Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Responses to word problems involving rates of change were collected on four occasions during and after 24 hours of concept-based calculus instruction given to a group of first-year university students, all of whom had studied calculus in secondary school.The number of students who could symbolize rates of change in noncomplex situations increased dramatically.However, there was almost no increase in the number who could symbolize rates of change in complex items or in items that required modeling a situation using algebraic variables.Detailed analysis revealed three main categories of error, in all of which variables are treated as symbols to be manipulated rather than as quantities to be related.We surmise that the students had developed an "abstract-apart" concept of a variable rather than the "abstract-general" concept that is needed for the successful study of calculus.Changes in technology, the qualifications of teachers, and the mathematical competence of students have led many to question the role of traditional calculus courses in the curriculum.There is, in particular, much concern about the large numbers of students taking calculus and the rote, manipulative learning that takes place (Cipra, 1988;Steen, 1988;White, 1990).The value of skill-based calculus courses has also come under fire because computers and calculators now perform most (if not all) of the manipulative procedures taught in such courses (Steen, 1988; Tall, 1987a).Several studies (Heid, 1988(Heid, , 1989;; Hickernell & Proskurowski, 1985;Judson, 1990;Palmiter, 1991) have shown how using the computer as a tool for performing the procedures of calculus and algebra can free students to explore applications.Other studies (Hsaio, 1984/85;Tall, 1986) have used graphics to explore secants and tangents to curves in order to build up a sound concept of a derivative.The general tendency is for less emphasis on skills and greater emphasis on underlying concepts.Research into the understanding of calculus has shown a whole spectrum of concepts that cause problems for students.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
White et al. (1996) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: