Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The rare formation of paragonite in medium-temperature (MT) high-pressure (HP) metabasites (= eclogites) can be easily explained by common geotherms in subduction-zone environments. Paragonite would disappear at pressures close to 20 kbar by a reaction forming kyanite and omphacite. During prograde metamorphic evolution and a geotherm of 6-7°C/km this takes place at temperatures below 500°C. Paragonite in higher-temperature eclogites is typically a retrograde product. According to calculated pseudosections for H2O excess conditions, paragonite should be abundant in MT-HP metapelites (and meta-rhyolites). We have experimentally proven by bracketing the reaction paragonite = kyanite + jadeite + H2O in the P-T range 23.5 to 25.5 kbar and 560 to 710°C that the thermodynamic data of paragonite used for the pseudosections are justified. The rare occurrence of paragonite in MT-HP metapelites, which are frequently indicated by phengites with Si contents > 3.25 p.f.u. (P > 10 kbar in garnet-biotite-bearing assemblages), is due to insufficient H2O in the rock, as again demonstrated by calculated pseudosections. Crustal thickening due to continent-continent collision produces MT-HP metapelites mainly by pressure increase, for instance, starting at mid-crustal levels (~20 km depth, 500°C). Rocks at these levels had been dried out by the previous prograde metamorphic evolution. During subsequent pressure increase, no water is liberated by mineral reactions to produce H2O-excess conditions, and thus no paragonite can form. In turn, lacking paragonite and low paragonite contents of phengite in ordinary MT-HP metapelites are indicators of water-deficient conditions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Massonne et al. (2007) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: