to female factors, and the final third due to overlapping factors from both partners. The cornerstone of the evaluation of the man remains semen analysis. Although it gives some quantitative and qualitative information about the sperm sample, recent insight into the molecular biology and genetics of the sperm cell have demonstrated that morphology and motility alone are not the only grounds upon which sperm should be evaluated. Commonly overlooked is the fact that sperm carry 2 different kinds of DNA. The nDNA, commonly called the genome, is located in the head of the sperm. The second DNA type is called the mtDNA and is responsible for delivering the sperm to the egg by providing ATP for cellular acceleration. Both types of DNA work toward the common goal of fertilization, but each is susceptible to a myriad of factors that could derail the fertilization process. Imperfections in both types of DNA contribute equally to the problem at hand. This article hopes to elucidate male factor infertility as contributed by both kinds of DNA. nDNA in somatic cell nuclei is packaged into structures called nucleosomes. These structures consist of a protein core formed by an octamer of histones with 2 loops of wrapped DNA. The nucleosomes are then further coiled into regular helixes called solenoids, which increase the volume of the chromatin (Agarwal and Said, 2003). Sperm nuclei, however, need to be packaged much differently and more compactly to assure proper delivery of the nDNA. There are believed to be 4 levels of organization for packaging spermatozoon nDNA (Sakkas et al, 1999; Agarwal and Said, 2003). One level consists of anchoring the chromosomes to the nuclear annulus. In another, DNA loop domains are created as the DNA attaches itself to the newly added nuclear matrix. The arrangement of these loop domains ensures that the DNA can be delivered to the egg in a form that is both physically and chemically accessible to the growing embryo. Chromosome repositioning and organization within the matrix of the sperm head is another level. Condensation of nDNA into tiny, supercoiled doughnuts called toroids by replacing the nuclear histones with structures called protamines completes the levels of chromosomal organization. Human sperm contain 2 types of protamines that are about half the size of typical histones; throughout evolution, they have increased the number of positively charged residues, allowing formation of a highly condensed complex with the negatively charged paternal genomic DNA. Also, the addition of cysteine residues allows the formation of disulfide bonds between adjacent protamine molecules, thereby strongly stabilizing the nucleo-protamine complex (Oliva, 2006). Prior to this re-arrangement, recombination is essential for spermatogenesis to occur (Carrell et al, 2006); as seen in studies using animal knockout models, decreased recombination is associated with diminished spermatogenesis. Many factors (both endogenous and exogenous) can influence this, contributing to male infertility. Scientists agree on 4 distinct methods, although there may be others, by which nDNA can be compromised or damaged: defective sperm chromatin packaging, apoptosis, oxidative stress, and genetic lesions (Agarwal and Said, 2003; Sharma et al, 2004; Lewis and Aitken, 2005; Shafik et al, 2006). The effects of these damaging methods are often found to be interrelated. Chromatin packaging refers to the highly complex and specific structure into which nDNA is folded to properly deliver the genetic information to the egg. Although defects can arise at any of the 4 levels of packaging, the most common problems arise during DNA loop domain formation and histone-protamine replacement. nDNA loop domains can be difficult to arrange without inducing endogenous nicks to the nDNA (Sakkas et al, 1999). It is thought that these nicks exist naturally and serve to relieve torsional stress. The presence of these nicks is greatest during transition from round to elongated spermatids in the testis and occurs before complete protamination within the sperm. Topoisomerase II is the enzyme that creates and ligates the nicks within nDNA during this process (Sakkas et al, 1999; Henkel et al, 2004). Any defect in the enzyme itself will negatively affect the packaging of the genetic information and will contribute to male infertility. The enzyme may leave the nDNA fragmented with single- or double-stranded breaks; this may indicate an early apoptotic process in somatic cells and incomplete sperm maturation in the case of spermatozoa. Topoisomerase inhibitors have been proven to increase the levels of internal nDNA breaks by preventing their repair and increasing their susceptibility to damage (Lewis and Aitken, 2005). Also involved in sperm chromatin packaging is the replacement of histones with protamines. Protamines are major DNA-binding proteins essential for chromatin condensation (Vogt, 2004). During epididymal transport, histones are replaced by transition proteins, only to be replaced by protamines (Oliva, 2006); both intermolecular and intramolecular disulfide cross-linking among the cysteine-rich protamines compresses the DNA into one sixth the volume occupied by somatic cell nDNA (Lewis and Aitken, 2005; Zini and Libman, 2006). This high rate of cross-linking affords the sperm nDNA a measure of protection against exogenous assault and compensates for an impaired DNA-repair capacity. Human spermatozoa retain approximately 15% histones in their structure, leading to a less compact chromatin arrangement than in other mammals (Erenpreiss et al, 2006), perhaps to allow access for oocyte repair mechanisms. Human sperm contain 2 different types of protamines, which are believed to be present in equal amounts in fertile men: P1 and P2 (Carrell et al, 2007). Experiments have shown that the ratio of P1 to P2 is critical to male fertility (Vogt, 2004; Erenpreiss et al, 2006; Oliva, 2006; Carrell et al, 2007), more specifically to the sperm's fertilization ability (Aoki et al, 2006). In addition, recent testing has demonstrated that P2 precursors (pre-P2) are vital in maintaining the delicate P1:P2 ratio. Translation of pre-P2 mRNA appears to cause abnormal head morphogenesis, reduced sperm motility, and male infertility (Tseden et al, 2007). Also, low pre-P2:P2 ratios suggest a link between deficient protamine processing and decreased nDNA integrity (Torregrosa et al, 2006). Apoptosis is the controlled disassembly of a cell from within (Henkel et al, 2004); it is believed to have 2 roles during normal spermatogenesis (Seli et al, 2004; Sharma et al, 2004; Spano et al, 2005). The first role is to limit the germ cell population to numbers that can be supported by the surrounding Sertoli cells. The second is for the depletion of abnormal spermatozoa. As seen in the prior section, abnormal spermatozoa can be produced via defective sperm chromatin packaging, among other ways. In somatic cells, cells that enter into an apoptotic pathway usually have several classical indicators, such as phosphatidylserine (PS) relocation, Fas expression, nDNA strand breaks, and caspase activity. PS relocation is perhaps the earliest indicator of apoptosis; normally located on the inner leaflet of the plasma membrane, PS migrates to the outer membrane once the apoptotic signal has been given (Henkel et al, 2004). To help control this signal, both pro- and anti-apoptotic proteins are present in the testis; they are members of the Bcl-2 family of proteins and provide a signaling pathway that is imperative to maintaining male germ cell homeostasis (Spano et al, 2005). Bcl-2 and Bcl-xL are both prosurvival proteins, while Bax is a pro-apoptotic protein. Disturbing the balance of these proteins from the Bcl-2 family has been demonstrated in mice to contribute to male infertility by disrupting normal apoptosis levels. Fas expression is another indicator that the apoptosis signal has been given. Fas is a type I cell surface protein, belonging to the tumor necrosis/nerve growth factor receptor family (Henkel et al, 2004); it is induced by the binding of Fas ligand to the Fas receptor on the plasma outer membrane. Sertoli cells are known to express Fas ligand, demonstrating the fact that apoptosis is a commonly used mechanism to control the germ cell population at a level that can be supported by the Sertoli cells (Erenpreiss et al, 2006). Ligation of Fas ligand to the Fas receptor triggers activation of cytosolic aspartate-specific proteases, or simply caspases. Once caspase activation has taken place, a signal is transduced to synthesize caspase-activated deoxyribonuclease, which leads to DNA degradation by forming single- and double-stranded breaks within the nDNA (Agarwal and Said, 2003). In infertile men, ejaculated spermatozoa often possess partially degraded nDNA, usually considered to be indicative of the apoptosis pathway; this “escaping” of the apoptosis signal is referred to as “abortive apoptosis” (Sakkas et al, 2002; Lewis and Aitken, 2005; Erenpreiss et al, 2006). The apoptotic pathway is an all or nothing response, meaning that once the signal has been given there is no reversing the process. Abnormalities in this pathway are often attributed to 1 of 2 possibilities: infertile men may not produce enough sperm to trigger Sertoli cell activation to produce Fas, or there may be a problem in activating the Fas-mediated apoptosis signal (Agarwal and Said, 2003). It is believed that if the apoptotic cascade is initiated at the round spermatid phase when transcription is still active, this may be the origin of the nDNA breaks commonly seen in abortive apoptosis in ejaculated spermatozoa. However, nDNA breaks are known to be common during condensation of the genome. It is currently unclear whether these breaks are caused by an apoptotic pathway or simply by incomplete chromatin Also, not all caspase has been shown to be indicative of the apoptotic work has demonstrated that there appears to be some caspase in germ cells that is not associated with apoptosis and may serve a et al, of the apoptotic pathway is are structures at that against preventing from being as nDNA breaks et al, 2006). are usually of that are to a complex of is a that a that In the of are each round of a that could be as an nDNA double-stranded this then be by a genomic mechanism that appears in the spermatid et al, 2006). This is another to an apoptotic response, contributing to the “abortive apoptosis” apoptosis is a that still much scientific to be considered of naturally within the spermatozoa that somatic cell apoptosis, many that this upon spermatozoa is induced by an increase in the of that are present in the the male et al, 2006). Sperm are susceptible to oxidative due to the high of in their as as their of and Aitken, 2005). increased susceptibility is by defective chromatin packaging, further damage to the with are susceptible to this type of damage et al, 2003). are created by into the and et al, 2001). an and protein vital to sperm and (Erenpreiss et al, 2006). to sperm men control the effects of are only when they are produced in of the It is known that the of in semen is are considered to be the most common However, are known to an role as when an is not The origin of these has to be in sperm, but there are many of are from within the sperm The first is of from the et al, 2001). This was of on spermatozoa increased of into the sperm genome. However, further has demonstrated that not have the effects on spermatozoa (Erenpreiss et al, 2006). The second is in sperm. This serve to from to to the It is known that in to contribute to in but it has to be demonstrated in et al, and Aitken, 2005). The third of is the of et al, 2004). is a created from the of by of has been shown to be associated with the and of sperm, their In decreased are known to increase sperm and The mechanism of influence has to be of from the sperm's usually from of the such as that the These possess that are of inducing by male germ cells et al, 2004; and Aitken, 2005). is known to increase levels increased are known to increased levels of spermatid oxidative with infertile This increase is associated with increased (Agarwal and Said, 2005). has been demonstrated in to damage sperm chromatin structure, by oxidative and 1999). on the of in to et al, 2005). These the of the as a upon further lesions are another of which nDNA can influence male infertility; these lesions or within the and may effects from to can be divided into on the type of they present (Vogt, 2004). The first consists of chromosomal and in which of on specific chromosomes have in expression or in their normal genomic The second in which or of in a molecular have in their expression The third is up of defects in which expression of a is or male infertility. These lesions can affect all of the any of the to be involved in male can occur within as as making their difficult to Prior to the second type of DNA found in it is to that nDNA as it to is still an of effects upon the have been as both and paternal effects to be by or a in factors within the sperm chromatin packaging and nDNA damage et al, effects are before the major activation of expression, which at the in paternal effects may sperm nDNA or abnormal chromatin packaging, which can influence the activation of paternal expression et al, 2004). It has been found that there is no between sperm nDNA and the early paternal however, many on the third prior to the when paternal effects can be of this may be at the of to The mtDNA of a sperm is located in the sperm it as a double-stranded DNA of et al, The genetic information by the mtDNA consists of 2 and essential for and oxidative associated with the The most of the sperm is to The itself is of 2 distinct an inner membrane and an outer membrane. The outer membrane is and allows the of molecules the inner membrane is much more The inner membrane is and for the are located on the inner membrane, and the of inner membrane to the membrane which the et al, It is to the between mtDNA and nDNA et al, mtDNA is not the protection or that nDNA is given. there is no protection from histones or DNA-binding proteins within it of this, in mtDNA has the to damage the of the mtDNA a and much more than this the rate found in mtDNA to be to more than that of nDNA. of the increased rate of have been of has been the relationship to sperm motility and in the affect the sperm's ability to synthesize ATP the have been found mtDNA and decreased sperm motility et al, et al, There are distinct that are for the to properly et al, all but complex II are by the complex II is by the nuclear and to the inner membrane of the et al, 2003). in these are considered of mtDNA have been found to into 2 and some to be found in fertile men and may be considered they are usually associated with spermatozoa with low motility et al, et al, et al, et al, however, can be equally as as 2 have been proven to a into the mtDNA and vital proteins to et al, 2003). It is to that no has been found to be indicative of sperm et al, 2001). mtDNA have been to the of infertility that mtDNA with increased et al, while have found that there is no between the two et al, and mtDNA have been that sperm may be to epididymal sperm for in et al, however, recent suggest the et al, 2004; et al, 2006). have been between the of nDNA in with mtDNA Although have only out of a between the 2 types of have been found et al, et al, The number of mtDNA molecules in a spermatozoon is known as mtDNA mtDNA number is controlled by the of transcription factor et al, 2003). have been trying to the specific mtDNA number that is considered normal for fertile men, but have numbers for fertile men from in et al, to in men et al, to in spermatozoa et al, 2003). These are usually attributed to the of analysis used or the of found in the nDNA. however, to on 1 cells possess mtDNA numbers than spermatozoa. nDNA can be associated with any number of male mtDNA is most often attributed to the apoptotic Mitochondrial membrane is a factor that has been used to the for apoptosis et al, There is an the cause and of apoptotic signaling in In other the sperm contribute to the apoptosis, or the increased cause The first is supported by the fact that the is a of that be to the and influence the of et al, 2003). by has been by et al, This a mtDNA cause the to the sperm of inducing an within the as the cellular for ATP the of associated with is This will and with the spermatozoa the apoptotic pathway et al, The that the is supported by the that the of mtDNA damage can be seen before any other of the apoptosis pathway et al, The first of induced by increased levels are seen in the of the membrane et al, In addition, that the of the within the sperm midpiece these structures in to the of increased levels et al, of lack of DNA this that these DNA molecules be the first to be Although both have further is to the cause and It is known that is of origin et al, however, the pathway by which paternal are is still paternal mtDNA within the fertilized egg or oxidative damage to the paternal mtDNA as for mtDNA The most the of the paternal mtDNA et al, 2003). is a process which a is to a protein it for The protein within paternal most commonly believed to be is et al, et al, which is an protein of the inner membrane that is during spermatogenesis as as fertilization. that is by the spermatozoa itself and is for before it the egg. fertilization, the the and the This is further supported by the fact that when is upon spermatozoa there distinct for the protein 1 at the and 2 in the of to the of the protein in for the of the et al, however, the in the of paternal mtDNA et al, 2005). protein known as located in the testis and involved in spermatogenesis has been given due to in a vital complex within the of spermatozoa. are of the outer membrane. is found to be in the midpiece of it to has that is a protein of the complex using and they are known to be for cell and are on the cytosolic of the outer membrane. and expression has been as a of paternal and of from abnormal that to paternal however, these to past the et al, In the that paternal mtDNA is in et al, and 2002; et al, recombination are often attributed to this it is generally more to recombination in before recombination to have there is no treatment for mtDNA have upon in which to sperm with nDNA as as sperm for to The first of treatment of all that are known to be to the of sperm; this and to such as (Agarwal and Said, 2003). This is usually by treatment at 2 months prior to treatment in an to oxidative et al, 2006). of treatment is the of spermatozoa of epididymal sperm. The reason to sperm is to sperm with fragmented nDNA and with mtDNA for with in fertilization and sperm et al, 2006). However, recent the epididymal sperm to be to sperm for et al, 2004; et al, 2006). Also, a can be used to spermatozoa for In this spermatozoa can be by morphology not with normal this high that be seen normal high allowing the to sperm for fertilization and 2007). to sperm nDNA This the on the sperm when it and as as from the Also the can be used to of the It is that the addition of sperm to semen prior to may binding to the sperm surface as as nDNA damage caused by (Agarwal and Said, 2003). in of spermatozoa for to at has been to motility, with the of spermatozoa nDNA breaks et al, 2001). a sperm has been to sperm of chromosomal for with Sperm binding has demonstrated the ability to sperm with without damaging the et al, 2003). One of this in the expression of the protein in of role in levels have indicative of sperm maturation et al, 2005). levels of expression are associated with diminished sperm increased of chromosomal presence of apoptotic and fragmented nDNA. The second involved into account of the and the formation of sperm binding for the of and for the binding of sperm that to membrane are unable to to and will not be in this et al, 2005). are to be reduced between and in sperm with semen sperm et al, 2006), that for normal sperm. of such a for this has The binding has been for testing of sperm motility and fertility et al, 2006). have of in fertilization in demonstrating less than sperm morphology and clinical is needed to that will be to the of spermatozoa that are for in all to This article has that sperm DNA integrity is both and for male The 2 types of DNA to be distinct and packaged however, has demonstrated the of these structures in contributing to male infertility. must to be to between semen analysis and sperm DNA this information remains and in clinical for the and treatment of sperm DNA can be must be to such information into clinical
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Marchesi et al. (2007) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: